New in OS X: Get MacRumors Push Notifications on your Mac

Resubscribe Now Close

iPhone X Owners Complain About Keyboard's 'Wasted Space'

Monday November 6, 2017 7:07 am PST by Mitchel Broussard
As early adopters began to experience the iPhone X for the first time this past weekend, many users took to the MacRumors forums, Reddit, and Twitter to discuss the gap that exists below the keyboard within iOS 11 on iPhone X. As some users pointed out, this space was likely meant as a way to more easily swipe up to go Home, and potentially for ergonomics reasons since a lower keyboard could be more difficult to type on, but many iPhone X owners are still getting used to the way the keyboard looks across all apps on the device.

The iOS keyboard on iPhone X

On the new keyboard, the Globe or Emoji icon and the Dictation icon both sit below the space bar at the very bottom of the screen. Between these two buttons is a wide, empty gray area that isn't sitting well with some iPhone X owners, and which some early reviews of the device pointed out last week.

BuzzFeed, for example, wondered why Apple didn't do more with this space, potentially including adding "common punctuation, frequently used emojis, or literally anything."
It’s when the keyboard, in any app, is on screen (which, for me, is most of the time): There’s all this dead space on the bottom, where Apple could have put common punctuation, frequently used emojis, or literally anything, but instead left it blank. Other full-screen apps on other phones put navigation or other design elements in that area, and it doesn’t look crowded or crammed. It looks fine. It’s puzzling why Apple didn’t put something more useful down at the bottom, or why it didn’t add a row of numbers or emojis up top and push down the keyboard to make it more thumb-accessible.
Alex Muench, a UI/UX designer for apps like Todoist and Twist, went a step further and created a mockup of how this could look on future versions of iOS on the iPhone X. Muench likened this space on iPhone X to be a potential area for recently used emojis, "like Touch bar on Mac."


Twitter user @Yespur asked third-party keyboard SwiftKey if the company will "fill the bottom part of the screen," to which SwiftKey responded: "We'll have to look into it. Nothing to comment on beyond that." It's unclear whether third parties will have any ability to design for this area of iOS on iPhone X. In the Human Interface Guidelines for the new smartphone, the only direct mention of the keyboard asks developers to not duplicate the Globe and Dictation keys.
Don't duplicate system-provided keyboard features. On iPhone X, the Emoji/Globe key and the Dictation key automatically appear beneath the keyboard—even when using custom keyboards. Your app can't affect these keys, so avoid causing confusion by repeating them in your keyboard
The iPhone X comes with a variety of new interface gestures, features, and interactions that take some time getting used to following years of the traditional iPhone experience. Without a Home Button, unlocking the iPhone X requires you to swipe up from the bottom edge of the device, and also rearranges some physical commands like taking a screenshot by pressing the Side Button and Volume Up Button. For more information on Apple's newest smartphone, check out our iPhone X Roundup.
[ 210 comments ]


Top Rated Comments

(View all)

Avatar
djcerla
12 months ago
Alternate universe headline: “iPhone X users complain about inadvertently entering symbols while using home gesture”.
Rating: 54 Votes
Avatar
PastaPrimav
12 months ago

Apple is really slipping in the quality control department recently...

Totally irrelevant, uninformed comment. That would imply Apple just didn't know it looked like this. They know. And its on purpose. Try reading their Human Interface Guidelines. You're not supposed to crowd content close to the Home Bar, and precisely zero users would want them (or other devs) to do so.

Unfortunately, most "users" don't know what they want until they see it and try it. But, Apple isn't going to give you something bad just so you can decide for yourself that it was right the first time.
Rating: 33 Votes
Avatar
joshwenke
12 months ago
Apple is really slipping in the quality control department recently...
Rating: 19 Votes
Avatar
PastaPrimav
12 months ago
Why do we have to shove things in there? I really don't want stuff in that close proximity to the Home Bar. There's enough screen in use already.
Rating: 18 Votes
Avatar
randymac09
12 months ago
I saw somewhere else someone mentioned that iOS 11 is really like iOS 1 for the X. It’s a completely new device and needs a different OS than the others. These things will get worked out. I’m not taking the blame away from Apple, but I think come iOS 2 for the X (i.e. iOS 12) we will see a much improved UI.
Rating: 15 Votes
Avatar
Nick A
12 months ago
I think it’s fine the way it is. It’s neat and clean and doesn’t look cluttered like it does in that mock-up pic with the emojis.

The keyboard on the X is also sits in the natural position your thumbs go when holding the phone.

I do wish Apple would fix the bug that keeps changing my “I” to an A with a question mark though!!
Rating: 12 Votes
Avatar
iapplelove
12 months ago
I’m just happy Face ID works as flawless as it does. Also the screen is real nice!
Rating: 9 Votes
Avatar
jabingla2810
12 months ago
The space is there to make the keyboard comfortable to use.
Rating: 9 Votes
Avatar
Berzerker7
12 months ago

Beta product, expected.

Happy testing.

Didn't read past the headline.

Uninformed reader, expected.
Rating: 9 Votes
Avatar
drzen
12 months ago
The reason for this design choice is this: have you ever tried to bring up control center in iOS 10.x.x when you're inside iMessages and the keyboard is active? More often than not the gesture doesn't work consistently.

Now the same thing would have happened trying to swipe back home, a gesture that's going to be used often.
Rating: 7 Votes

[ Read All Comments ]