Apple Settles State and Consumer Class Action E-Book Price Fixing Lawsuit - MacRumors
Skip to Content

Apple Settles State and Consumer Class Action E-Book Price Fixing Lawsuit

by

ibooks-iconAccording to a letter filed in the Southern District Court of New York, Apple has reached an out-of-court settlement with both class action lawyers and state district attorneys over e-book price-fixing, reports Bloomberg.

Settlement details remain sealed and must be approved by the court. If approved, this agreement will end litigation ahead of a potentially costly damages trial that was slated to begin July 14. Apple faced more than $800 million in damages in this class-action antitrust lawsuit involving both consumers and states.

Steve Berman, a lawyer representing the plaintiffs, said by phone that all the U.S. attorneys general and consumers settled the case. Berman said he filed a memorandum of understanding with the court under seal, which prevents him from describing the agreement.

In an earlier decision, Apple was found guilty of conspiring to fix e-book prices in a lawsuit brought by the U.S. Department of Justice. As part of its preparations for launching the iBookstore alongside the iPad in 2010, Apple sought to weaken Amazon's hold on the industry and change the business model that governed the sale of e-books, an effort that resulted in higher prices for consumers. Apple filed an appeal in that case earlier this year.

Top Rated Comments

John.B Avatar
161 months ago
All while Amazon wields complete monopoly power in the bookseller world. Unbelievable....
Score: 7 Votes (Like | Disagree)
redscull Avatar
161 months ago
But book prices have not changed. Amazon still sells books as a loss lead at the author/publisher's expense, and iBooks are still MSRP sticker priced. This whole thing accomplished nothing but putting money in lawyer's pockets.
Score: 5 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Rocketman Avatar
161 months ago
Apple sought to weaken Amazon's hold on the industry and change the business model that governed the sale of e-books, an effort that resulted in higher prices for consumers. Apple filed an appeal in that case earlier this year.
As a publisher who sets a firm wholesale price on the books I publish I welcomed the agency model Apple proposed. It "raised prices to consumers" by protecting "copyright owners' rights to set wholesale prices to above cost".

Amazon wanted to sell loss leader products and transfer the cost reductions to copyright owners and not compensate them for their work since under the Amazon model the owner gets a percentage of actual sale price, even if it is $1 or $0.

That's a ripoff.

The fact they exploited a wrinkle in regulator attitudes (not written down) and thus gave civil plaintiffs a foothold based on the arbitrary and monologue rulings of regulators, means this country, in fact, does not operate under the rule of law.

It's also an example of the majority squashing the minority.

Rocketman

cite (pdf):
http://www.v-serv.com/usr/ATFE-03-16-09.pdf
Score: 4 Votes (Like | Disagree)
161 months ago
Ok I give up. Sorry I wasted your time. It's my poor English that leads me to raw and rough simplifications. Bye.
Apple clearly was in the wrong in this case and the fact that posters in here are arguing keeping prices higher for the consumers isn't a negative is inane.
Score: 3 Votes (Like | Disagree)
FakeWozniak Avatar
161 months ago
Glad this is out of the way, it was a slam dunk, they clearly did conspire to keep prices high, the evidence is clear for everyone to see except those who dont want to.

Amazon kept (and keeps) book prices low, people talk about a "monopoly" but it patently isn't, there are numerous places to buy books from, online or in print. The only monopoly (or to be accurate oligopoly) was the conspiracies of a handful of major publishers and Apple to keep prices high.
The only thing the "conspirators" did was enact an agency model which keeps vendors like Amazon from instituting aggressive "loss leaders". These below-cost prices which would eventually turn into predatory contract negotiations like we have now with Hatchette and Time Warner.

And it's not over for either Apple or Amazon.
Score: 3 Votes (Like | Disagree)
sofila Avatar
161 months ago
I'm not feeling shortsighted. I look beyond the names involved, I see a company found guilty for fixing ebook prices (raising prices for final consumers). I see the same company reaching out of court settlements. And I see some guys trying to explain me that an higher price was better in the end. I live on another planet, different from yours.
Score: 2 Votes (Like | Disagree)

Popular Stories

Apple Creator Studio iWork suite

Apple Pulls Keynote, Pages and Numbers From App Store [Update: Back]

Thursday October 22, 2026 11:01 am PDT by
Apple has temporarily removed Keynote, Pages, and Numbers from the App Store, just after releasing an update that added iPhone Duo support and a new Intelligent Assistant. It is not clear if the apps were removed intentionally, or if it is a bug. Apple has not said when the apps will be reinstated, but if it was in error, they should return soon. Update: The Mac versions are back without...
Apple Music iPod Page Not Found

Apple Music Has a Hidden iPod You Can Play With

Friday October 23, 2026 7:11 am PDT by
Apple Music has a 404 page easter egg on the web: a functional iPod that appears when you load a page that does not exist, such as music.apple.com/macrumors. "Page Not Found," says Apple. "Give this a spin instead." Apple is clever with this. If you navigate to music.apple.com/ipod instead, the page says "Looking for something?" instead of "Page Not Found." The easter egg is only...
iPhone Duo Trio

