New in OS X: Get MacRumors Push Notifications on your Mac

Resubscribe Now Close

Apple Asks Developers to Put 'Sign In With Apple' Above Other Sign-in Options

At its WWDC keynote on Monday, Apple unveiled its new login feature that will allow users to sign into apps and websites using their Apple ID. As part of iOS 13, Apple will require all apps that use third-party sign-in options to include its Sign In With Apple button.


The feature has been largely welcomed as a more secure alternative to similar sign-in services offered by Facebook, Google, and Twitter, since it authenticates the user with Face ID or Touch ID, and doesn't send personal information to app and website developers.

However, one detail in Apple's updated Human Interface Guidelines is raising eyebrows – Apple is asking developers to position its Sign In with Apple button more prominently by putting it above all other rival sign-in options.

The guidelines are regarded as suggestions about how developers should build their apps, rather than mandatory requirements. Even so, many developers believe that following the guidelines gives their apps the best chance of passing Apple's approval process. Curiously, Apple is also asking developers to place its Sign In with Apple button above other options on websites, an area over which it wields no review power.

The suggestions come at a time when developers and rivals have claimed some of Apple's business practices, such as taking up to a 30 percent commission on apps sold through its App Store, are unfair and anticompetitive, and amount to operating the platform as a monopoly.

In the EU, antitrust regulators are looking into claims by Spotify that it is using the App Store to deliberately disadvantage other app developers. Meanwhile in the U.S., the Department of Justice was recently given the go ahead by the Federal Trade Commission to launch a probe into Apple's business practices, as part of a broader review of antitrust concerns in relation to large technology companies.

In an interview yesterday with CBSNews, Apple CEO Tim Cook said that scrutiny of Apple's business practices was "fair" and a good thing for large companies, but claimed the company is not a monopoly in any of the markets it operates in.



Top Rated Comments

(View all)

2 weeks ago

I'm a big fan of 'Sign in with Apple" but making it mandatory for developers who offer existing third-party sign-in options and now requesting they put Apple's sign-in above those others is only inviting further antitrust scrutiny.


Once this rolls out, I will most like not use your app if you don't offer this as an option.
Rating: 35 Votes
2 weeks ago
I'm a big fan of 'Sign in with Apple" but making it mandatory for developers who offer existing third-party sign-in options and now requesting they put Apple's sign-in above those others is only inviting further antitrust scrutiny.
Rating: 17 Votes
2 weeks ago
Apple could just say that "sign-in" list has to be in alphabetical order and they will be fine (like Sign in with Apple, Sign in with Google, Sign in with Facebook, etc.). This, to me, is just asking for trouble.
Rating: 15 Votes
2 weeks ago
Wait, so now we’re all going to sit around and complain about a suggestion.

These forums are hilarious. ;):)o_O
Rating: 12 Votes
2 weeks ago

Once this rolls out, I will most like not use your app if you don't offer this as an option.

As easy as it is to implement the google and Facebook versions of this, there is no reason for a dev not to. Unless, of course, they like the idea of users’ data being spread all over the place.
Rating: 12 Votes
2 weeks ago
Good grief. The big bully telling you what you can and can't do. Oh wait, that's okay, it's Apple.
Rating: 11 Votes
2 weeks ago

Apple could just say that "sign-in" list has to be in alphabetical order and they will be fine (like Sign in with Apple, Sign in with Google, Sign in with Facebook, etc.). This, to me, is just asking for trouble.


The letter "F" comes before "G" ;)
Rating: 10 Votes
2 weeks ago
Most are going to use the Apple one no matter where it is located.
Rating: 10 Votes
2 weeks ago
"Suggestions" my rear-end! We had an app rejected for not following a "suggestion" in the Human Interface Guidelines before.
Rating: 9 Votes
2 weeks ago

Apple could just say that "sign-in" list has to be in alphabetical order and they will be fine (like Sign in with Apple, Sign in with Google, Sign in with Facebook, etc.). This, to me, is just asking for trouble.

Suddenly Google sign in becomes Alphabet's Google.
Rating: 7 Votes

[ Read All Comments ]