Apple Fights Government Demand to Unlock iPhone in New York Drug Case

Following the U.S. Department of Justice's decision to dismiss its lawsuit against Apple after it managed to access the iPhone 5c of San Bernardino shooter Syed Farook, the agency announced its intention to continue on with a similar New York lawsuit where it is attempting to get Apple's help to breach an iPhone 5s used in a drug case.

In a filing this afternoon, Apple again refused to help the DOJ gain access to the device in question and asked the judge to dismiss the lawsuit, claiming the government has not proven that it has exhausted all other means of getting the data. There are specific references made to the San Bernardino case, where the FBI did manage to find another way into the iPhone without involving Apple. Via The Wall Street Journal:

"The government has utterly failed to demonstrate that the requested order is necessary to effectuate the search warrant, including that it exhausted all other avenues for recovering the information it seeks,'' Apple argued in the new filing to U.S. District Judge Margo Brodie. "Before the government demands that Apple do the work of law enforcement, the government must offer evidence that it has performed an 'exhaustive search' and that it remains unable to obtain the data it seeks without Apple's assistance.''

According to Apple, the FBI has not adequately demonstrated that the method it used to gain access to the iPhone 5c used by Syed Farook does not work on the Brooklyn iPhone 5s. Apple also argues the FBI has not proven it has consulted with the third party that helped with the San Bernardino iPhone or other third parties that could provide assistance.

iPhone 5s
In late February, U.S. Magistrate Judge James Orenstein ruled the FBI lacked the legal authority to force Apple to breach the New York iPhone, but the U.S. Justice Department filed a formal appeal in early March in an effort to turn over the ruling, which is what Apple is responding to with today's filing.

In the New York case, which dates back to October 2015, the FBI is aiming to access data on an iPhone 5s belonging to Brooklyn drug dealer Jun Feng. While the FBI employed the help of "professional hackers" to access the iPhone 5c in the California case, FBI Director James Comey has said the method used to gain entry to that device does not work on the iPhone 5s or later.

The iPhone 5s in question is running an earlier version of iOS (iOS 7) that Apple does have the means to access, but Apple is refusing to do so after taking a stronger stance on encryption and customer privacy. While Apple can obtain data from that particular iPhone 5s, it does not have the means to do so on devices running iOS 8 or iOS 9 due to a change in its encryption methods.

Note: Due to the political nature of the discussion regarding this topic, the discussion thread is located in our Politics, Religion, Social Issues forum. All forum members and site visitors are welcome to read and follow the thread, but posting is limited to forum members with at least 100 posts.

Top Rated Comments

zorinlynx Avatar
104 months ago
That's it, folks. The government is going to keep trying and trying and trying until they get their way and set a precedent, or manage to ram laws through and ruin the security of our devices forever.

They've made it clear they want to do this. I just hope we can hold things off for as long as possible.
Score: 10 Votes (Like | Disagree)
nt5672 Avatar
104 months ago
Be glad you've got our government and not one of the others.
And if we don't get pissed and up in arms with the stuff our government does do, then we will turn into the other 2-bit dictatorships.
Score: 7 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Benjamin Frost Avatar
104 months ago
Apple should not need to defend themselves full stop.

It is wrong for any government to break into a phone with Apple's help. I regard any attempt by the US government to do so as criminal and hold them to account. Anyone found guilty of attempting to break into a phone on behalf of the government should be stripped of their duties and imprisoned. They will have a criminal record for the rest of their life.
Score: 7 Votes (Like | Disagree)
KALLT Avatar
104 months ago

According to Apple, the FBI has not adequately demonstrated that the method it used to gain access to the iPhone 5c used by Syed Farook does not work on the Brooklyn iPhone 5s.
Are they trying to get the FBI to disclose the method? :)
Score: 6 Votes (Like | Disagree)
5105973 Avatar
104 months ago
Apple should not need to defend themselves full stop.

It is wrong for any government to break into a phone with Apple's help. I regard any attempt by the US government to do so as criminal and hold them to account. Anyone found guilty of attempting to break into a phone on behalf of the government should be stripped of their duties and imprisoned. They will have a criminal record for the rest of their life.
Seriously. It's almost like the government expects Apple to allocate a whole department of resources just to help law enforcement, to sort of be their personal locksmith. But will they compensate Apple? No. They're just strong arming them.
Score: 5 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Rocketman Avatar
104 months ago
Seriously. It's almost like the government expects Apple to allocate a whole department of resources just to help law enforcement, to sort of be their personal locksmith. But will they compensate Apple? No. They're just strong arming them.
FEDGOV has arbitrary and capricious rulemaking authority with very limited judicial overview. Research my words.

Rocketman
[doublepost=1460770441][/doublepost]The standard of conduct in law is you cannot conscript a person, natural or corporate, to do your bidding even if you pay them a fee, but espicially if you do not. Citizen rights are presumed not bestowed or granted by FEDGOV!!
Score: 4 Votes (Like | Disagree)

Popular Stories

iOS 18 Siri Integrated Feature

iOS 18 Will Add These New Features to Your iPhone

Friday April 12, 2024 11:11 am PDT by
iOS 18 is expected to be the "biggest" update in the iPhone's history. Below, we recap rumored features and changes for the iPhone. iOS 18 is rumored to include new generative AI features for Siri and many apps, and Apple plans to add RCS support to the Messages app for an improved texting experience between iPhones and Android devices. The update is also expected to introduce a more...
iPhone 16 Camera Lozenge 2 Colors

iPhone 16 Plus Rumored to Come in These 7 Colors

Wednesday April 10, 2024 3:52 am PDT by
Apple's iPhone 16 Plus may come in seven colors that either build upon the existing five colors in the standard iPhone 15 lineup or recast them in a new finish, based on a new rumor out of China. According to the Weibo-based leaker Fixed focus digital, Apple's upcoming larger 6.7-inch iPhone 16 Plus model will come in the following colors, compared to the colors currently available for the...
apple silicon feature joeblue

Macs to Get AI-Focused M4 Chips Starting in Late 2024

Thursday April 11, 2024 10:10 am PDT by
Apple will begin updating its Mac lineup with M4 chips in late 2024, according to Bloomberg's Mark Gurman. The M4 chip will be focused on improving performance for artificial intelligence capabilities. Last year, Apple introduced the M3, M3 Pro, and M3 Max chips all at once in October, so it's possible we could see the M4 lineup come during the same time frame. Gurman says that the entire...
top stories 13apr2024

Top Stories: M4 Mac Roadmap Leaked, New iPads in Second Week of May, and More

Saturday April 13, 2024 6:00 am PDT by
Apple's hardware roadmap was in the news this week, with things hopefully firming up for a launch of updated iPad Pro and iPad Air models next month while we look ahead to the other iPad models and a full lineup of M4-based Macs arriving starting later this year. We also heard some fresh rumors about iOS 18, due to be unveiled at WWDC in a couple of months, while we took a look at how things ...
new best buy blue

Best Buy Opens Up Sitewide Sale With Record Low Prices on M3 MacBook Air, iPad, and Much More

Saturday April 13, 2024 7:41 am PDT by
Best Buy this weekend has a big sale on Apple MacBooks and iPads, including new all-time low prices on the M3 MacBook Air, alongside the best prices we've ever seen on MacBook Pro, iPad, and more. Some of these deals require a My Best Buy Plus or My Best Buy Total membership, which start at $49.99/year. In addition to exclusive access to select discounts, you'll get free 2-day shipping, an...