iPod Lawsuit Against Apple Given Class-Action Status - MacRumors
Skip to Content

iPod Lawsuit Against Apple Given Class-Action Status

Apple customers who purchased an iPod between September 12, 2006 and March 31, 2009 are being informed via email that they are being included in a class-action lawsuit filed against Apple in 2004. The lawsuit was granted class-action status by the courts last year and includes millions of customers who purchased any of a broad number of iPod music players. Notices are being distributed to customers covered by the class, directing them to the lawsuit's webpage.

cand
The class-action suit was filed in January 2005 by a customer complaining about the exclusive nature of Apple's digital music offerings encoded with FairPlay, preventing users from playing music purchased from the iTunes Store on other companies' music players and other music stores' digital offerings from being played on iPods. In particular, Apple's efforts to thwart RealNetworks' reverse engineering of FairPlay with its own "Harmony" technology served as the impetus for the lawsuit.

In 2011, then Apple CEO Steve Jobs was instructed to provide a deposition in the case. Apple of course no longer sells DRM-encoded music through the iTunes Store, but the lawsuit argues that Apple sought to build monopolies in the digital music and portable music player markets by integrating its products and services while preventing interoperability with competitors' products.

Three individuals who bought iPods have sued Apple seeking to recover money for themselves and other people who bought iPods. The lawsuit claims that Apple violated federal and state laws by issuing software updates in 2006 for its iPod that prevented iPods from playing songs not purchased on iTunes. The lawsuit claims that the software updates caused iPod prices to be higher than they otherwise would have been.

The Court in charge of the case is the United States District Court for the Northern District of California, and the case is known as In re Apple iPod iTunes Antitrust Litigation, C-05-00037-JW.

The list of affected iPods is extensive, including all 5th generation iPods; the iPod Classic; the U2 Special Edition iPod; first, second and third generation iPod Shuffle models; first and second generation iPod Touch models; and, first, second, third and fourth generation iPod Nano models.

Customers who wish to be excluded from the class must inform the court by July 30, 2012. Members of the class who wish register with the court can sign up on the lawsuit's website.

Popular Stories

iphone duo screen crack

Apple Responds to iPhone Duo Display Cracking Reports

Monday October 26, 2026 10:20 am PDT by
Shortly after the iPhone Duo launched, a few users reported hinge issues that were causing cracks in the inner display. Apple has now responded to the reports in a statement to MacRumors, saying a small number of units are affected. The response to iPhone Duo from early users has been incredibly positive, and we are seeing exciting things from developers who are rapidly updating their apps...
iphone duo screen crack in store

Crackgate? iPhone Duo Owners Report Screens Breaking Along the Hinge

Friday October 23, 2026 11:05 am PDT by
Some iPhone Duos are already experiencing hinge issues that cause display cracks, based on photos shared on Reddit and the MacRumors forums. Almost all of the display faults are right along the hinge, and most result in a line of bright pixels across one side of the screen. An iPhone Duo owner in Australia said his device cracked after being opened fewer than 20 times, and there was no...
jerryrigeverything iphone duo dust

iPhone Duo Fails JerryRigEverything's Dusty Durability Test

Saturday October 24, 2026 11:27 am PDT by
Apple's iPhone Duo has failed JerryRigEverything's latest durability test. Despite its IP68 dust-resistance rating, dust entered the hinge through several ingress points, overwhelming the magnets that hold the phone shut. The bend test then left a permanent green line across the inner display, before the screen became unresponsive. The outer screen with Ceramic Shield 2 scratched at level 7...

Top Rated Comments

189 months ago
I rather lose out on 5 dollars, and be done with it. Plus, we know who's getting rich out of this lawsuit, and it ain't you or me!
Score: 36 Votes (Like | Disagree)
189 months ago
iPod Music

This suit is crap.
There was never any limitation that you could not play other music on your iPod. An iPod just didn't support other DRM. You could always rip your music and play DRM free music.

You could always play your music on other players by, burning a CD them re-ripping to MP3. The argument in specious because other players didn't support AAC encoded music at the time.

Plain bull.
Score: 21 Votes (Like | Disagree)
189 months ago
Can't wait to fill out 30lbs of paperwork to collect my $2.47
Score: 21 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Earendil Avatar
189 months ago
I always assumed DRM on iTunes music was imposed by the recording industry, and not what Apple would have preferred. If that's the truth, it seems like this lawsuit shouldn't go much of anywhere.

