Samsung Demands Another Retrial, Says 'No Reasonable Jury' Could Have Sided With Apple - MacRumors
Skip to Content

Samsung Demands Another Retrial, Says 'No Reasonable Jury' Could Have Sided With Apple

Last month, a jury ruled that Samsung must pay Apple $539 million for violating Apple design patents as part of a legal battle that has spanned years, but the jury's ruling apparently won't be the end of the dispute between the two companies.

Samsung last week filed an appeal (via CNET) asking the U.S. District Court in San Jose to either reduce the judgment against it to $28 million or hold a new trial. Samsung filed the motion on the grounds that "no reasonable jury could have found that any of Apple's asserted design patents was applied to Samsung's entire accused smartphones."

applevsamsung
The jury's ruling, says Samsung, is "excessive" and the evidence "supports a verdict of no more than $28.085 million," which was the amount Samsung advocated for during the trial.

The latest Samsung v. Apple trial was held to redetermine the amount of damages Apple had to pay after Samsung appealed to the Supreme Court and said that the original damages award, set at $399 million after several appeals, was a disproportionate sum for the design violation.

During the trial, the jury was tasked with deciding whether the damages should be based on the total value of the iPhone or if Samsung's penalty should be based on just the elements of the iPhone that it copied.

apple v samsung 2011
Apple argued for $1 billion in damages based on the total design of the iPhone, while Samsung argued that it should pay a far lesser amount, the aforementioned $28 million. The jury split the difference and awarded Apple $539 million, which happened to be a far larger penalty than the original $399 million damages ruling from 2015.

When the jury's ruling was announced in May, Samsung promised to appeal in a statement: "Today's decision flies in the face of a unanimous Supreme Court ruling in favor of Samsung on the scope of design patent damages. We will consider all options to obtain an outcome that does not hinder creativity."

Samsung also filed a separate motion at the same time asking the court to order Apple to reimburse it for a $145 million payment that Samsung submitted for a now-invalidated multi-touch patent.

Apple has 10 days to respond to Samsung's new filing, with a hearing scheduled for July 26.

Popular Stories

samsung canada iphone duo ad

Samsung Mocks iPhone Duo Display Cracks in New Ad Campaign

Friday October 30, 2026 10:20 am PDT by
Samsung this week launched an advertising campaign mocking the display issues some people have had with the iPhone Duo. In an Instagram post on its Canadian account, Samsung shared several images showing a bright line through the spot where iPhone Duo models have been experiencing display problems. There are three images, each with different text: Folding is nothing new to us Foldi...
Apple vs DOJ Feature

Apple Pushes Back on DOJ Request for More Evidence

Friday October 23, 2026 9:02 pm PDT by
Apple and the U.S. Department of Justice disagree over how much newer evidence Apple must hand over in their antitrust case, according to a new court filing this week. The two sides previously agreed to a June 20, 2025 cutoff for Apple's records. With the evidence-gathering phase now scheduled to end in late May 2027, lawyers want Apple to supply documents created up to 30 days before that ...
Apple Trade Ins Feature

Apple Adds Samsung Foldables to Trade-In Program

Thursday November 12, 2026 8:43 am PST by
Apple today revised its U.S. trade-in estimates, with increases for many older iPhones, reductions for several Pro models, and newly listed offers for six Samsung foldables. The iPhone 17 Pro has the largest dollar reduction among the affected iPhones, dropping $45 to a maximum of $740. The iPhone 17 Pro Max falls $30 to $855, while the iPhone Air and standard iPhone 17 each gain $30,...

Top Rated Comments

826317 Avatar
110 months ago
Samsung, you had a 132-page PDF document specifically made to show the design team how to copy the iPhone. How could anyone side with Samsung on this?

Link to PDF for those interested: https://www.scribd.com/doc/102317767/Samsung-Relative-Evaluation-Report-on-S1-iPhone#download&from_embed
Score: 111 Votes (Like | Disagree)
110 months ago
The judge should reverse it and make them pay the whole original amount!
Score: 67 Votes (Like | Disagree)
penajmz Avatar
110 months ago
Just pay up Sammy!! Enough!
Score: 64 Votes (Like | Disagree)
fairuz Avatar
110 months ago
Samsung, you had a PDF document specifically made to show the design team how to copy the iPhone. How could anyone side with Samsung on this?
This. Screw Samsung. They've been putting it off for so long that the payment hardly matters at this point. Their phones were blatant knockoffs of the iPhone from its start.
Score: 43 Votes (Like | Disagree)
AngerDanger Avatar
110 months ago
Yeah, Samsung should've been given the opportunity to present a reasonable case. You know, like a trial or something…
Score: 37 Votes (Like | Disagree)
CanadianGuy Avatar
110 months ago
Funny how companies with lots of money can just keep rejecting verdicts until they get one they like. Small companies/individuals don't have that luxury.

