New in OS X: Get MacRumors Push Notifications on your Mac

Resubscribe Now Close

Consumer Reports Ranks iPhone X Below iPhone 8 Because of Durability and Battery Life

Tuesday December 5, 2017 9:53 am PST by Juli Clover
Consumer Reports today shared its final iPhone X testing results, and while the site has given the iPhone X a recommendation, Apple's new flagship smartphone has been ranked below the iPhone 8 and the iPhone 8 Plus in the Consumer Reports recommended list.

The iPhone X did make the Consumer Reports list of top 10 smartphones in the number 9 slot, but the site says it did not beat out the iPhone 8 or the iPhone 8 Plus because of its poor performance on a durability test. Both the iPhone 8 and the iPhone 8 Plus better survived a tumble test for emulating real-world drops and fumbles of about 2.5 feet that can result in device damage, despite the fact that all three devices have glass bodies.


After 50-100 tumbles, one iPhone X model suffered serious body damage, while two others had screen defects. The iPhone 8 and 8 Plus ended up with just a few scrapes after the test. Front displays for the iPhone X, 8, and 8 Plus all came away unscathed, and the iPhone X did well on scratch tests and water resistance tests.

"If not for the damage in that durability test, the iPhone X would have come in ahead of the iPhone 8 and 8 Plus," says Richard Fisco, head of smartphone testing at CR.
Consumer Reports also had some complaints about the iPhone X battery life, which does not last as long as the battery in Samsung phones like the Galaxy S8. The iPhone X lasted 19.5 hours in the Consumer Reports battery test, compared to 26 hours for the Samsung Galaxy S8 and 21 hours for the iPhone 8 Plus.

The iPhone X didn't fare well on durability or battery tests, but it did earn the highest camera score out of all the smartphones tested by Consumer Reports. The site also listed the OLED display and the Face ID facial recognition system as iPhone X strengths.
The rear camera on the iPhone X is among the best we've ever seen. In fact, if you combine the performance scores for stills and video, this is the highest-rated smartphone camera Consumer Reports has tested.
Overall, Consumer Reports continues to rank the Samsung Galaxy S8 and the Samsung Galaxy S8+ as its top two recommended smartphones, mainly due to superior battery life, followed by the iPhone 8 Plus and the iPhone 8 in spots number three and four. At number nine, the iPhone X is at the bottom of the list, but only a few points separate all of the devices tested.

Related Roundup: iPhone X
Tag: Consumer Reports
[ 209 comments ]


Top Rated Comments

(View all)

Avatar
Gaprofitt
17 months ago

Durability is completely subjective. That's based on how someone treats their device and what type of protection they use. Every iPhone will react differently to a drop based on angle and impact.


Nonsense. Durability can easily be tested..
Rating: 50 Votes
Avatar
Relentless Power
17 months ago
Durability is completely subjective. That's based on how someone treats their device and what type of protection they use. Every iPhone will react differently to a drop based on angle and impact.
Rating: 31 Votes
Avatar
djcerla
17 months ago
Ridiculous.

Battery life is awesome, I go to bed with >50% battery with my normal everyday usage that sinked the 6S+.
Rating: 21 Votes
Avatar
ticlortic
17 months ago
...50-100... drops?!? What are people doing with their phones? Anyone who drops the same object even 10 times probably is in dire need of medical attention....
Rating: 21 Votes
Avatar
theheadguy
17 months ago

Prepare for lots of butthurt posts.

Oh, people have already beat you to the punch. These same people can't stop loving on CR when they give Apple a highest award/rating in any product category. However, if Apple is criticized, even rightly, CR becomes nothing but a worthless rag (even though they still put the X in the top ten category of all smartphones). It's stunning how the comment section has devolved since I first joined MR.

Durability is completely subjective. That's based on how someone treats their device and what type of protection they use. Every iPhone will react differently to a drop based on angle and impact.

sounds like consumer reports is trying to get more views

Consumer Reports has been hating on Apple since antenna-gate. They'll always find a reason to recommend Samsung over Apple. Nothing surprising here. Funny observation - another apologist who didn't read the article didn't notice that the article didn't recommend Samsung over Apple - in fact, they even said the Samsung's glass shell broke during their tests as well. SMH.

Consumer Reports is becoming irrelevant, they needs some news today

Consumer Who?

People still give Consumer Reports attention?

They have been irrelevant for years.

Rating: 18 Votes
Avatar
magpie maniac
17 months ago
Prepare for lots of butthurt posts.
Rating: 16 Votes
Avatar
asdavis10
17 months ago
Consumer Reports has been hating on Apple since antenna-gate. They'll always find a reason to recommend Samsung over Apple. Nothing surprising here.
Rating: 15 Votes
Avatar
Gaprofitt
17 months ago
Not surprising.. Apple isn't all it's cracked up to be..
Rating: 14 Votes
Avatar
Packers1958
17 months ago
Breaking story, glass breaks. News at 11.
Rating: 13 Votes
Avatar
nviz22
17 months ago
If I cared enough about durability, I would use a heavy duty case. If I needed more than my average day of battery life, I would’ve gone with an external battery. I am content with my X!
Rating: 13 Votes

[ Read All Comments ]