Is ASUS Trying to be Apple?

If it was just their MacBook Air-alike, we might have let it pass. But after we saw the ASUS Chairman's Computex presentation and "Behind the Scenes" video, it seems that ASUS is trying hard to be like Apple. Here is ASUS Chairman Jonney Shih revealing their one more thing at the Computex press conference:
At the end of the Asus press conference at Computex 2011, Chairman Jonney Shih waited until the very last minute to unveil the best product of the night: The Asus PadFone, a convergent device that docks a smartphone into the back of a slate so that they can be used together as a single device.

Note the staged phone call comes from "Steve". And here's their "behind the scenes" video, complete with interview with the designer:



The video ends:


There's nothing particularly wrong about trying, though they do come across as a Bizarro Apple.




Top Rated Comments

(View all)
Avatar
106 months ago
Well, that was awkward....
Rating: 11 Votes
Avatar
106 months ago
lol @ the "padfone" at the end. ASUS has a serious case of Apple envy alright.
Rating: 7 Votes
Avatar
106 months ago

It happens more that you might think. I'm studying this at the minute. The tiger economies import the technology from innovators, break it down, work out how to do it cheaper, and then copy the ideas for a lower price.

Toyota had the same problem. It discovered a company called Cherry, who had taken one of their cars, torn it down and then recreated it to the exact specs with just larger headlights to differentiate.

As someone mentioned above, if you can't innovate; replicate.


I believe Toyota started out in the 1930's in much the same way, by copying Chrysler, Ford and GM. Heck, even Steve Jobs famously once said, 'We have always been shameless about stealing great ideas.'

The challenge for any designer is to learn from what others are doing, and then add to it, innovate, make it better, put their own stamp on it — and then, sadly, step away and let the lawyers fight it out to see who owes who money when all the dust has settled!
Rating: 6 Votes
Avatar
106 months ago
Is this real?

Is this real? It looks like a comedy routine on SNL. This can not possibly be a real product and it must be a late April fools joke from MacRumors. :D
Rating: 5 Votes
Avatar
106 months ago
Wait... Padfone?
Hilarity.
Rating: 5 Votes
Avatar
106 months ago

This does not sound very professional. Just because the Vietnamese couldn't copy Apple very well, that doesn't give you the right to mock them.


First, Asus is a Taiwanese company. Second, why are you bringing up nationality?

This is a blog that covers topics related to Apple, and any news from a competitor that might be relevant to discussion. Asus is aping Apple's look, themes and style (even down to using the same font, Myriad Pro) and all that this post is doing is pointing out the eerie similarities. It's not unprofessional at all.
Rating: 5 Votes
Avatar
106 months ago
If you can't innovate, you have to imitate.
Rating: 4 Votes
Avatar
106 months ago
kind of sad.
Rating: 4 Votes
Avatar
106 months ago
Is it racist that I found those videos hilarious?

I think ASUS is on to something, the pad and the phone experience SHOULD be connected and I think going forward will be more and more. Slapping your phone inside of your tablet isn't the best solution though. In fact, it's a little silly.

But that wasn't even the hilarious part.

And to be honest, while funny, the engrish wasn't the hilarious part either.

I think the hilarious part was the dense amount of fail located throughout all of that. It was just sopping wet with fail.
Rating: 4 Votes
Avatar
106 months ago
That was kind of creepy, they need someone else to do their presentation for them next time.
Rating: 4 Votes
[ Read All Comments ]