New in OS X: Get MacRumors Push Notifications on your Mac

Resubscribe Now Close

Yahoo Adapted Email-Scanning Spam Filter to Satisfy 'Secret Court Order' Related to Terrorist Hunt

Following a report yesterday that cited three former Yahoo employees who claimed the company built a program to scan every customer's email for specific information at the order of the United States government, new pieces of information have surfaced in a separate article from The New York Times. Specifically, anonymous sources close to the matter said that Yahoo built the program by adapting a filter meant to scan email inboxes for child pornography, malware, and basic spam content.

Yahoo was said to have done this in order to "satisfy a secret court order," created to require the company to search for content containing a specific computer signature related to online communications of an unspecified state-sponsored terrorist group. Two of the anonymous sources -- referred to as "government officials" -- mentioned the Justice Department received the order from a judge of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court sometime last year, an order that Yahoo was "barred from disclosing" to the public.

yahoo
Through its modifications to the spam filter program, Yahoo complied with the Justice Department's order and made available any email that contained the signature, but as of now that collection method "is no longer taking place." The order was described as "unusual" because it required the scanning of individual emails instead of user accounts as a whole, and was allegedly only given to Yahoo as other tech companies, including Apple, have said they never encountered such a demand.
In response to a request for comment, an Apple spokesperson told BuzzFeed News, “We have never received a request of this type. If we were to receive one, we would oppose it in court.”

A Microsoft spokesperson said, “We have never engaged in the secret scanning of email traffic like what has been reported today about Yahoo.”

A Google spokesperson told BuzzFeed News, “We’ve never received such a request, but if we did, our response would be simple: no way.”
According to the sources, federal investigators learned last year that members of a foreign terrorist organization were communicating using Yahoo's email service, through a method that used a "highly unique" designator, or signature, in each communication. Although built to look for specific content, the modified program's far-reaching scanning of each user on the service brought about unrest in the user base when the original report came out yesterday. Yahoo's compliance is also being contrasted to Apple's obstinate response in its battle with the FBI earlier in the year.

After the news broke, Yahoo said that the Reuters story was "misleading" and that the email scanning outlined in the report "does not exist on our systems." Compounding the company's woes, last month Yahoo confirmed that "at least" 500 million user accounts were compromised during an attack in late 2014, leaking customer information like names, email addresses, telephone numbers, birthdates, hashed passwords, and both encrypted and unencrypted security questions and answers. In the midst of all of this, Yahoo’s pending acquisition by Verizon could potentially face negative effects.

Note: Due to the political nature of the discussion regarding this topic, the discussion thread is located in our Politics, Religion, Social Issues forum. All forum members and site visitors are welcome to read and follow the thread, but posting is limited to forum members with at least 100 posts.

Tag: Yahoo


Top Rated Comments

(View all)

35 months ago
If the supposed filter works as well as Yahoo's spam filter then the terrorists have nothing to worry about.
Rating: 14 Votes
35 months ago
I have a hard time believing the efficacy of this secret email filter, as Yahoo has been notoriously bad at filtering malware & spam. :rolleyes: It must have been super porous.

I also have a hard time believing anybody who has their life or super secret plans on the line would even think of using Yahoo email in the first place. So wouldn't it be a really stupid terrorist gang?
Rating: 10 Votes
35 months ago
It goes from bad to worse. Both hacked and spying government shills.

It's over, Yahoo!
Rating: 8 Votes
35 months ago
It's unlikely they just scanned "inboxes". That could have been accomplished by scanning incoming mail with a network sniffer, and Yahoo's cooperation wasn't needed for that.

This was most likely to look in folders OTHER than the inbox, particularly the Drafts folder.

