Luna Display Gains PC-to-Mac Mode, 5K Support and More

Just tried this update on my M1M 16" and 2017 27" iMac as a second display. Pretty lackluster, even over a thunderbolt wire. Experience the usual lag/pixelation.

Would be fine for still content?

Thank you Luna Display

Posting late to the thread but others interested in the product might find themselves here anyway on a search so here's to you. ? I was put off from buying during the discounted period by some of the earlier posts in this thread, but eventually went ahead even though it was at full price. You see, it's my curse: Nothing is ever on a sale when I've decided I actually want it. (aka: won't be rushed into a too-quick decision by a short-term discount)

TL;DR: It's brilliant. Better than expected, and WHEN ? the new Apple monitors come next year the decision to get one is just a little bit harder. (But I will; but it looks like I'll have had a year of use out of this by then.)

My use case is, a 2021 MacBook Pro (M1Pro) as the primary, a 2019 iMac Retina 5K as the secondary. I'm a programmer, and most else I do is also mostly text-based, so what I'm looking for is super sharp text, and relative slowness of the display is of less importance. I just really really wanted the 5K. I have an older 4K monitor, but the 5K on the iMac spoiled me.

I did find on a wifi connection it was on the sluggish side; latency was too high, and quite a lot of pixellation. I expected that, and always expected to use a wired connection.

With a thunderbolt 3 cable directly connecting the two machines things were much better, and for my purposes entirely usable. I basically don't see any pixellation or other compression artefacts. All I see is that the refresh rate seems a little low. It's probably at the 45fps point, I'm guessing. (It doesn't definitively tell me, and I tell it manually it can go up to 60Hz, but that's what it feels like. Just a little less smooth than the 60Hz display next to it.) This is acceptable for my use case. Dragging windows, scrolling windows, using the trackpad is still responsive enough, and that's what I wasn't really expecting to be the case, so it's a bonus as far as I'm concerned.

I'm also trying using a Thunderbolt 3 dock (Caldigit TS3), with the Luna Display dongle connected to the onward-facing thunderbolt port on the dock, and a real 4K monitor connected to the dock's DisplayPort, and using an ethernet connection from the dock, via a nearby switching hub (into which the iMac is also connected). I needed to opt-open prefs and set a connectivity rate to manual and drag it all the way to maximum (40MB/s / 320Mbps) and this... seems to work as well as the direct thunderbolt connection did; although as noted, I am pushing it to prioritise the traffic, whereas the thunderbolt connection was fast enough without changing any defaults. In further use I may yet find that the ethernet gets more contention than the direct thunderbolt would, but that's not been an issue yet.

Videos are watchable, but don't really keep up in full screen, so frames get dropped. That was expected, and not important to me. (I can play those on the real 4K monitor attached.)

It comes with a bandwidth meter (selectable from the app main menu), shown below just after I'd been scribble-dragging this browser window around on the Luna Display. (The meter window is on the internal screen so it doesn't itself take up bandwidth.) 320Mbps seems to be a hard upper limit on the bandwidth it'll take on any interface, but it also seems sufficient. (I wonder if you could use more to get 60Hz on a 5K screen, you'd get diminishing returns as it would use up more computing resources on both ends, to capture, encode, decode, display that, to the point of possibly sacrificing performance in other respects.)



Wants:

I wish it also provided an audio output on the DisplayPort, so it could pass that through to be played out of the selected audio output on the secondary.

Given my secondary is an iMac that isn't that old or that much of a slouch, yet, and is also the place where I run apps that aren't Apple Silicon capable yet (I refuse to install Rosetta 2, more than a year into transition), it would also be nice if you could switch easily and quickly between it being a Luna Display and showing its own desktop; ideally as if Luna Display was just running in its own space ("as if" in user interface/control terms, I'm pretty sure it's driving the screen more directly than that). You can switch in the sense of just turning Luna Display *off* (quitting the app), but sometimes I'd just like to cmd-tab to another iMac app or mission control to its main desktop using its own keyboard & trackpad, and then switch right back.

Summary: Totally worth the full price, being able to use the Retina 5K screen on my shiny new MacBook Pro is a balm to my tired eyes. It definitely looks like this will do me until those new Apple monitors arrive. ?

Anyone know if the driver for windows needs admin rights? Thinking this would be useful for a company laptop.

I tested this for a while today, primarily comparing it to JumpDesktop.

I’ve got a Retina iMac with attached Thunderbolt Display and an M1 Mac Mini which is temporarily intended to be the primary Mac for some applications until the MBP arrives.

LunaDisplay visual quality on my Retina iMac is so much better than JumpDesktop - I don’t think I can not use it.
There are downsides though, the 2nd monitor attached to the iMac is not useable when using Luna Display, whereas with Jump Desktop I can have a dual monitor setup (2 iMac displays and 2 Mini displays with 3-finger swiping between Macs).

I did try the settings suggested here but I ended going back to the auto settings with 5K as I found no issue with it for my purposes - I do use the Macs connected via Ethernet not wifi.

Therefore I suspect when my new MBP arrives I will use the MBP as the central/main Mac with the external monitor connected to it directly and the iMac used as a Retina display via Luna Display. The shortage of ports on the M1 Mini is a bit limiting so am looking forward to the extras on the MBP. I’ll likely end up upgrading the Thunderbolt Display at some point.

I also tried a few options for connecting my iPad Pro as another display at the same time - I found Sidecar to be the best option for me - especially with ZBrush. I couldn’t get Easy Canvas working correctly when connected via Luna Display and when using Jump Desktop I found the screen aspect ratio too “off” compared to using the native “move window to iPad Pro”. It may be that Easy Canvas is better than SideCar for a few things such as pressure curves and touch gestures - but the combination of the aspect ratio weirdness and losing Retina display on iMac when using JumpDesktop pushed me to SideCar. I do have my physical keyboard in front of the iPad so keyboard shortcuts are not a concern - I would prefer if the Magic Keyboard worked more fully though. I’m tempted to try Astropad in case it is even better but I can’t see what it would give me for ZBrush that I don’t have with Sidecar.

Someone said VNC didn’t work with Luna Display (and I think I’ve been guilty of repeating that) but today I had no issues to that effect - at one point I had both working at the same time - I had them connected with Jump Desktop and also had the iMac connected via Luna Display at the same time. So I could have the iMac displaying the M1 Mini in Retina mode and when I wanted to use the 2nd monitor I could quit Luna and use the M1 Mini dual displays and then launch Luna to go back to single M1 Mini display on the Retina iMac.

Sooo Target Display Mode is back… sort of …by a third party? I’ll take it!