Source: I used to watch Law and Order as a kid.
Score: 17 Votes (Like | Disagree)
189 months ago
Wow, what a waste of time, money, and effort.
Score: 12 Votes (Like | Disagree)
189 months ago
Breaking news

In other news, a new class action lawsuit has been filed charging Sony with not letting Xbox users play Xbox games on their PlayStation systems.
Score: 10 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Latest Stories
New iMac and 14-Inch MacBook Pro With M6 Chip Expected Tomorrow
New iMac and 14-Inch MacBook Pro With M6 Chip Expected Tomorrow
8 hours ago
JAŸ-Z to Headline 2027 Apple Music Super Bowl LXI Halftime Show
JAŸ-Z to Headline 2027 Apple Music Super Bowl LXI Halftime Show
8 hours ago
Older Siri Remotes Now Show Up in Find My With iOS 27.2
Older Siri Remotes Now Show Up in Find My With iOS 27.2
10 hours ago
iOS 27.2 Features: Everything New in iOS 27.2
iOS 27.2 Features: Everything New in iOS 27.2
11 hours ago
Why Can't iPhone Duo Users Make Eye Contact on FaceTime?
Why Can't iPhone Duo Users Make Eye Contact on FaceTime?
11 hours ago
iOS 27.2 Fixes Over 160 Security Vulnerabilities
iOS 27.2 Fixes Over 160 Security Vulnerabilities
12 hours ago
iPhone AI Images and Edits Now Have a Hidden Watermark
iPhone AI Images and Edits Now Have a Hidden Watermark
13 hours ago
iOS 27.2 Lets You Watch Four Live Sports Streams on iPhone
iOS 27.2 Lets You Watch Four Live Sports Streams on iPhone
14 hours ago
iOS 27.2 Expands Dual Capture to Group FaceTime
iOS 27.2 Expands Dual Capture to Group FaceTime
14 hours ago
Here's Why Apple's Next Pre-Orders Begin on Wednesday at 10:10 AM
Here's Why Apple's Next Pre-Orders Begin on Wednesday at 10:10 AM
14 hours ago
Apple Says Siri AI Will Support Even More Languages Later This Year
Apple Says Siri AI Will Support Even More Languages Later This Year
15 hours ago
Apple Releases iOS 27.2 With New Siri AI Languages
Apple Releases iOS 27.2 With New Siri AI Languages
16 hours ago
Apple Releases macOS Golden Gate 27.2
Apple Releases macOS Golden Gate 27.2
16 hours ago
Apple Releases watchOS 27.2 With Siri AI Enhancements
Apple Releases watchOS 27.2 With Siri AI Enhancements
16 hours ago
Apple Releases HomePod 27.2 Software With Sound Glow for Existing HomePods
Apple Releases HomePod 27.2 Software With Sound Glow for Existing HomePods
16 hours ago
Apple Releases tvOS 27.2 With HomePod Surround Sound Support
Apple Releases tvOS 27.2 With HomePod Surround Sound Support
16 hours ago
Apple Releases visionOS 27.2
Apple Releases visionOS 27.2
16 hours ago
iPad Mini 2024 vs. 2026 Buyer's Guide: Should You Upgrade?
iPad Mini 2024 vs. 2026 Buyer's Guide: Should You Upgrade?
16 hours ago
Apple Responds to iPhone Duo Display Cracking Reports
Apple Responds to iPhone Duo Display Cracking Reports
17 hours ago
iPhone Duo: Watch Video Above an App in Portrait Mode
iPhone Duo: Watch Video Above an App in Portrait Mode
17 hours ago
AirPods Pro Hearing Aid Feature Launching in These Canadian Provinces
AirPods Pro Hearing Aid Feature Launching in These Canadian Provinces
18 hours ago
New iPad Mini Announced Today Has More Than 12 New Features
New iPad Mini Announced Today Has More Than 12 New Features
18 hours ago
Apple Raises iPad and Mac Trade-In Values
Apple Raises iPad and Mac Trade-In Values
19 hours ago
New iPad Mini Gains Adaptive True Tone Flash
New iPad Mini Gains Adaptive True Tone Flash
19 hours ago
Quickly Silence iPhone Duo Without a Ring/Mute Switch
Quickly Silence iPhone Duo Without a Ring/Mute Switch
19 hours ago
Anker Launches Halloween Sale With Sitewide Discounts and Labubu Bundles
Anker Launches Halloween Sale With Sitewide Discounts and Labubu Bundles
20 hours ago
OLED iPad Mini Fast Charge Needs a 35W Adapter, Sold Separately
OLED iPad Mini Fast Charge Needs a 35W Adapter, Sold Separately
20 hours ago
Apple Brings TechWoven to iPad With All-New $79 iPad Mini Smart Folio
Apple Brings TechWoven to iPad With All-New $79 iPad Mini Smart Folio
20 hours ago
All Current iPads Now Feature a Landscape Front Camera
All Current iPads Now Feature a Landscape Front Camera
20 hours ago
OLED iPad Mini Starts at $699 After Second Price Hike This Year
OLED iPad Mini Starts at $699 After Second Price Hike This Year
20 hours ago