Got a tip for us? Share it...

Steve Jobs Tried Unsuccessfully to Defuse Patent Dispute with Samsung in 2010


Dow Jones Newswires and Bloomberg report on testimony from Apple patent portfolio manager Chip Lutton as part of the Australian dispute between Apple and Samsung, revealing that Steve Jobs personally initiated contact with Samsung in 2010 in an attempt to head off the conflict before it headed into the courts.
Steve Jobs, founder of Apple Inc. (AAPL), initiated contact with rival Samsung Electronics Co. in July 2010 to try to resolve a patent dispute that has since become a legal battle on four continents, an Australian court was told.

Jobs wasn’t involved once the ultimately unsuccessful talks over the Galaxy smartphone began, Richard Lutton, a senior director at Apple and the company’s patent attorney, told Federal Court in Sydney today.

“Samsung is an important supplier with whom we have a deep relationship,” Lutton testified in response to questioning by Samsung lawyer David Catterns. “We wanted to give them a chance to do the right thing.”
Apple is seeking an injunction against Samsung preventing the sale of the Galaxy Tab 10.1 in Australia. Samsung has agreed to delay the device's launch several times as the injunction is being considered by the court, and today's reports note that Samsung has offered to make some concessions such as eliminating a feature designed to recognize and ignore accidental touch input. The judge in the case has indicated that she plans to offer a decision next week on a preliminary injunction against Samsung, which would remain in effect as a full hearing potentially lasting several months is conducted.

Top Rated Comments

(View all)

22 months ago
Love this Img

Thumb resize.
Rating: 75 Positives
22 months ago

Samsung's cable connector is PDMI, an industry standard. Gives a lot of credibility to that big picture you posted (use timg next time).


And what about the others? Seems like people still don't understand the lawsuit.

It is not about an icon or a PDMI connector. It is about the entire presentation for start to finish.

Next time, check the definition of 'delusion'.
Rating: 31 Positives
22 months ago
It shocks me that Samsung didn't give into Apple's claim of ownership on rectangles.
Rating: 30 Positives
22 months ago
Finally somebody put pictures showing where and in what Samsung is claimed to be copying from Apple. C'mon, even a kid can see that the depicted objects are highly similar!!!
Rating: 22 Positives
22 months ago
Samsung's cable connector is PDMI, an industry standard. Gives a lot of credibility to that big picture you posted (use timg next time).
Rating: 20 Positives
22 months ago
Too bad Samsung tried to killed their golden goose (Apple as customer) by attempting to copy it.
Rating: 19 Positives
22 months ago

This is a generic PDMI cable. Looks like the dock connector isn't it? Unlike Apple's proprietary dock connector, this is based on open standards. The Tab uses this, not Apple's similar Dock connector.
Image (http://lib.shopping.srv.yimg.jp/lib/eleuthera/mpdl-pdmi05bk-1.jpg)


So the use of Apple icons? The identical design of the wall power plug? The packaging? The voice recorder app? The fact the Galaxy Tab 7 looks exactly like a super sized clone of the iPhone 3GS? The latest Galaxy 2 S commercial done in 100% Apple style, including a Richard Dreyfus soundalike?

Just all happy coincidence, right people?

One would have to be blind, dense, or in complete denial not to recognize Samsung's obvious and deliberate intent to copy Apple's products, packaging and marketing for their own benefit.

Samsung = KIRF.
Rating: 18 Positives
22 months ago

This is a generic PDMI cable. Looks like the dock connector isn't it? Unlike Apple's proprietary dock connector, this is based on open standards. The Tab uses this, not Apple's similar Dock connector.
Image (http://lib.shopping.srv.yimg.jp/lib/eleuthera/mpdl-pdmi05bk-1.jpg)


Ok, we get it. Different technology. Surprised you didn't harp on the fact that the Tab's cable is black and Apple's is white.

But do you deny that the overall presentation and packaging of the Tab is nearly identical to the iPad?

I'm pretty sure that was the entire point of the picture comparison.
Rating: 17 Positives
22 months ago

FAIL at the connector part.

The Tab is using the standard PDMI connector.
Read it. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PDMI)


Uh, no.

The electrical connector is entirely different in terms of pin layout. The iPod connector supports different signal types such as FireWire, where the PDMI does not. PDMI supports Displayport USB3 and power transfer, the dock connector does not.

Furthermore, the Samsung Tab isn't even using the proper PDMI standard, just the connector. The pin layout is identical to Apples, just flipped over; pin 1 becomes pin 30.

Interestingly, if you were to plug a Samsung cable into an iPod, you would be shorting the USB power pins together on the host side, as pins 1-2 are grounded in Apple devices, but used for USB power in Samsung ones.

It [PDMI connector] is designed as an alternative to the iPod interface which was used exclusively by Apple Inc


Samsung specifically chose a connector that has little to no industry adoption, for the sole reason that it looks like Apples. There's no other explanation.
Rating: 16 Positives
22 months ago
its not just the connector.

Summarize it up and there is a reason to be pissed with Samsung.
Rating: 16 Positives

[ Read All Comments ]