Settlement over e-Book Pricing to Undo Apple's Agency Model for Pricing? - MacRumors
Skip to Content

Settlement over e-Book Pricing to Undo Apple's Agency Model for Pricing?

ibooks iconEarlier this month, we reported on word from the U.S. Department of Justice that regulators were looking at filing suit against Apple and e-book publishers over the "agency model" of pricing championed by Apple leading up to the launch of its iBookstore. Under the model, retail book prices are set by publishers, with retailers receiving a cut of the proceeds.

Of most concern to regulators, Apple's agreements with the publishers included "most favored nation" clauses that prevented publishers from selling their books through any other retailers at lower prices than offered through Apple's iBookstore. Reuters now reports that the parties involved in the dispute are continuing to move toward a settlement in order to ward off a lawsuit, and that the settlement is likely to see the removal of these clauses. As a result, the publishing industry will likely in some form return to the previous wholesale model in which retailers set their own prices for books.

While negotiations are still fluid, the settlement is expected to eliminate Apple's so-called "most favored nation" status, which had prevented the publishers from selling lower-priced e-books through rival retailers such as Amazon.com Inc (AMZN.O) or Barnes & Noble Inc (BKS.N), the people said.

The deal could also force a shift, at least temporarily, in pricing control from publishers to retailers, one of the people said.

Such a move to a "wholesale model" would not only benefit consumers but also Amazon, which had been the leading bargain e-book retailer with its Kindle reader.

Under the wholesale model, Amazon priced e-books at or even below cost in many cases in order to draw in customers who would then purchase other items from its online store. But the practice generated concern among publishers that their works were being devalued, and many were happy to sign on with Apple's agency model in order to create more price stability.

Analysts estimate that a return to the wholesale model could add $1 billion to Amazon's revenues this year given its commanding 65% share of the e-book market and the impact of discounted pricing on sales of other items in its store. Book sales make up only a small portion of Apple's revenue, with estimates pegging iBookstore sales at roughly $50 million annually, and the company is expected to see little impact from any pricing changes in the book market.

Popular Stories

Apple Event Logo

Apple Unveiled Four New Products Today

Tuesday August 25, 2026 8:39 am PDT by
Apple today unveiled a new Mac mini with M6 and M5 Pro chip options, a new Mac Studio with M5 Max and M5 Ultra chip options, a new version of the Polishing Cloth with a lower price, and updated Magic Keyboards for Macs. To learn more about these products, read our coverage below: Apple Announces New Mac Mini With M6 and M5 Pro Chips and More Apple Unveils New Mac Studio With M5 Max and M5...
apple magic keyboard with glyphs 2026 refresh

Apple Quietly Refreshes Magic Keyboards

Tuesday August 25, 2026 7:22 am PDT by
Apple today quietly introduced updated Magic Keyboard models with revised U.S. English key labeling. On the new keyboards, the tab, caps lock, shift, return, and delete keycaps are labeled with glyphs rather than edge text. On the full-size models with a numeric keypad, the change goes further, with the home, page up, page down, end, clear, and enter keys also swapping their text labels for...
Apple Logo Gradient 16x9 1

Apple Just Made an Extremely Rare Product Announcement

Thursday August 27, 2026 7:58 am PDT by
The new Mac mini and Mac Studio models unveiled by Apple this week are the company's first new Macs announced in August since 2020. It is extremely rare for Apple to announce new products of any kind in August, excluding smaller things like new color options and accessories. As mentioned, Apple's last notable August product announcement was in 2020, when it updated the 27-inch iMac and a...

Top Rated Comments

669532 Avatar
188 months ago
the whole price thing with e-books puts a lot of people off. shame really
Score: 16 Votes (Like | Disagree)
188 months ago
I just want the price of an e-textbook to go down some.
Score: 15 Votes (Like | Disagree)
188 months ago
By allowing amazon to undercut others forces them to lower prices as well. price fixing is so subjective.
How is this any different than any other retailer lowering prices because they can afford to make lower margins for a given product by making it up elsewhere? For Pete's sake...your local grocery store does this every week. They put certain items (like cereal) on sale so you go to their stores, buy the cereal, and then buy other items that yield a better margin for the store.

Are you telling me you never comparison shop?!
Score: 14 Votes (Like | Disagree)
188 months ago
I have to agree this practice by Apple is pretty obviously anti-competitive.
Score: 13 Votes (Like | Disagree)
188 months ago
I read to many....

Good for you! To a class of kids? Or perhaps to the blind or the elderly? Either way, I applaud your efforts to help keep literacy alive!
Score: 12 Votes (Like | Disagree)
188 months ago
the whole price thing with e-books puts a lot of people off. shame really

That's the one thing that's really put me off ebooks: why pay more than the PB book price when I can buy it at a used book store for less?
Score: 12 Votes (Like | Disagree)