Australia Considers Case for Opening iPhone NFC Chip to Third Party Payment Systems

Apple on Monday responded to questions from Australia's parliament about its third-party access approach to the NFC chip in its iPhones, following claims that its Apple Pay system is stifling innovation in the contactless payment technology space.

apple pay contactless terminal
The Parliamentary Joint Committee on Corporations and Financial Services heard for-and-against arguments from Apple, Google, and others relating to whether Apple should open up access to its near-field communication (NFC) chip. Australia's big banks have also sought open access to the NFC chip on the iPhone in recent years. However, in a written response to the committee, Apple said it "provides banks with access to NFC functionality on Apple devices" through ‌Apple Pay‌, which is "available to all banks in Australia on fair and non-discriminatory terms."

Apple has developed a technical architecture that comprises hardware and software components and application programming interfaces (APIs) that banks can use to facilitate contactless payments with their cards and mobile banking applications.

Apple chose to call this architecture Apple Pay because: (a) merchants need a simple way to communicate their acceptance of the service to consumers both in store and online, (b) Apple wished to facilitate consumer choice of payment method / bank by providing a consistent and simple experience, and (c) it allowed Apple to market the service to consumers without having to preference one bank over another.

According to ZDNet, Apple cited security as one of the reasons it doesn't support alternatives to ‌Apple Pay‌, comparing it to Google's HCE payment system which it claimed is an inherently less secure system with a worse user experience.

Host Card Emulation (HCE) is a less secure implementation, which was adopted by Android … Apple did not implement HCE because doing so would lead to less security on Apple devices. Google likely selected this implementation because Android software is used in a variety of hardware devices offered from many different companies other than Google, and therefore had to select a software-centric solution, even though it is less secure than a secure element-based implementation.

Apple, which offers a tight integration between the operating system and its own hardware, is able to offer a fully integrated solution that is superior to Android's approach.

In response, Google denied the allegation that it had made a security trade-off in implementing the HCE system.

"Our payments apps are immensely secure … our HCE system, which is used by a very large number of banks all around the world, is audited directly by the banks … we would refute the suggestion our HCE environment is in any way insecure," Google president of partnerships in the EMEA region Diana Layfield told the committee on Monday afternoon. "I would argue the user experience on Google Pay is equal to that of Apple Pay."

The Australian parliamentary committee is still considering the arguments submitted. Elsewhere, the EU is currently considering forcing Apple to open up its NFC payment technology, and earlier this year, Germany passed anti-money laundering legislation that requires Apple to grant payment service providers access to its technical infrastructure.

Top Rated Comments

Porco Avatar
8 weeks ago
As with a lot of this stuff, if Apple were the only smartphone makers I would completely support the involvement of government and/or lawsuits to allow for fair competition. But they’re not, alternatives exist elsewhere and people buy iPhones understanding the choices and consequences (some good, some bad, mostly subjective). That is competition and choice.
Score: 34 Votes (Like | Disagree)
ruka.snow Avatar
8 weeks ago
Not fond of having the NFC chip compromised by any government or third party.
Score: 27 Votes (Like | Disagree)
alba_83 Avatar
8 weeks ago
This makes no sense to me; and I certainly have no sympathy for the banks.

In Australia, we have extremely widespread adoption of NFC/contactless payments. You can literally find yourself in shops that don’t take cash at this stage.

Some of the larger banks like NAB held out on using Apple Pay and now it seems they’re crying foul because it turns out it’s a wildly popular payment method and their own implementations are ridiculous (an NFC ring, anyone? I kid you not).
Score: 19 Votes (Like | Disagree)
nikaru Avatar
8 weeks ago

It took years before the big four Australian banks and Apple could come to an agreement over Apple Pay. Although it’s been up and running for maybe a couple of years now, Apple users in Australia were years behind with the functionality enjoyed by Android users and in many other countries. If these actions lead to a further relaxation over NFC usage and the ability to use Myki mass transit cards with Apple, then it will be a good thing. At the moment, and for several years, Android users have been able to use an electronic Myki card on their phone for trains and trams. iOS users are still waiting for this functionality, with currently no rumours that it will ever be available.
Probably there is a cartel between banks in Australia, because I don't believe that out dozens or even hundred of banks and card issuers, not a single one is able to reach an agreement with Apple over Apple Pay implementation.

The Australian parliament should investigate that, instead of imposing anything on Apple IMO.
Score: 14 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Mac4Mat Avatar
8 weeks ago
If some of these ill informed governments carry on, it will stifle innovation and I don't say that in defence of Apple, but innovation in general.

When a company spends millions/billions developing products, and mindful of security, many customers use that as an indicator reason for their purchase.

If we take everything Apple away from Apple, then where is the motivation for development, for security, etc.

I do wonder sometimes if these government paper pushers have another agenda altogether, i.e. in making technology less secure and less private, to enable more and more intrusion into everyone's lives.

Consumers CHOOSE what to buy, and they know what they are buying. I don't want some government no name fighting a corner in my name, when its not what I want, and not what many customers want.

