WSJ: Apple Piloted Running Its Own Subscription Based Primary Healthcare Service With 'Apple Doctors'

In 2016, Apple considered an "audacious" plan to launch its own healthcare service, based on a subscription, with "Apple doctors" at clinics for customers, according to The Wall Street Journal.

apple health keynote
The project, which has since stalled due to internal concerns, was to offer customers an all-encompassing healthcare service that would integrate data collected from the iPhone and Apple Watch. On the project's heels, an internal team studied how data collected from the Apple Watch could improve healthcare service.

One of its most ambitious healthcare ideas was a plan to offer primary-care medicine, conceived in 2016, according to documents and the people familiar with the plan. An Apple team spent months trying to figure out how the flood of health and wellness data collected from users of its smartwatch, first released in 2015, might be used to improve healthcare, the people said.

Apple CEO Tim Cook has said one of Apple's greatest contributions to humanity will be in health, and at one point, its biggest idea of that contribution would be its own healthcare service.

One of its most ambitious healthcare ideas was a plan to offer primary-care medicine, conceived in 2016, according to documents and the people familiar with the plan. An Apple team spent months trying to figure out how the flood of health and wellness data collected from users of its smartwatch, first released in 2015, might be used to improve healthcare, the people said.

The team decided one of the best ways to realize that vision was to provide a medical service of its own, said people familiar with the plan, linking data generated by Apple devices with virtual and in-person care provided by Apple doctors. Apple would offer primary care, but also continuous health monitoring as part of a subscription-based personalized health program, according to these people and the documents.

In 2017, a year after the idea was first conceived, Apple took over health clinics near Apple Park to set up testbeds for the new health service. Dr Sumbul Desai, of Stanford University, manages the project. The testing at those clinics continues to this day, however, they have yet to move past "a preliminary stage."

Dr Desai's project and team have faced pushback from Apple employees. Some employees, including midlevel managers, have been critical of the way Dr Desai's unit "discourages critical feedback," including allegations that the unit provided inaccurate data about the performance of the test clinics, according to The Wall Street Journal.

Employees concerned about the culture pointed to a 2019 meeting during which a midlevel manager raised questions about data, according to people familiar with the meeting and the documents. Dr. Desai responded angrily, leading some present to conclude that critical questions were unwelcome, according to the people and the documents. The manager left Apple weeks later, and the episode contributed to her departure, documents show.

One initiative driven by Dr. Desai's team was an app being tested among Apple employees called HealthHabit. According to the report, it was meant to "connect people with clinicians via chat and encourages them to set health challenges." The app struggled with low downloads and enrollment, with half of the users who had downloaded the app in May not enrolling. The app's struggle has caused concerns over the accuracy of the data being collected.

Data supporting the app's hypertension program has caused new concerns among employees about the integrity of internal data and analysis, some of the people said.

During a presentation for all Apple health employees in March, Mr. Williams praised the clinics' results in treating hypertension and pointed to them as evidence supporting the HealthHabit app's potential, according to people who saw the presentation. He suggested that the company may have wider ambitions for the app if it is successful, they said.

At the same meeting, Apple's COO, Jeff Williams, also reportedly presented data that showed that "91% of patients in Apple's clinics with more severe stage-two hypertension improved to healthier stages or normal." An Apple spokesperson responded, saying that the statistic cited by Williams was for an internal program and not a product.

Apple's idea of launching its own healthcare service has stalled internally, and the company is likely keen on first building up its health infrastructure through more robust and meaningful health features for the Apple Watch, ‌iPhone‌, and various health studies. For example, Apple is reportedly considering and studying ways to include a blood-sugar sensor and temperature sensor in future iterations of the Apple Watch.

Top Rated Comments

dantracht Avatar
24 weeks ago
Gives a whole new meaning to "Apple Care."
Score: 12 Votes (Like | Disagree)
boss.king Avatar
24 weeks ago
I don’t know if I want a Health Genius giving me a check up.
Score: 12 Votes (Like | Disagree)
binarybob Avatar
24 weeks ago
Wow- the old saying, 'An apple a day keeps the machines at bay'
Score: 9 Votes (Like | Disagree)
ChromeAce Avatar
24 weeks ago
As soon as I upgraded to bodyOS 4, my life expectancy meter went down.
Score: 9 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Shanghaichica Avatar
24 weeks ago
I object to this. They shouldn’t be putting their fingers into every pie. It feels a bit intrusive.
Score: 8 Votes (Like | Disagree)
InuNacho Avatar
24 weeks ago
Sounds somewhat similar to the anatomy lessons of the Victorian era where it was discovered that those stricken by poverty had different wear and tear on the body than that of a healthy individual.

Living in one of the less "rich" sides of Silicon Valley, there is definitely a real divide between who can afford an expensive luxury phone + luxury watch and who can't. My neighbor is a hardcore techie with all the latest greatest Apple products and appears to be relatively healthy in appearance, by contrast my landlady on the other hand whom I rent my in-law unit from is less healthy, is of a lower income bracket and occasionally asks me for help with her older Android phone. No chance of biometrics or a watch there.

