New in OS X: Get MacRumors Push Notifications on your Mac

Resubscribe Now Close

Former Apple Employees Reflect on Siri's 'Squandered Lead' Over Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant

Wednesday March 14, 2018 9:21 am PDT by Joe Rossignol
The Information has published an in-depth look at how Siri has transitioned from one of Apple's most promising technologies into a "major problem" for the company. The article includes interviews with a dozen former Apple employees who worked on the various teams responsible for the virtual assistant.


The report claims that many of the employees acknowledged for the first time that Apple rushed Siri to be included in the iPhone 4s before the technology was fully ready, resulting in several internal debates over whether to continue patching up the half-baked product or start from scratch.
Siri's various teams morphed into an unwieldy apparatus that engaged in petty turf battles and heated arguments over what an ideal version of Siri should be—a quick and accurate information fetcher or a conversant and intuitive assistant capable of complex tasks.
The team working on Siri was overseen by Apple's then iOS chief Scott Forstall, but his attention was reportedly divided by other major projects, including the upcoming launch of Apple Maps. As a result, Forstall enlisted Richard Williamson, who was also managing the Apple Maps project, to head up the Siri team.

According to the report, several former employees said Williamson made a number of decisions that the rest of the Siri team disagreed with, including a plan to improve the assistant's capabilities only once a year.

Williamson, in an emailed response to the report, wrote that it's "completely untrue" that he decided Siri shouldn't be improved continuously.
He said decisions concerning "technical leadership of the software and server infrastructure" were made by employees below his level, while he was responsible for getting the team on track.

"After launch, Siri was a disaster," Mr. Williamson wrote. "It was slow, when it worked at all. The software was riddled with serious bugs. Those problems lie entirely with the original Siri team, certainly not me."
Forstall and Williamson were both fired by Apple in 2012 following the botched launch of Apple Maps on iOS 6. The former employees interviewed said they lamented losing Forstall, who "believed in what they were doing."

Another interesting tidbit is that the Siri team apparently didn't even learn about the HomePod until 2015. Last year, Bloomberg News reported that Apple had developed several speaker prototypes dating back to 2012, but the Siri team presumably didn't know due to Apple's culture of secrecy.
In a sign of how unprepared Apple was to deal with a rivalry, two Siri team members told The Information that their team didn't even learn about Apple’s HomePod project until 2015—after Amazon unveiled the Echo in late 2014. One of Apple’s original plans was to launch its speaker without Siri included, according to a source.
The report says that Siri is the main reason the HomePod has "underperformed," and said Siri's capabilities "remain limited compared to the competition," including Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant.
The most notable failure in Siri's evolution is that it still lacks the third-party developer ecosystem considered the key element of the original Siri vision. Apple finally launched SiriKit in 2016 after years of setting aside the project and shifting resources away to other areas. […]

But SiriKit has yet to fulfill its promise. So far it includes just 10 activities—Apple calls them "intent domains"—such as payments, booking rides, setting up to-do lists and looking at photos. Several senior engineers who worked on SiriKit have left Apple or moved off the project.
Some former employees interviewed noted that "while Apple has tried to remake itself as a services company, its core is still product design."

Apple responded to today's report with a statement noting Siri is "the world's most popular voice assistant" and touted "significant advances" to the assistant's performance, scalability, and reliability.
"We have made significant advances in Siri performance, scalability and reliability and have applied the latest machine learning techniques to create a more natural voice and more proactive features," Apple wrote in its statement. "We continue to invest deeply in machine learning and artificial intelligence to continually improve the quality of answers Siri provides and the breadth of questions Siri can respond to."
The full-length article is a worthwhile read for those interested in learning more about Siri's internal struggles and shortcomings.

The Information: The Seven-Year Itch: How Apple's Marriage to Siri Turned Sour

Tags: Siri Guide, theinformation.com
[ 303 comments ]

Top Rated Comments

(View all)

Avatar
HumpYourWayUp
21 months ago
Best Line in the article:

"Those problems lie entirely with the original Siri team, certainly not me"

LOL thats the attitude for effective teamwork!
Rating: 106 Votes
Avatar
Regime2008
21 months ago
Significant advances? Siri seems about the same since its launch...
Rating: 82 Votes
Avatar
jjhny
21 months ago
Tim would rather virtue signal. Or sing carpool karaoke than do the visionary thing.

His background is making a supply chain work. Not very helpful for envisioning the future.
Rating: 64 Votes
Avatar
Brookzy
21 months ago

...resulting in several internal debates over whether to continue patching up the half-baked product or start from scratch.

I can't help but think that starting from scratch might still be the best option...
Rating: 48 Votes
Avatar
tkukoc
21 months ago

Significant advances? Siri seems about the same since its launch...

Well they changed her from a wavy bar to a bunch of floating colors in a circle..that took.. Courage! o_O
Rating: 43 Votes
Avatar
andromedaan
21 months ago
Anyone who has ever used Google Assistant knows how crappy and inferior Siri is. It's a SHAME!
Rating: 40 Votes
Avatar
Spaceboy88
21 months ago

Anyone who has ever used Google Assistant knows how crappy and inferior Siri is. It's a SHAME!


Alexa too. I will often ask Alexa questions and the same question to Siri and 90% of the time, Siri can't answer it. Sadly, Apple must not realize that there's more we'd want to ask Siri than "Is it raining outside" or "how do I get to California Pizza Kitchen."
Rating: 26 Votes
Avatar
avanpelt
21 months ago

Apple responded to today's report with a statement noting Siri is "the world's most popular voice assistant" and touted "significant advances" to the assistant's performance, scalability, and reliability.


What a complete BS response from Apple. They should've just said nothing. Siri is the 'world's most popular voice assistant'? There are far more Android devices in use around the world today than iOS devices. Way to repeat an old, tired talking point that was actually accurate in 2011 when the iPhone 4S launched.
Rating: 26 Votes
Avatar
Spaceboy88
21 months ago
SiriKit is a joke. Until they allow you to control 3rd party music services with Siri, it's useless to me. If I'm going to send money or hail an uber, I'm going into the actual app for that.
Rating: 25 Votes
Avatar
WilliamG
21 months ago
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: Siri does what I NEED, not always what I WANT.

Actually, hardly ever what I REALLY want.

Oh well.

AND, again, Siri, why can’t I say, “Turn off the kitchen light and the dining room light?”

WHY?

*sigh*
Rating: 21 Votes

[ Read All Comments ]