Here's What Apple's Apps Look Like on the iPhone Duo

Tuesday October 20, 2026 11:12 am PDT by
With just three days to go until the iPhone Duo is released, Apple is getting ready for the launch. Behind the scenes, the App Store now has screenshots of Apple's built-in apps running on the Duo. We've seen some apps in marketing materials, but images of the ones we haven't seen give us an idea of what it will be like using the iPhone Duo day to day. Many apps are shown in landscape...
Latest Stories
Apple Closes French Stores Ahead of Further Protests
Apple Closes French Stores Ahead of Further Protests
4 hours ago
Apple Pushes Back on DOJ Request for More Evidence
Apple Pushes Back on DOJ Request for More Evidence
5 hours ago
The iPhone Duo Can Be a Tiny Mac, a Toaster, and a Nintendo DS
The iPhone Duo Can Be a Tiny Mac, a Toaster, and a Nintendo DS
9 hours ago
Using an Apple Pencil With the iPhone Duo: What to Know
Using an Apple Pencil With the iPhone Duo: What to Know
12 hours ago
Apple Store Pickup for iPhone Duo Starting to Resume But Very Limited
Apple Store Pickup for iPhone Duo Starting to Resume But Very Limited
12 hours ago
iPhone Duo Jailbroken on Launch Day
iPhone Duo Jailbroken on Launch Day
13 hours ago
Apple Seeds Updated watchOS 27.2 Release Candidate
Apple Seeds Updated watchOS 27.2 Release Candidate
13 hours ago
Apple Store in UK Reopens With New Design on iPhone Duo Launch Day
Apple Store in UK Reopens With New Design on iPhone Duo Launch Day
13 hours ago
Crackgate? iPhone Duo Owners Report Screens Breaking Along the Hinge
Crackgate? iPhone Duo Owners Report Screens Breaking Along the Hinge
14 hours ago
iPhone Duo Brings Back Long Lines at Apple Stores
iPhone Duo Brings Back Long Lines at Apple Stores
15 hours ago
The MacRumors Show: iPhone Duo Arrives, Touchscreen MacBooks Next
The MacRumors Show: iPhone Duo Arrives, Touchscreen MacBooks Next
17 hours ago
Apple Released iOS 27.1 for iPhone Duo Only
Apple Released iOS 27.1 for iPhone Duo Only
17 hours ago
iPhone Duo: Open Two Apps Side by Side and Lock Them As an App Pair
iPhone Duo: Open Two Apps Side by Side and Lock Them As an App Pair
17 hours ago
iPhone Duo Launches With Carrier and Accessory Discounts Available
iPhone Duo Launches With Carrier and Accessory Discounts Available
18 hours ago
Apple Music Has a Hidden iPod You Can Play With
Apple Music Has a Hidden iPod You Can Play With
18 hours ago
iPhone Duo Says 'Hello' to You Personally
iPhone Duo Says 'Hello' to You Personally
19 hours ago
iPhone Duo: How to Skip the Swipe Up After Touch ID
iPhone Duo: How to Skip the Swipe Up After Touch ID
20 hours ago
Where to Buy iPhone Duo Today: Stores, Pickup, and Wait Times
Where to Buy iPhone Duo Today: Stores, Pickup, and Wait Times
21 hours ago
MacBook Neo Helps Apple Outpace Rivals as Market Declines
MacBook Neo Helps Apple Outpace Rivals as Market Declines
1 day ago
Happy 25th Anniversary, iPod
Happy 25th Anniversary, iPod
1 day ago
iPhone Duo Demand Reportedly Exceeds Apple's Expectations
iPhone Duo Demand Reportedly Exceeds Apple's Expectations
1 day ago
iPhone Duo Launch Begins as First Orders Reach Customers
iPhone Duo Launch Begins as First Orders Reach Customers
1 day ago
1Password for Agents Keeps Your Passwords Hidden From AI
1Password for Agents Keeps Your Passwords Hidden From AI
1 day ago
iPhone Duo 24 Hours Later: Your Questions Answered
iPhone Duo 24 Hours Later: Your Questions Answered
2 days ago
Apple's iWork Apps Get 'Intelligent Assistant' and iPhone Duo Support
Apple's iWork Apps Get 'Intelligent Assistant' and iPhone Duo Support
2 days ago
Apple is Apparently Considering a Slightly Larger iPhone Duo
Apple is Apparently Considering a Slightly Larger iPhone Duo
2 days ago
Giant iPhone Duo Displays Coming to Four Apple Stores
Giant iPhone Duo Displays Coming to Four Apple Stores
2 days ago
Apple Pulls Keynote, Pages and Numbers From App Store [Update: Back]
Apple Pulls Keynote, Pages and Numbers From App Store [Update: Back]
2 days ago
Apple Updates More Apps With iPhone Duo Support
Apple Updates More Apps With iPhone Duo Support
2 days ago
Apple Will Label Apps 'Made for iPhone Duo' in App Store
Apple Will Label Apps 'Made for iPhone Duo' in App Store
2 days ago