Samsung Expert Says It Only Owes Apple $40 Million in Patent Case, Not $2 Billion

Monday April 21, 2014 4:02 PM PDT by Jordan Golson
In the ongoing Samsung vs. Apple lawsuit, experts hired by Samsung took the stand on Monday to explain to the jury why Samsung should only pay Apple $38.4 million in damages for infringing on Apple's patents, rather than the $2 billion Apple says it is owed.

apple_samsung_logos
Samsung's paid expert, Judith Chevalier, a professor of economics and finance at the Yale University School of management, said a reasonable royalty on the five patents -- if they were infringed -- would be approximately $1.75 per device, a total of $38.4 million in total damages. Apple had previously argued that it was owed $40 in damages per device.

She also called Apple's patents "very negligible" in value because they were not mentioned as frequently in customer reviews as other features that are not at issue in the case.
Chevalier also pointed to Apple's accounting for each of its annual iOS software updates since 2009, which Apple pegs between "100+" and "200+" new features at each release, and come in at $10 to $25 per device in deferred revenue. Dividing the number of features, Chevalier claimed you could classify these features, on average, as costing 5 to 25 cents per feature.
Following Chevalier's testimony, Samsung rested its defense before starting its own case accusing Apple of infringing on its patents. The trial is expected to conclude and head to jury deliberations sometime next week.

Top Rated Comments

(View all)

7 months ago
Their patents are "negligible" because they weren't mentioned in consumer reviews? This is the criteria that patents supposedly need to meet now? and she teaches at Yale??? Wow.

And if the features were so negligible, then why were they copied?
Rating: 7 Votes
7 months ago
Samsung Expert Says Something That Would Help Keep His Job.
Rating: 5 Votes
27 weeks ago
Considering how much Samsung copied Apple in terms of mobile phones, $2 billion is probably the base of what Samsung owes.
Rating: 5 Votes
7 months ago
Now in select Best Buy stores. Samsung Experts. Samsung, because experts are better than gurus, which are better than geniuses. Buy our **** and have a nice day.
Rating: 4 Votes
27 weeks ago

Samsung Expert Says Something That Would Help Keep His Job.


Now in select Best Buy stores. Samsung Experts. Samsung, because experts are better than gurus, which are better than geniuses. Buy our **** and have a nice day.


She's paid good money to spout the Samsung party line. ;)


There might be a conflict of interest there...

I almost had the same reaction reading "Samsung expert says" as I do when I read "industry analysts predict".


Here - enjoy some deeper reading. As if Apple didn't pay for "expert" witnesses either? :confused::rolleyes:

http://www.macrumors.com/2014/04/08/apple-samsung-2-billion-damages/
Rating: 4 Votes
27 weeks ago

Here - enjoy some deeper reading. As if Apple didn't pay for "expert" witnesses either? :confused::rolleyes:

http://www.macrumors.com/2014/04/08/apple-samsung-2-billion-damages/


whatever man, Apple experts did it out of the goodness of their hearts



or a case of hotpockets
Rating: 4 Votes
27 weeks ago

Here - enjoy some deeper reading. As if Apple didn't pay for "expert" witnesses either? :confused::rolleyes:

http://www.macrumors.com/2014/04/08/apple-samsung-2-billion-damages/


It was a joke. I'm not stupid but thanks for checking.
Rating: 4 Votes
27 weeks ago
Forgive me that I haven't been following this ongoing saga, but it's pretty bad that out the gate you admit you're wrong and immediately concede to fight about how much you were wrong.
Rating: 3 Votes
27 weeks ago

Apparently many here since they claim to know every details about Samsung


You would be first on that list IMO...
Rating: 3 Votes
27 weeks ago
Who grows up hoping to be a "Samsung Expert" ? :confused:
Rating: 3 Votes

[ Read All Comments ]