Now when it comes to taxation, that's a different story....don't let any of the IT behemoths get away with paying negligible taxes, but leave them to develop their products, when governments can in many cases even get a decent computer system up and running in their own governments!
Score: 14 Votes (Like | Disagree)
unsynaps Avatar
8 weeks ago
You know. I always have to look at this stuff in a particular way that makes me go WTF.

You release a product. It's a superior product. Other people try to make same product, but their version is anything from crap to not good enough. They go out of business. Superior product remains unchallenged because they are well a superior product, and no one can seem to make one better.

Monopoly because of their own success. Just sounds stupid to me.
Score: 14 Votes (Like | Disagree)

Top Stories

mir russia apple pay

Apple Pay Now Available for Mir Cardholders in Russia

Tuesday July 20, 2021 12:28 am PDT by
Customers using cards with the Russian payment system "Mir" now have access to using their cards with Apple Pay, the Russian News Agency reports, citing a press release. The Mir payment system is Russia's national payment system, with cards being accepted in 11 countries. The payment system has 270 banks as participants, with 150 banks issuing Mir cards. Apple Pay support came to Mir...
de volksbank logo

Apple Pay Support Coming to Dutch Bank de Volksbank and Its Subsidiaries

Wednesday September 8, 2021 4:25 am PDT by
Dutch bank de Volksbank has said it is bringing Apple Pay support to all its customers soon, including those of its subsidiary banks, reports iCulture. De Volksbank is the parent company of SNS, ASN Bank, and RegioBank, all of which operate in the Netherlands. "Apple Pay will be made possible for the customers of SNS, ASN Bank and RegioBank," a De Volksbank spokesperson told iCulture, adding ...
Apple Pay Feature

Australia Continues to Scrutinize Apple Pay Amid Push for Regulation

Monday August 30, 2021 6:31 am PDT by
The government of Australia is considering creating new laws that could more heavily regulate digital payments systems such as Apple Pay, Google Pay, and WeChat Pay (via Reuters). An Australian government-commissioned report into digital payments systems has made a number of recommendations, one of which suggested actively regulating Apple Pay and other similar digital payments services....
ing belgium apple pay

ING Belgium Announces Support for Apple Pay

Tuesday August 3, 2021 4:01 am PDT by
ING Belgium today announced support for Apple Pay, offering the bank's customers another way to pay using contactless without needing their physical debit card to hand. The 1.4 million customers who do their banking via the ING Banking app will now be able to use their ING cards with Apple Pay to make payments even more easily, said the bank in a press release. "We're constantly looking for ...
apple pay qatar qnb

Apple Pay Launches in Qatar

Tuesday August 17, 2021 2:31 am PDT by
Apple Pay has launched for iPhone, Apple Watch, and Mac users in Qatar, expanding Apple's regional reach for its mobile payment solution, according to a post by the QNB Group (via AppleInsider). Apple Pay in Qatar will first be available with the Dukhan Bank and QNB Group, which calls itself the "largest financial institution in the Middle East and Africa." Other banks in the country can be...
Apple Pay Feature

Survey: Only 6% of U.S. iPhone Users Who Set Up Apple Pay Actually Use It

Tuesday September 7, 2021 8:36 am PDT by
Only six percent of iPhone users in the United States who have Apple Pay set up actually use the feature, according to a detailed study by PYMNTS. Seven years after Apple Pay launched in September 2014, 93.9 percent of consumers with Apple Pay activated on their iPhone do not use it to pay for in-store purchases, meaning that only 6.1 percent do. In 2015, the year following Apple Pay's...
coinbase app mobile

Coinbase Users Can Now Buy Crypto Assets Using Apple Pay

Friday August 6, 2021 1:23 am PDT by
Popular cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase has announced that it is now allowing traders to use bank cards linked to Apple Pay to purchase crypto assets on the platform. "Today, we're introducing new and seamless ways to enable crypto buys with linked debit cards to Apple Pay and Google Pay, and instant cashouts up to $100,000 per transaction available 24/7," said a Coinbase blog post on...
apple pay contactless terminal

Dutch Antitrust Probe Targets Contactless Payments Like Apple Pay

Friday December 4, 2020 12:44 pm PST by
The Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM) today announced an investigation into contactless platforms on smartphones and the access that payment apps have to NFC capabilities. According to the ACM, the software that's on some smartphones "only allows the developer's own payment app to connect to NFC communication," preventing third-party payment apps from also being able to...
hicaps apple wallet support

Major Australian Healthcare Insurance Companies Now Support Apple Wallet

Tuesday July 27, 2021 1:39 am PDT by
A number of the largest healthcare insurance companies in Australia now allow their customers to add their insurance cards to their digital Apple Wallet on their iPhone and Apple Watch, giving healthcare patients ease of access of by using their iPhone and Apple Watch instead of their plastic insurance card. Bupa, Medibank, nib, and GU Health have announced support through electronic payment ...
taiwan railways administration

Taiwan Railways Administration Announces Apple Pay Support for E-Tickets

Monday September 6, 2021 1:21 am PDT by
Taiwan's Railways Administration (TRA) has officially announced support for using Apple Pay when purchasing train tickets with the service's e-booking mobile app. In a press release on its website, the country's railway operator said it was making the new "Apple Pay ticketing service" available from September 7 in order to improve convenience for passengers when booking tickets via the...