A well-known circumvention of incoming email sniffing is to use the same account: composing a message and saving it in the Drafts folder. The recipient logs into the same account and reads the draft message, replying to it or deleting it.
Rating: 7 Votes
35 months ago

I guess I must be an enemy of freedom. The secrecy isn't great, but look. What was the greatest risk involved with Yahoo Mail? You were going to a very low-rent neighborhood of the Internet. The equivalent of a truck stop. Crummy design, intrusive ads eating up your bandwidth, crazy people trying to convince you of nonsense. Think of it as a neighborhood. How would you feel if some militants are being organized for violence in that neighborhood? If they develop evidence that they MIGHT be hiding child porn, cash for weapons, directions for bombs, and yes, child porn, such that a judge would grant a warrant. When did the Internet get to be outside of the real world? Not talking intrusive, but if the guy next door was torturing kids, what are his privacy rights worth in the scheme of things? How about a native ISIS cell? Neo-Nazis? Our police, in a democracy, do have a real job. I'm not saying I've worked out all these questions, but the Internet giveth and the Internet taketh away. If you're on the web you can see the world. And the world sees you.


Email itself is Sticky, many people with Yahoo addresses come from a time before Google's popularity. I try not to make character judgments based on whatever domain they email me from.

Child porn? That has commonly been the trump card used to take away, or limit the privacy of people who have absolute detest, and nothing to do with such a vile activity. Fear mongering of terroristic activity is slowly replacing it as the new ultimate argument against privacy.
Rating: 5 Votes
35 months ago
surely google, fb etc are doing the same then... since they cant 'discuss' it?
Rating: 5 Votes
35 months ago
I have a hard time believing that the government hasn't approached Google, or Microsoft with such questions. I could see them not asking Apple, simply due to their overall lack of marketshare.
Rating: 5 Votes
35 months ago

I have a hard time believing that the government hasn't approached Google, or Microsoft with such questions. I could see them not asking Apple, simply due to their overall lack of marketshare.

I don't understand the logic you're using. I hope you're not conflating phone marketshare with email client marketshare. There are several metrics showing the iPhone email client is the largest by a wide margin. To be fair, that could be a focus on mobile. To be even more fair, I didn't dig into how those metrics were obtained. Desktop and business client email may paint a different picture but I seriously doubt those would be the vector for terrorists. Regardless, you can't use phone marketshare as a reason for not asking Apple. It doesn't make sense.

Apple, Microsoft, and Google all state they haven't been approached with a request like this. Apple and Google were both pretty emphatic in their response. Hell no. Microsoft on the other hand, their response was a bit more vague and non-commital regarding their response if requested to do something similar.
"We have never engaged in the secret scanning of email traffic like what has been reported today about Yahoo." - Microsoft. If someone gave me a response like that, my first question would be "Well what kind of secret email scanning have you done?"
Rating: 5 Votes
35 months ago
I guess I must be an enemy of freedom. The secrecy isn't great, but look. What was the greatest risk involved with Yahoo Mail? You were going to a very low-rent neighborhood of the Internet. The equivalent of a truck stop. Crummy design, intrusive ads eating up your bandwidth, crazy people trying to convince you of nonsense. Think of it as a neighborhood. How would you feel if some militants are being organized for violence in that neighborhood? If they develop evidence that they MIGHT be hiding child porn, cash for weapons, directions for bombs, and yes, child porn, such that a judge would grant a warrant. When did the Internet get to be outside of the real world? Not talking intrusive, but if the guy next door was torturing kids, what are his privacy rights worth in the scheme of things? How about a native ISIS cell? Neo-Nazis? Our police, in a democracy, do have a real job. I'm not saying I've worked out all these questions, but the Internet giveth and the Internet taketh away. If you're on the web you can see the world. And the world sees you.
Rating: 4 Votes
35 months ago
Email address list
isis_hr@yahoo.com
isis_support@yahoo.com
isis_tech@yahoo.com
isis_operations@yahoo.com
isis_singles@yahoo.com
isis_help@yahoo.com

Specific Signatures
Today the Iraq, Tomorrow the World!
Today is the first day of the Caliphate!
Islam is our co-pilot.
Caliphate starts with you!
Rating: 3 Votes

[ Read All Comments ]