Judge Drops Apple's $533M Fine in iTunes-Related Lawsuit, Sets New Damages Trial - MacRumors
Skip to Content

Judge Drops Apple's $533M Fine in iTunes-Related Lawsuit, Sets New Damages Trial

newitunes122logoThe U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas on Tuesday voided $532.9 million in damages awarded to patent licensing firm Smartflash LLC in February in an iTunes-related patent lawsuit, per Reuters.

The report claims federal judge Rodney Gilstrap has set a new damages trial on September 14 after ruling that "his jury instructions might have 'skewed' jurors' understanding of the damages that Apple should pay."

Apple was initially ordered to pay $532.9 million in damages to Smartflash LLC after a federal jury in the Tyler, Texas courtroom found certain iTunes apps to be infringing upon the company's patents related to digital rights management, data storage and managing access through payment systems.

Apple countered that Smartflash LLC was exploiting the patent system to collect royalties.

“Smartflash makes no products, has no employees, creates no jobs, has no U.S. presence, and is exploiting our patent system to seek royalties for technology Apple invented,” said Kristin Huguet, an Apple spokeswoman. “We refused to pay off this company for the ideas our employees spent years innovating and unfortunately we have been left with no choice but to take this fight up through the court system.”

Smartflash LLC was originally seeking $852 million in damages, and claimed it was entitled to a percentage of sales of Apple products used to access iTunes, such as iPhones, iPads and Macs. Apple argued that $4.5 million was fair at most, claiming it does not infringe upon any of Smartflash LLC's inventions and that its patents are invalid.

Apple likely still faces a fine of a different amount pending the results of the new damages trial scheduled for September, but the iPhone maker plans to appeal the decision.

Related Forum: Mac Apps

Popular Stories

Apple vs DOJ Feature

Apple Pushes Back on DOJ Request for More Evidence

Friday October 23, 2026 9:02 pm PDT by
Apple and the U.S. Department of Justice disagree over how much newer evidence Apple must hand over in their antitrust case, according to a new court filing this week. The two sides previously agreed to a June 20, 2025 cutoff for Apple's records. With the evidence-gathering phase now scheduled to end in late May 2027, lawyers want Apple to supply documents created up to 30 days before that ...
apple park at night 1

Apple Hires Former Meta Lawyer to Oversee Global Litigation

Saturday October 17, 2026 1:21 pm PDT by
Apple has hired former Meta lawyer Scott Tucker to lead its litigation team, according to Bloomberg's Mark Gurman. Tucker will become Apple's vice president of global litigation and financial services, a new position overseeing commercial lawsuits, patent disputes, and legal matters involving its financial products. He previously led litigation at Meta and held a senior legal role at Morgan...
servant tv show

Apple's 'Servant' Copyright Lawsuit Win Upheld on Appeal

Saturday October 24, 2026 9:05 pm PDT by
Apple and M. Night Shyamalan have won an appeal in the copyright dispute over Apple TV series "Servant," with a federal appeals court upholding last year's jury verdict in their favor (via Reuters). In its October 22 decision, the Ninth Circuit rejected filmmaker Francesca Gregorini's arguments that problems with the jury instructions and an unanswered question from jurors warranted...

Top Rated Comments

duffman9000 Avatar
148 months ago
Is this the same "judge" that is leaving NewEgg hanging ('http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/07/after-20-month-delay-a-furious-newegg-still-cant-appeal-2-3m-patent-loss/') on another trial? Sounds like another judge who loves hearing the sound of his own voice.

EDIT: Yup, same creep.
Score: 7 Votes (Like | Disagree)
roland.g Avatar
148 months ago
Eastern Texas patent courts. It's like some sort of cocoon for last century thinking.
Score: 4 Votes (Like | Disagree)
bbeagle Avatar
148 months ago
OH EM GEEE.. Apple could never do wrong, this is just DUMB... pathetic "patent trolls" just wanting a handout. :rollseyes:

Apple does wrong
Patent trolls exist
Both do wrong
Get over it

This judge is an idiot too.
Apple also does a lot right
Maybe you shouldn't label every Apple fan as someone who says Apple does no wrong.
Less than 1% of the zealots here think Apple is God.
A lot more people here think Apple is the anti-christ than think they are God.
Get over it
Score: 3 Votes (Like | Disagree)
bbeagle Avatar
148 months ago
You would need to ask Apple...
Or MOST companies. Almost EVERY company holds many patents they don't use. That's the nature of the beast.

Microsoft and Google hold far more patents than Apple - why aren't you singling them out like you are with Apple?
Score: 2 Votes (Like | Disagree)
148 months ago
These patent trolls need to go on Horders.
Score: 2 Votes (Like | Disagree)
kdarling Avatar
148 months ago
Apple countered that Smartflash LLC was exploiting the patent system to collect royalties.
That's ironic, coming from a company that wanted others to pay them $30-40 a device for their patents on common items like slide to unlock.

And even more ironic, considering that Apple was one of those who spent billions buying up old Nortel patents, and then when they turned out not to be such a good weapon against Android, co-created one of the worst patent troll companies on the planet, Rockstar, which does nothing but employ engineers who probe everyone's code to see who they can sue.