Does this just go on forever, if Samsung gets what they want in the next round, does Apple then go crying for a new trial as well?
Score: 30 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Latest Stories
Apple Black Friday Deals Available Now: AirPods, Apple Watches, MacBooks, and More
Apple Black Friday Deals Available Now: AirPods, Apple Watches, MacBooks, and More
1 hour ago
Siri Recap Hands-On: Private, But Not Very Useful
Siri Recap Hands-On: Private, But Not Very Useful
2 hours ago
Save on Headphones This Black Friday With Major Deals on Beats, Sony, Soundcore, and More
Save on Headphones This Black Friday With Major Deals on Beats, Sony, Soundcore, and More
5 hours ago
MacRumors Giveaway: Win a 512GB OLED iPad Mini and a Year of Astropad Workbench
MacRumors Giveaway: Win a 512GB OLED iPad Mini and a Year of Astropad Workbench
6 hours ago
The MacRumors Show: What's Next for iPhone Duo?
The MacRumors Show: What's Next for iPhone Duo?
7 hours ago
Anker's Black Friday Steals: The Lowest Prices Yet on MagSafe Favorites
Anker's Black Friday Steals: The Lowest Prices Yet on MagSafe Favorites
7 hours ago
Microsoft to Retire 'To Do' Apps Next Year
Microsoft to Retire 'To Do' Apps Next Year
8 hours ago
First Look at iPhone Air 2 and iPhone 18 Revealed By Dummy Models
First Look at iPhone Air 2 and iPhone 18 Revealed By Dummy Models
11 hours ago
WhatsApp Raises Group Chat Limit to 1,500 Members
WhatsApp Raises Group Chat Limit to 1,500 Members
11 hours ago
MacBook Pro Black Friday Deals Are Here: Get Up to $250 Off M6 and PROLED XDR
MacBook Pro Black Friday Deals Are Here: Get Up to $250 Off M6 and PROLED XDR
1 day ago
Apple is Building an AI Agent That Can Use Apps and Code
Apple is Building an AI Agent That Can Use Apps and Code
1 day ago
Black Friday Deal: Apple TV Streaming Service for $6.99/Month
Black Friday Deal: Apple TV Streaming Service for $6.99/Month
1 day ago
AirPods Black Friday Deals Hit Pro 3 at $179 and Max 2 at $429
AirPods Black Friday Deals Hit Pro 3 at $179 and Max 2 at $429
1 day ago
Second iOS 27.3 and macOS Golden Gate 27.3 Public Betas Now Available
Second iOS 27.3 and macOS Golden Gate 27.3 Public Betas Now Available
1 day ago
Google's Gemini Can Now Control Apps on Your Mac
Google's Gemini Can Now Control Apps on Your Mac
1 day ago
iPhone Duo vs. Samsung Galaxy Z Fold8: Which is Better?
iPhone Duo vs. Samsung Galaxy Z Fold8: Which is Better?
1 day ago
Apple Executive in Charge of iPhone's Camera App Reportedly Retires
Apple Executive in Charge of iPhone's Camera App Reportedly Retires
1 day ago
Apple Announces 2026 Black Friday Event, Here's What You Can Get
Apple Announces 2026 Black Friday Event, Here's What You Can Get
1 day ago
Sonos Black Friday Sale Takes Up to 25% Off Speakers, Soundbars, and More
Sonos Black Friday Sale Takes Up to 25% Off Speakers, Soundbars, and More
1 day ago
Apple TV to Stream Female 'F1 Academy' Races in U.S. Starting in 2027
Apple TV to Stream Female 'F1 Academy' Races in U.S. Starting in 2027
1 day ago
Tomorrow Marks the End of a 28-Year Era at Apple
Tomorrow Marks the End of a 28-Year Era at Apple
1 day ago
Amazon Takes $200 Off Every Apple Studio Display for Black Friday
Amazon Takes $200 Off Every Apple Studio Display for Black Friday
1 day ago
UK Loses Secrecy Fight Over Apple 'Backdoor' Order
UK Loses Secrecy Fight Over Apple 'Backdoor' Order
1 day ago
Beats 360 Black Friday Deal Arrives With Massive $100 Discount on Amazon
Beats 360 Black Friday Deal Arrives With Massive $100 Discount on Amazon
1 day ago
Apple Music Radio Now Reaches Over 50 Million Monthly Listeners
Apple Music Radio Now Reaches Over 50 Million Monthly Listeners
1 day ago
Future Macs Could Get Brighter, Longer-Lasting OLED Displays in 2030
Future Macs Could Get Brighter, Longer-Lasting OLED Displays in 2030
1 day ago
Apple Faces 'Planned Obsolescence' Trial Over iPhone Repairs
Apple Faces 'Planned Obsolescence' Trial Over iPhone Repairs
1 day ago
Apple May Cancel OLED iMac
Apple May Cancel OLED iMac
2 days ago
Instagram Now Lets You Save Songs to Apple Music
Instagram Now Lets You Save Songs to Apple Music
2 days ago
Apple Releases Safari Technology Preview 257 With Bug Fixes and Performance Improvements
Apple Releases Safari Technology Preview 257 With Bug Fixes and Performance Improvements
2 days ago