Court Ruling Could Lead to Stricter Password-Sharing Laws in the Future - MacRumors
Skip to Content

Court Ruling Could Lead to Stricter Password-Sharing Laws in the Future

by

Earlier this month a federal appeals court decided that an employee "acted without authorization" after he used a former co-worker's password login without their permission, in order to gain access to a collection of their data. Concerning the case The United States of America v. David Nosal, this has led to a decision by the court to rule that password sharing is a federal crime under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, meaning that sharing your login among friends and family for accounts like Netflix and HBO Go could now be an illegal act (via TechCrunch).

Judge McKeown, who is close to the case and wrote its opinion, admitted that more innocent forms of password sharing "bears little resemblance" to the circumstances presented in the lawsuit that ignited the ruling. McKeown urged future judges and courts to consider how important "facts and context" are to each case, and craft rulings surrounding password-sharing lawsuits and their legality from there.

netflix2.jpg
While the daily sharing of passwords has yet to be designated as a violation of federal law, some do see the new ruling as a slippery slope to a future where giving a friend your HBO Go login could land you in a heap of trouble. Judge Reinhardt took the dissenting opinion on the case, commenting that while David Nosal may have gotten into "criminal or civil" liabilities while logging into his co-worker's accounts, "he has not violated the CFAA."

This case is about password sharing. People frequently share their passwords, notwithstanding the fact that websites and employers have policies prohibiting it. In my view, the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (“CFAA”) does not make the millions of people who engage in this ubiquitous, useful, and generally harmless conduct into unwitting federal criminals. Whatever other liability, criminal or civil, Nosal may have incurred in his improper attempt to compete with his former employer, he has not violated the CFAA. — Judge Stephen Reinhardt, Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals

An act so widely perpetrated is far less likely to incur major legal repercussions, even if it does become enacted on more of a wider scale, but there is still a possibility for the federal appeals court's decision to let companies decide on their own whether password sharing should be more strictly reprimanded or not. Comments by Netflix earlier this year at CES suggest the company won't be heading in that direction any time soon, as CEO Reed Hastings saw the expansive sharing of their services as "a positive thing."

Top Rated Comments

oneMadRssn Avatar
135 months ago
Good. If you share your details for a streaming service or online game then you are committing fraud. Plain and simple.
What fraud? At very worst it's a simple breach of contract.
Score: 6 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Glassed Silver Avatar
135 months ago
That law shows very well how lobbying works under the radar.
Ah, it's just there to protect you! Except, when you actively share a password, at worst you're stupid, but at best it's intentional and with someone you trust with whatever the password unlocks.

Thank companies like Netflix for this mess existing.
This has nothing to do with security.
Might as well ban lending your car.
I mean, they could open the trunk with the key!!!! And who knows what you put in there!!!

Glassed Silver:mac
Score: 6 Votes (Like | Disagree)
lederermc Avatar
135 months ago
The fact that Netflix allows multiple Queues/profiles is a clue that sharing a Netflix password is sanctioned. The media is negligent in spewing this garbage.
Score: 4 Votes (Like | Disagree)
oneMadRssn Avatar
135 months ago
If you and some buddies, who aren't family, sign up for Spotify and split the family plan pricing between you, then it's fraud. Your intent is to avoid paying for a single user subscription by "pretending" you're family and at the same address.
First, what you described would be against Spotify's Family Plan Terms and Conditions. This is a contract of adhesion essentially, and on point it only says "All account holders must reside at the same address to be eligible for the Spotify Family Plan." So it doesn't actually define family, nor require any lineal or blood relationship. In theory, a bunch of guys living in a frat house with a Spotify family account would not be a breach of this contract. Interestingly, Spotify's larger general Terms and Conditions do not address this at all.

Either way, if people were to do what you described above, it would be a violation of this contract. Spotify's Terms and Conditions discuss breach in a few sections. So Spotify does contemplate and foresee that some users will breach the contract. Should Spotify want, when they become aware of this breach, they can do a number of things including cancelling the contract and deleting the account. This is, simply, a breach of contract. Nothing more. As a party to a contract, you are allowed to breach it and suffer the consequences.

Second, your example fails as it isn't even an example of sharing login information. With Spotify family, each user uses their own login and password and otherwise keeps a wholly separate account. Being in the family plan just means one of the users is responsible for billing.
Score: 4 Votes (Like | Disagree)
JRobinsonJr Avatar
135 months ago
Really silly. Says a lot about how in America, it's all about the money at the expense of loss of personal freedom/decision.
Good. If you share your details for a streaming service or online game then you are committing fraud. Plain and simple.
I don't see this as either extreme. The reality is that some services (eg. cable ID based) are intended and priced for a single user/household, and it is not unreasonable for the provider to ask that you not expand usage beyond that audience. Other services (eg. Netflix) are priced for multiple users and can be used in that context. For example, I pay for the 4-stream 'family' plan on Netflix, and have no problem sharing that login within the family. Either way it is both reasonable and fair for the providers to ask that you respect the intent.
Score: 4 Votes (Like | Disagree)
12vElectronics Avatar
135 months ago
I think this type of court case will never affect Netflix/Hulu etc.
Score: 3 Votes (Like | Disagree)

Popular Stories

iPhone Duo Outer Display Hand

Apple Aiming to Upgrade the iPhone Duo in Four Ways

Sunday November 15, 2026 8:42 am PST by
Bloomberg's Mark Gurman today said Apple has four goals for future iPhone Duo models: Face ID, an Action button, a telephoto camera, and a thinner-and-lighter design. Gurman said Apple has already developed iPhone Duo 2 prototypes with Face ID on the outer display, but it is "running out of time" to finalize the feature for that model, so it might not arrive until the iPhone Duo...
Apple Health AI Study App Feature

