Microsoft Surface Beats iPad in Design, Productivity, and Accessory Use in New J.D. Power Study - MacRumors
Skip to Content

Microsoft Surface Beats iPad in Design, Productivity, and Accessory Use in New J.D. Power Study

The Microsoft Surface has been ranked the highest in overall consumer satisfaction, and six points above Apple's iPad in second place, according to J.D. Power's 2017 U.S. Tablet Satisfaction Study. This marks the first top spot win for Microsoft in all six years that J.D. Power has published the Tablet Satisfaction Study, with the company earning a total 855 satisfaction score out of a potential 1,000 points.

The J.D. Power U.S. Tablet Satisfaction Study measures customer satisfaction in the tablet market by looking at five areas: performance (28 percent); ease of operation (22 percent); features (22 percent); styling and design (17 percent); and cost (11 percent). The study accounts for 2,238 tablet owners who have owned their current device for less than one year, with participants being questioned between October and December 2016.

With these rankings, Microsoft has received the designation as "among the best" on the market, while Apple at 849 points is "better than most."

surface vs ipad
According to J.D. Power, Microsoft's win this year "is largely due to its top rankings in the features and styling & design factors." The company earned top marks in categories related to the variety of pre-loaded applications, internet connectivity, and availability of manufacturer-supported accessories. This last category highlights the Surface's versatility, according to consumers, who reportedly "have the highest incidences of accessory use" with Microsoft Surface when compared to competitors.

Specifically, the Microsoft Surface's stylus saw a 48 percent usage rate in comparison to 27 percent of the industry average, while the tablet's add-on keyboard had a 51 percent usage rate in comparison to just a 14 percent industry average. Rounding out the Surface's pros were its variety of input/output ports (like a microSD card slot, USB 3.0, and 3.5mm headphone jack) and amount of internal storage available.

“The Microsoft Surface platform has expanded what tablets can do, and it sets the bar for customer satisfaction,” said Jeff Conklin, vice president of service industries at J.D. Power. “These tablet devices are just as capable as many laptops, yet they can still function as standard tablets. This versatility is central to their appeal and success.”

Microsoft also beat Apple in areas like the size of the tablet, quality of materials used, and attractiveness of tablet design. Microsoft's customers who are using the Surface Pro line of tablets are said to largely be early adopters (51 percent), younger than the customers of its competitors, and "more likely to consider productivity features as important." Microsoft customers tend to list productivity-related tasks as "very important" in comparison to industry average, like emailing, word processing, and banking.

jd power tablet study
Overall, J.D. Power found that customer satisfaction with their tablets is rising, with the study average sitting at 841 and increasing 21 index points from the six-months-ago iteration of the study. Customers are also tending to choose large screens, with satisfaction at 869 points for customers with screens measuring 10 inches or more, 850 points for screens 8-10 inches or more, and 824 for screens less than 8 inches.

More key findings include:

  • Driving the selection process: Lower price and past experience are the most commonly cited reasons for tablet selection among customers (22% each). Reputation is next at 19%.

  • Data plans increase satisfaction: Nearly one-third (32%) of customers have a data plan with their tablet. Overall satisfaction among customers with a data plan is 863 vs. 834 among those without such a plan.

    Apple has moved up and down J.D. Power's Tablet Satisfaction Study throughout the years, earning the top spot on some iterations of the study, while falling back down a few months later in others. Previous first place holders include Amazon and its Fire Tablets, as well as Samsung. When it's on top, Apple has used J.D. Power's ratings in numerous web campaigns in the past.

    Related Roundups: iPad, iPad Pro
    Related Forum: iPad
  • Popular Stories

    ipad peach

    Apple Code Confirms iPad 12 Specs: A19, 8GB RAM, N1, C1X Modem

    Friday September 25, 2026 10:12 am PDT by
    The next low-cost iPad will be equipped with an A19 chip, C1X modem, N1 networking chip, and 8GB RAM, according to details found in Apple's code by MacRumors contributor Aaron Perris. We've heard some of these same specifications in prior rumors, so this is more of a confirmation than a new leak. The iPad 11 has an A16 chip, so the upgrade to the A19 in the 12th-generation iPad will bring a...
    surface laptop ultra

    Microsoft Launches $2,599 Surface Laptop Ultra to Take on MacBook Pro

    Wednesday October 7, 2026 5:45 pm PDT by
    Microsoft today announced launch timing and pricing for the Surface Laptop Ultra that it unveiled earlier this year. The 15-inch Surface Laptop Ultra is priced starting at $2,599, undercutting Apple's $2,999 16-inch MacBook Pro, and it targets the same creator and developer market. Microsoft says it is built for "demanding creative, software development, AI, engineering, and 3D workloads." ...
    new ipad cyber

    New Entry-Level iPad Not Expected Until Early 2027

    Sunday October 11, 2026 8:57 am PDT by
    Apple's next entry-level iPad models, codenamed J581 and J582, will not arrive until early 2027, according to Bloomberg's Mark Gurman. He added that Apple plans a major iPad Air refresh to add an OLED display and a new iPad Pro in 2027. The latter could gain a vapor chamber to improve thermals and performance. A new iPad mini is still expected to arrive at the end of October this...

    Top Rated Comments

    Keniutek Avatar
    125 months ago
    It is better, an awesome little "machine". My wife uses one and she absolutely loves it (and she was a life long apple user). If they fit a better battery in the new one, im getting one myself. Windows is actually not that bad anymore...
    <Ducks for cover>
    Score: 72 Votes (Like | Disagree)
    Ds6778 Avatar
    125 months ago
    Hows that iPad "Pro" Tim? Maybe one more stupid commercial?
    Score: 68 Votes (Like | Disagree)
    Crosscreek Avatar
    125 months ago
    Not surprising. ....it runs a full desktop OS.
    Score: 62 Votes (Like | Disagree)
    rlavelock Avatar
    125 months ago
    This strong competition from Microsoft is great. It should inspire Apple to improve their products. They have had little motivation for too long.
    Score: 60 Votes (Like | Disagree)
    125 months ago
    Well duh!

