New in OS X: Get MacRumors Push Notifications on your Mac

Resubscribe Now Close

Apple Store Expansion in China Said to Have Slowed Due to Red Tape, Fraud, and Other Factors

In 2015 and 2016, Apple aggressively expanded its retail presence in China with 30 new stores, according to the Apple Storefronts tracker. Since the start of 2017, however, Apple has opened just five new locations in the country.

Apple's newest store in China in Suzhou

The Information's Wayne Ma has shared a report today that offers explanations for the slowdown, including China's bureaucratic government, scalpers, previously-reported fraud, and increasing competition from Chinese smartphone makers. The report is based on interviews with 17 former Apple employees.

On government bureaucracy:
Apple had to navigate a maze of government bureaucracy to obtain everything from business and tax licenses to construction, fire and customs permits for imported building materials, former employees say. The regulatory framework in China is far more complicated than in the U.S., with many more layers of government, these former employee say, and it’s far more opaque. Employees frequently scrambled to chase down permits and local approvals to keep store openings on track, they said.
On scalpers:
Apple, too, had to contend with scalpers, known as "yellow cows" in colloquial Chinese. These scalpers swarmed its stores and elbowed out other customers during product launches and in-store promotions. …

Apple executives worried they were losing control of the customer experience in their stores, and along with it opportunities to interact with real consumers. The scalpers showed little interest in the accessories and add-on services Apple likes to offer customers.
Other factors, according to those interviewed, included low-level government officials asking for free iPhones and other products as a form of bribery, a tug-of-war between the Beijing and Shanghai local governments over taxes, and a vibrant gray market for iPhones smuggled from Hong Kong.

As a result of these difficulties, Apple is said to have "abruptly changed" its retail expansion plans in mainland China in 2017, resulting in the dramatic slowdown in grand openings. Apple's latest store in China opened in the city of Suzhou on September 21, coinciding with iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max launch day.

Last quarter, Apple brought in revenue of $9.5 billion from the Greater China region, including Taiwan, Hong Kong, and Macao. Greater China accounted for 17.9 percent of Apple's revenue in the quarter, making it the company's third largest market, behind the United States and Europe.

Note: Due to the political nature of the discussion regarding this topic, the discussion thread is located in our Politics, Religion, Social Issues forum. All forum members and site visitors are welcome to read and follow the thread, but posting is limited to forum members with at least 100 posts.

Related Roundup: Apple Stores
Tag: China


Top Rated Comments

(View all)

7 weeks ago

Apple, too, had to contend with scalpers, known as "yellow cows" in colloquial Chinese. These scalpers swarmed its stores and elbowed out other customers during product launches and in-store promotions. ...

This is the most exciting Apple-related thing that has ever happened.

Rating: 14 Votes
7 weeks ago
WHAT!!?? Fraud!!?? In CHINA!!?? I just can't believe that!

But it doesn't matter...soon there will be an Aple Store right next door, backed by the Chinese Government.





Rating: 7 Votes
7 weeks ago

Trying to decide how offended I should be.


Why, are you yellow, or a cow?
Rating: 5 Votes
7 weeks ago
China is all over the MacRumors site today.

Why are scalpers known as Yellow Cows?
Rating: 3 Votes
7 weeks ago
So anything China related is automatically in the social and political forum?
Rating: 2 Votes
7 weeks ago

Why are scalpers known as Yellow Cows?

That was the most interesting part of the the story for me.


China is all over the MacRumors site today.

Actually, they have been all over MR for a while now, I just can't remember it ever being a positive story for Apple.

If Apple's push into China ends up working out for them, it will look like a genius move. So far, it looks like it is nothing but problems.

So anything China related is automatically in the social and political forum?

Probably because every China related story on MR, including this one, involves something political.
Rating: 2 Votes
7 weeks ago
don't blame them, this article brought up so much memory when i was in china couple years back and i had to fight bunch of ppl who were cutting in lines to get a taxi,

alot of these low-level gov't officials grew up with the peasant revolution and therefore don't have an education, its really a dog eat dog world over there often times.

when they see apple trying to open up a store on their turf they want to exploit them for $$$ as much as possible. hence the red tape nightmare
Rating: 2 Votes
7 weeks ago

This is the most exciting Apple-related thing that has ever happened.


I think you are making a moo-t point.
Rating: 2 Votes
7 weeks ago
Yet, Apple is still trying to strengten human rights and data privacy - so expect further bureaucratic hurdles to come...
Rating: 2 Votes
7 weeks ago
Tim Cook is Chinas puppet.
Rating: 1 Votes

[ Read All Comments ]