Complete crap. How can you hold patents when you do not make any products that use any of those patents?
Every company has lots of patents they don't use. Often they're gotten simply for self-defense just in case, and are not used offensively.

Apple, OTOH, has sued companies like Samsung using patent claims that Apple themselves do not use.

Apple's lawyers have no moral leg to stand on, complaining about patent exploitation.
Score: 1 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Latest Stories
Apple on Fatal Vehicle Crash Near Apple Park: 'Our Hearts Are Broken'
Apple on Fatal Vehicle Crash Near Apple Park: 'Our Hearts Are Broken'
2 hours ago
Apple Invites App Updated With Two New Features
Apple Invites App Updated With Two New Features
2 hours ago
Google Says Gemini App Rolling Out on Apple CarPlay Starting Today
Google Says Gemini App Rolling Out on Apple CarPlay Starting Today
3 hours ago
Is It Worth Buying a Ceramic Apple Watch?
Is It Worth Buying a Ceramic Apple Watch?
6 hours ago
Samsung Early Black Friday Event Brings Major Sales to Frame TVs and More
Samsung Early Black Friday Event Brings Major Sales to Frame TVs and More
8 hours ago
iPhone 18 Pro Max Wins Battery Test Involving 32 Smartphones
iPhone 18 Pro Max Wins Battery Test Involving 32 Smartphones
8 hours ago
AirTag 2 4-Pack Hits Record Low $69.99 Price Ahead of Black Friday
AirTag 2 4-Pack Hits Record Low $69.99 Price Ahead of Black Friday
9 hours ago
Rumored Apple Smart Glasses Mentioned in Supplier's Earnings Briefing
Rumored Apple Smart Glasses Mentioned in Supplier's Earnings Briefing
9 hours ago
Make Apple Watch Listen for Sounds Like the Doorbell
Make Apple Watch Listen for Sounds Like the Doorbell
13 hours ago
Apple Chip Supplier TSMC Approves $1 Billion AI Investment
Apple Chip Supplier TSMC Approves $1 Billion AI Investment
13 hours ago
'Apple Support Community' Permanently Closing on November 20
'Apple Support Community' Permanently Closing on November 20
19 hours ago
Apple's Holiday Gift Guide Highlights iPhone Duo and More
Apple's Holiday Gift Guide Highlights iPhone Duo and More
22 hours ago
Three Workers Die at Tata iPhone Parts Plant in India
Three Workers Die at Tata iPhone Parts Plant in India
22 hours ago
iCloud Mail, Calendar, Contacts and More Experiencing Outage [Updated]
iCloud Mail, Calendar, Contacts and More Experiencing Outage [Updated]
23 hours ago
Apple's Claris Testing 'Harbor' App for Local AI on Macs
Apple's Claris Testing 'Harbor' App for Local AI on Macs
1 day ago
iFixit's PROLED MacBook Pro Teardown Reveals Logo LEDs
iFixit's PROLED MacBook Pro Teardown Reveals Logo LEDs
1 day ago
10 Free iPhone Duo Apps Worth Downloading
10 Free iPhone Duo Apps Worth Downloading
1 day ago
Apple Releases New AirPods Firmware
Apple Releases New AirPods Firmware
1 day ago
Amazon Begins Early Black Friday Sale, Featuring Sitewide Discounts on Tech and Decor
Amazon Begins Early Black Friday Sale, Featuring Sitewide Discounts on Tech and Decor
1 day ago
Apple Announces Swift Student Challenge Ahead of WWDC 2027
Apple Announces Swift Student Challenge Ahead of WWDC 2027
1 day ago
Next iPad Air Likely to Have These 10 New Features
Next iPad Air Likely to Have These 10 New Features
1 day ago
iPad Mini 2021 vs. 2026 Buyer's Guide: Is It Worth Upgrading?
iPad Mini 2021 vs. 2026 Buyer's Guide: Is It Worth Upgrading?
1 day ago
New Apple TV Sign Language Feature Announced
New Apple TV Sign Language Feature Announced
1 day ago
Disable Touch on MacBook Pro PROLED XDR and When Using Sidecar
Disable Touch on MacBook Pro PROLED XDR and When Using Sidecar
1 day ago
Anker's Early Black Friday Sale Surprises With Mystery Boxes and Big Discounts
Anker's Early Black Friday Sale Surprises With Mystery Boxes and Big Discounts
1 day ago
Apple Arcade Adding These Four Games in December
Apple Arcade Adding These Four Games in December
1 day ago
OLED iPad Air Rumored to Launch in Two Sizes in Early 2027
OLED iPad Air Rumored to Launch in Two Sizes in Early 2027
1 day ago
The Original iPod Went on Sale 25 Years Ago Today
The Original iPod Went on Sale 25 Years Ago Today
1 day ago
Apple Maps Could Factor Parking Into Your Arrival Time
Apple Maps Could Factor Parking Into Your Arrival Time
1 day ago
Waze Now Alerts Drivers to Nearby Cyclists Using Garmin LiveTrack
Waze Now Alerts Drivers to Nearby Cyclists Using Garmin LiveTrack
1 day ago