    The iPad after many years is still just a big iPhone!

    Innovate the iOS then you'll have my $ Apple.
    Score: 43 Votes (Like | Disagree)
    hawkeye_a Avatar
    125 months ago
    But Apple has 'Clips'! /s
    Score: 40 Votes (Like | Disagree)
    Latest Stories
    Verizon Apologizes for iPhone Duo Pre-Order Delays, Giving Customers $100 Gift Card
    Verizon Apologizes for iPhone Duo Pre-Order Delays, Giving Customers $100 Gift Card
    39 minutes ago
    Skip the Touch ID Scan: Unlock iPhone Duo With Apple Watch
    Skip the Touch ID Scan: Unlock iPhone Duo With Apple Watch
    40 minutes ago
    iPhone Duo Fails JerryRigEverything's Dusty Durability Test
    iPhone Duo Fails JerryRigEverything's Dusty Durability Test
    40 minutes ago
    Make iPhone Duo Volume Buttons Follow Screen Rotation
    Make iPhone Duo Volume Buttons Follow Screen Rotation
    3 hours ago
    iPhone Duo Teardowns Reveal Two Batteries and More
    iPhone Duo Teardowns Reveal Two Batteries and More
    4 hours ago
    M5 MacBook Air Returns to Prime Day Low With $200 Amazon Discount
    M5 MacBook Air Returns to Prime Day Low With $200 Amazon Discount
    5 hours ago
    Top Stories: Apple 'Pro and Tell' Debut, iPhone Duo Launch, and More
    Top Stories: Apple 'Pro and Tell' Debut, iPhone Duo Launch, and More
    6 hours ago
    Apple Store Pickup System for iPhone Duo Just Went Live Again in U.S. and Canada
    Apple Store Pickup System for iPhone Duo Just Went Live Again in U.S. and Canada
    7 hours ago
    Apple Closes French Stores Ahead of Further Protests
    Apple Closes French Stores Ahead of Further Protests
    14 hours ago
    Apple Pushes Back on DOJ Request for More Evidence
    Apple Pushes Back on DOJ Request for More Evidence
    15 hours ago
    The iPhone Duo Can Be a Tiny Mac, a Toaster, and a Nintendo DS
    The iPhone Duo Can Be a Tiny Mac, a Toaster, and a Nintendo DS
    20 hours ago
    Using an Apple Pencil With the iPhone Duo: What to Know
    Using an Apple Pencil With the iPhone Duo: What to Know
    22 hours ago
    Apple Store Pickup for iPhone Duo Starting to Resume But Very Limited
    Apple Store Pickup for iPhone Duo Starting to Resume But Very Limited
    23 hours ago
    iPhone Duo Jailbroken on Launch Day
    iPhone Duo Jailbroken on Launch Day
    23 hours ago
    Apple Seeds Updated watchOS 27.2 Release Candidate
    Apple Seeds Updated watchOS 27.2 Release Candidate
    1 day ago
    Apple Store in UK Reopens With New Design on iPhone Duo Launch Day
    Apple Store in UK Reopens With New Design on iPhone Duo Launch Day
    1 day ago
    Crackgate? iPhone Duo Owners Report Screens Breaking Along the Hinge
    Crackgate? iPhone Duo Owners Report Screens Breaking Along the Hinge
    1 day ago
    iPhone Duo Brings Back Long Lines at Apple Stores
    iPhone Duo Brings Back Long Lines at Apple Stores
    1 day ago
    The MacRumors Show: iPhone Duo Arrives, Touchscreen MacBooks Next
    The MacRumors Show: iPhone Duo Arrives, Touchscreen MacBooks Next
    1 day ago
    Apple Released iOS 27.1 for iPhone Duo Only
    Apple Released iOS 27.1 for iPhone Duo Only
    1 day ago
    iPhone Duo: Open Two Apps Side by Side and Lock Them As an App Pair
    iPhone Duo: Open Two Apps Side by Side and Lock Them As an App Pair
    1 day ago
    iPhone Duo Launches With Carrier and Accessory Discounts Available
    iPhone Duo Launches With Carrier and Accessory Discounts Available
    1 day ago
    Apple Music Has a Hidden iPod You Can Play With
    Apple Music Has a Hidden iPod You Can Play With
    1 day ago
    iPhone Duo Says 'Hello' to You Personally
    iPhone Duo Says 'Hello' to You Personally
    1 day ago
    iPhone Duo: How to Skip the Swipe Up After Touch ID
    iPhone Duo: How to Skip the Swipe Up After Touch ID
    1 day ago
    Where to Buy iPhone Duo Today: Stores, Pickup, and Wait Times
    Where to Buy iPhone Duo Today: Stores, Pickup, and Wait Times
    1 day ago
    MacBook Neo Helps Apple Outpace Rivals as Market Declines
    MacBook Neo Helps Apple Outpace Rivals as Market Declines
    2 days ago
    Happy 25th Anniversary, iPod
    Happy 25th Anniversary, iPod
    2 days ago
    iPhone Duo Demand Reportedly Exceeds Apple's Expectations
    iPhone Duo Demand Reportedly Exceeds Apple's Expectations
    2 days ago
    iPhone Duo Launch Begins as First Orders Reach Customers
    iPhone Duo Launch Begins as First Orders Reach Customers
    2 days ago