If this health care plan comes to reality, either it'll be targeted towards the high income brackets with overall healthy tech savvy individuals or it'll stay trapped in the Valley mocked by those without it.
Score: 6 Votes (Like | Disagree)

Related Stories

apple health keynote

Apple's Increasing Focus on Health Seen in Recent Hiring Trends, New Board Member

Thursday November 11, 2021 8:26 am PST by
Apple has been talking for years about the role it wants to play in human health, led by the Apple Watch and its array of health-related features. With the Apple Watch maturing and Apple increasing its integration of health-focused hardware and software, several pieces of evidence suggest the company is positioning itself for an even bigger expansion in that direction. According to trends...
apple watch series 6 blood oxygen monitoring 1

Apple Responds to Report Saying Company's Health Team Has Faced Several Internal Issues

Tuesday October 5, 2021 10:13 am PDT by
Apple CEO Tim Cook has previously stated that Apple's greatest contribution to mankind will be related to health, but Insider's Blake Dodge today reported that the company's health team has faced internal issues and a series of high-level departures. The report, based on conversations with 11 current and former Apple employees and the review of dozens of documents, claims that Apple's health ...
apple health keynote

Report: Apple Scaling Back Internal 'HealthHabit' Project for Employee Health Tracking and Coaching

Thursday August 19, 2021 7:20 am PDT by
Apple is scaling back its work on a critical internal initiative within its health department, possibly presenting a significant setback to the company's long-term health goals, as well as the departure of multiple staff members, according to a report from Business Insider. The initiative in question is an internal app used by employees called "HealthHabit" that allowed them to monitor and...
data driven integration apple health app

BlueJeans Telehealth Adds Support for Syncing Apple Health App Data

Wednesday August 11, 2021 8:01 am PDT by
BlueJeans Telehealth has today announced that it will integrate with Apple's Health app to give more contextual information to healthcare providers. BlueJeans Telehealth is a HIPAA-ready virtual care system that provides a way for healthcare providers to meet with their patients via a video call, integrating with the workflows of clinical teams to replicate the experience of onsite...
apple privacy

Apple Fined $11 Million in Italy for Employing 'Aggressive Methods' in Commercial Use of Private Data

Friday November 26, 2021 2:16 am PST by
Apple and Google were today fined 10 million euros ($11 million) by Italy's Competition Authority for allegedly using user data for commercial purposes without their explicit consent, an apparent violation of Italy's Consumer Code. The authority claims that both Apple and Google utilize user data they collect through their services for promotional and economic activity without the user's...
applewatchs6bloodoxygen2

Apple Watch Series 8 Suppliers Developing Blood Glucose Monitoring Components

Monday October 25, 2021 3:34 am PDT by
Apple's suppliers are currently developing components for next-generation sensors in the Apple Watch Series 8 that will allow users to measure their blood glucose level, according to a new report. According to a paywalled report from DigiTimes, Apple and its suppliers have begun working on short-wavelength infrared sensors, a commonly used sensor type for health devices. The new sensors,...
apple park drone june 2018 2

Apple Employees Expected to Return to Offices in February

Thursday November 18, 2021 10:02 am PST by
Apple employees are expected to begin returning to corporate offices starting on February 1, according to a memo Apple CEO Tim Cook sent out to staff today. The memo, obtained by The Information, says that employees will return under the hybrid work pilot that was announced earlier this year. Starting in February, employees will work at Apple's campuses and offces for one to two days each...
airpods pro black background

Future AirPods Could Monitor Body Temperature and Posture, and Work as a Hearing Aid

Wednesday October 13, 2021 4:21 am PDT by
Apple is developing AirPods with health features, including body temperature and posture monitoring, and the ability to work as a hearing aid, according to The Wall Street Journal. According to documents seen by The Wall Street Journal, prototypes of AirPods with temperature sensors for monitoring a wearer's core body temperature from inside the ear are being developed. The report noted that ...
apple watch 6s 202009

Apple Reportedly Planning Multiple New Apple Watch Health Features, Including Temperature and Blood-Pressure Monitoring

Wednesday September 1, 2021 6:25 am PDT by
Apple is planning to add a raft of new health features to the Apple Watch, including blood-pressure trends, a thermometer for fertility and sleep tracking, sleep apnea detection, and diabetes detection, as well as a number of updates for existing models, according to the Wall Street Journal. Sources who claim to be familiar with Apple's plans and have access to internal company documents...
tim cook apple park

Tim Cook Wants Apple Devices to Be Used for Creativity, Not 'Endless, Mindless Scrolling'

Wednesday October 6, 2021 2:07 am PDT by
In a new interview, Apple CEO Tim Cook said he's worried about the "endless, mindless scrolling" behavior that social media inspires people to undertake and is generally concerned that people are "using technology too much." The interview conducted with Bustle touched heavily on Apple's support of Shine, an app designed to fight social stigmas around mental health issues and is "another...