Apple Just Released a New App

Monday November 16, 2026 9:43 am PST by
Apple today launched a new research study in the U.S. to explore the use of AI for health, and it has released a dedicated iPhone app for participants. In a press release, Apple said the study and app are "designed to advance the understanding of how people interact with conversational health AI tools." The Apple Health AI Study App contains a generative AI chatbot that participants can...
iphone duo yellow hand

Apple Adds Facial Unlock Option on iPhone Duo in iOS 27.3

Monday November 16, 2026 10:17 am PST by
Apple today added a new option for unlocking the iPhone Duo using the front-facing camera, giving device users multiple ways to access their content. The feature is available in the second iOS 27.3 beta. The option to unlock with facial recognition is only available on the Lock Screen, and authentication via Touch ID is still needed for Apple Pay purchases, adding passwords and logins, and...
Latest Stories
Apple Tests Bringing Back a Softer Side of Liquid Glass
Apple Tests Bringing Back a Softer Side of Liquid Glass
52 minutes ago
Apple Close to Rare Long-Term Memory Deal With Samsung
Apple Close to Rare Long-Term Memory Deal With Samsung
2 hours ago
Everything New in iOS 27.3 Beta 2
Everything New in iOS 27.3 Beta 2
12 hours ago
Apple Plans to Release These 18 New Products Next Year
Apple Plans to Release These 18 New Products Next Year
13 hours ago
New Apple TV 4K Discount Returns at Amazon
New Apple TV 4K Discount Returns at Amazon
14 hours ago
iPhone Duo Orders Will Now Arrive Before the Holidays
iPhone Duo Orders Will Now Arrive Before the Holidays
14 hours ago
Hands-On With the iPhone Duo's New Face Unlock
Hands-On With the iPhone Duo's New Face Unlock
14 hours ago
macOS 27.3 Warns Against Giving AI Apps Full Mac Control
macOS 27.3 Warns Against Giving AI Apps Full Mac Control
15 hours ago
iPad and Mac Get Apple Intelligence in China in 27.3 Betas
iPad and Mac Get Apple Intelligence in China in 27.3 Betas
16 hours ago
Apple News+ Puzzles Come to UK, Australia, and French Canada
Apple News+ Puzzles Come to UK, Australia, and French Canada
17 hours ago
macOS Golden Gate 27.3 Beta 2 Now Available for Developers
macOS Golden Gate 27.3 Beta 2 Now Available for Developers
17 hours ago
Apple Celebrates Pokémon With iPhone Wallpapers and Special Gift Card
Apple Celebrates Pokémon With iPhone Wallpapers and Special Gift Card
17 hours ago
Apple TV App Gets Video Podcasts in iOS 27.3
Apple TV App Gets Video Podcasts in iOS 27.3
17 hours ago
Best Early AirPods Black Friday Deals Include AirPods Pro 3 for $179
Best Early AirPods Black Friday Deals Include AirPods Pro 3 for $179
18 hours ago
iOS 27.3 Adds 'Ask About Page' Siri AI Feature to Safari
iOS 27.3 Adds 'Ask About Page' Siri AI Feature to Safari
18 hours ago
Apple Says More Than 200,000 Apps Now Optimized for iPhone Duo
Apple Says More Than 200,000 Apps Now Optimized for iPhone Duo
18 hours ago
Apple Adds Facial Unlock Option on iPhone Duo in iOS 27.3
Apple Adds Facial Unlock Option on iPhone Duo in iOS 27.3
18 hours ago
iOS 27.3 Beta Adds Daily Siri AI Limits and iCloud+ Upgrades
iOS 27.3 Beta Adds Daily Siri AI Limits and iCloud+ Upgrades
18 hours ago
iOS 27.3 Beta 2 Now Available for Developers
iOS 27.3 Beta 2 Now Available for Developers
18 hours ago
Apple Launches Spanish Version of Its U.S. Website
Apple Launches Spanish Version of Its U.S. Website
18 hours ago
Apple Releases Second watchOS 27.3, tvOS 27.3 and visionOS 27.3 Betas
Apple Releases Second watchOS 27.3, tvOS 27.3 and visionOS 27.3 Betas
18 hours ago
Some OLED MacBook Pro Owners Report Eye Strain and Dizziness
Some OLED MacBook Pro Owners Report Eye Strain and Dizziness
18 hours ago
Didn't Order Apple's HomeView Yet? Wait Times Are Significant Now
Didn't Order Apple's HomeView Yet? Wait Times Are Significant Now
19 hours ago
Apple Pushes Back Against Canada's Plan to Access User Data
Apple Pushes Back Against Canada's Plan to Access User Data
20 hours ago
Black Friday TV Deals Include Year's Best Prices on Samsung, Sony, LG, and Many More
Black Friday TV Deals Include Year's Best Prices on Samsung, Sony, LG, and Many More
20 hours ago
Adobe's Black Friday Sale Takes 57% Off Creative Cloud Pro for Your First Year
Adobe's Black Friday Sale Takes 57% Off Creative Cloud Pro for Your First Year
21 hours ago
Apple's New HomeView Smart Home Hub Has Issues, Say Owners
Apple's New HomeView Smart Home Hub Has Issues, Say Owners
22 hours ago
'Slow Horses' to Hit 10-Season Milestone With Apple TV Renewal
'Slow Horses' to Hit 10-Season Milestone With Apple TV Renewal
22 hours ago
Apple Watch SE 3 Black Friday Deals Arrive With $50 Off Every Model
Apple Watch SE 3 Black Friday Deals Arrive With $50 Off Every Model
22 hours ago
Apple Confirms iOS 27.3 Beta 2 Coming Today
Apple Confirms iOS 27.3 Beta 2 Coming Today
22 hours ago