New in OS X: Get MacRumors Push Notifications on your Mac

Resubscribe Now Close

Developers Report Recent Enforcement of Stricter Rules for Emoji Use in iOS Apps

Wednesday February 7, 2018 5:51 am PST by Mitchel Broussard
Over the past few weeks, iOS app developers have been sharing stories on Twitter about their apps getting rejected by Apple's App Review team because emojis were used in "non-keyboard based situations." So if an app displayed an emoji in its user interface, where the user did not type it in with a keyboard, Apple said it was not complying with its trademark and Apple Emoji imagery guidelines.

As accounts of similar situations begin to build, Emojipedia this week reported on the topic, and attempted to make sense of the new rules, with a handful of examples of apps that have been using emoji within their UI and are now being rejected by Apple. In the iOS app "Reaction Match," a Game Center error screen saw the use of the loudly crying face and alien emojis become problems for developer Eddie Lee. He eventually removed all instances of the emojis, and the App Store reviewers then accepted the app.

Image of Reaction Match's rejected (left) and approved (right) app screens via Emojipedia

Github client app GitHawk faced similar issues, with Apple rejecting the app for its use of emojis as "media" in various parts of the app. As developer and software engineer Ryan Nystrom explained, these instances of "non text input" emoji use got flagged, but once he removed the emojis and used them only as "content" and as text input examples, the app was approved.



Like other newly discovered App Store guidelines, there is some inconsistency in Apple's processes and the exact rules remain unclear. For example, a few major apps apparently violate the new emoji-as-text-only rule -- like Snapchat's emoji friend scores -- but appear to not have had issues in recent updates. Other areas of uncertainty include emojis in push notifications and in responses from chatbot apps.

As Emojipedia pointed out, this could affect smaller developers the most and cause their user interfaces to become less personalized.
Smaller developers will be hardest hit as Apple's professionally designed emojis were a quick and easy way to provide imagery in an app that fit in with the system. They will now need to create their own icons to fill the gap, embed a licensed emoji set, or have a naked-looking UI.

Larger developers have the budget to create their own emoji or icon sets, or to license existing ones. The largest or most popular apps may see Apple overlooking breaches of this new policy.
Apple is known to consistently introduce tweaks and updates to its App Store Review Guidelines, occasionally amending harsher rules that create unexpected problems for some apps. For example, last June Apple introduced new guidelines that banned apps created from a commercialized template or app generation service in an effort to fight clones and spam on the App Store. Eventually, the rule negatively affected small businesses who rely on such templates, and Apple amended its guidelines to be less restrictive.

Outside of the traditional emoji characters, Apple launched a new set of advanced emojis with Animoji on the iPhone X. The new feature creates 3D models of existing emojis and tracks their animations to the user's facial features using the iPhone X's TrueDepth front-facing camera, which resulted in the phenomenon of "Animoji Karaoke" videos that Apple itself eventually got in on.

Tags: emoji, App Store Review Guidelines
[ 63 comments ]


Top Rated Comments

(View all)

Avatar
alex00100
19 months ago
Finally, Apple working on the real issues here!
Rating: 29 Votes
Avatar
RedWing512
19 months ago

This is funny because Paul Hegarty in his Stanford iOS 11 development course uses emoji in the first class demo. I suppose Apple thinks it isn't professional to use them outside email and messaging apps, which makes sense.


Since when is using emoji for anything professional?
Rating: 16 Votes
Avatar
Baymowe335
19 months ago

Finally, Apple working on the real issue here!

Classic argument.

It is possible to work on multiple initiatives, some of them ranging from not very important to very important.

The reasoning behind something you perceive as a failure is not always directly related to their work on Animoji.
Rating: 10 Votes
Avatar
Chupa Chupa
19 months ago

Anyone know the reasoning behind Apple blocking this? Do they just not want developers to be lazy?

I figure if it looks good, it should be allowed. Nobody really owns Emojis anyway.


I don't know but seems to me Apple wants to reserve use of emojis as typing shortcut and not extend them to, essentially, clip art. It's not about ownership of emojis, but rather how Apple wants them to be used in the OS to keep it unified.
Rating: 8 Votes
Avatar
GrumpyMom
19 months ago
I guess it’s because Apple expended their own resources to create these emoji and don’t want them treated as generic royalty free clip art as [USER=6108]@Chupa Chupa[/USER] posted. It makes sense from the point of view of preserving their “brand” integrity, though the optics on this does make them look heavy handed. I don’t think it’s that big a deal. The revised screen in the example without the emoji has better impact and seems more personal with the new wording than it did with that ugly emoji on it.
Rating: 7 Votes
Avatar
Zenithal
19 months ago
Yeah, screw the Pro and the Mini. This stuff is as bad as coke!
Rating: 6 Votes
Avatar
Avieshek
19 months ago
If that strictness was maintained on removing bugs...

Emojis & Rainbow Watchbands it is.
Rating: 5 Votes
Avatar
dannyyankou
19 months ago
Seriously Apple? Let them use an emoji in menu screens if they want. Who’s it hurting?
Rating: 5 Votes
Avatar
JosephAW
19 months ago
Part of the problem is when I use their app in iOS 10 and they use an emoji from iOS 11 I get a square.
Rating: 5 Votes
Avatar
miniyou64
19 months ago
It only applies to the little guy. If you're big like snapchat, no need to worry
Rating: 5 Votes

[ Read All Comments ]