Apple CEO Tim Cook Calls Recent WSJ Report About Jony Ive 'Absurd'

I don't think the WSJ article said the design team was not talented.

I think the article talked about how Ive had basically checked out over the past few years.

Cook's comment is misdirection--it doesn't address the true point of the article.

Leads me to believe the WSJ article was largely accurate.

No outright denial though ....

Calling the article "absurd" and that "... the conclusions, just don't match with reality..." is pretty much an outright denial as far as I can see.

That being said... while I have no reason to doubt Tim Cook, this rebuttal would have more weight if being made by Jony Ives himself. Of course that's just my opinion.

I dont believe Tim Cook for a second here. Honestly...he seems like a great guy, but he is in no way, shape or form the next Steve Jobs and never will be. He just doesnt strike me as a person who has the passion for design and innovation steve had.

So i totally get why Johny would want to leave and seemed to not care any more with apple because his partner Steve is gone and there is no one worthy for him to bounce design and ideas off of. Tim is just not that guy.

What they need there is another Rebel, another Steve Jobs who cares more about changing the world then making a profit!

No outright denial though ....

Here’s what happened, Tim put a lot of trust in Jony after he fired Scott Forstall. But Tim felt like he probably gave Ive a bit too much power: iOS 7 wasn’t a hit out the gate had major UI issues, 2013 Mac Pro which thermally designed itself into a thermal problem, the late arrival of the 2012 iMac; the Apple Watch first gen was pretty bad and waste in making a gold version without a clear vision of its intended purpose probably cost Apple a lot of money. Bend gate with iPhone 6 was probably another big one that probably pushed Tim into taking back some control.

Cool I believe felt like Jony was probably manipulating both him and the company in the wrong direction. I also think Cook felt like Jony could easily **** this up for everyone and decided that maybe it was best his energies put towards training new leadership, emeritus role, attending product launches and blessing products with narration.

This would at least give the impression to investors and users everything is ok.

To be honest, it’s a mess right now, because there isn’t that one voice reign things in and slap the operations and MBA when they try to weasel their way in.

Steve Jobs let Jony get away with some things consciously partly due to his love for him (G4 Cube, Hi-fi iPod,), but he knew when to tell him and the team you are losing the script.

I think that is what Jony truly yearns for and is missing at Apple: Vision, Guidance and Direction.

A bean counter and human rights activist jetting all over the world to collect awards and do speeches can’t give Jony that.

I smell some damage control

The article was very unflattering towards Cook and Apple, so no wonder he’s come out self-promoting again.

That last sentence is the reason it’s hard to take anything else he says seriously: just corporate hyperbole and propaganda.

The truth is usually much less scandalous or interesting and would get way fewer clicks....

Looks like somebody touched a nerve here. :rolleyes:

Seeing as the WSJ report corroborates some of the cultural problems within Apple that a select few of us (those immune to reality-distortion fields) had surmised over these past five years - based on the lackluster output of hardware and software, along with Apple's increased focus on shareholder happiness to the detriment of customer happiness - I am not in least bit surprised.

Quality is Apple's proverbial "canary in the coal mine," and for those of us with functioning olfactory receptors, the smell coming from Cupertino has been a little worrying at times. ;)

I often disagree with the WSJ, but it's usually responsible reporting. But this wasn't an example. What value other than being a gossip hit piece did it serve? The article was the business equivalent of something that would be reported on the Kardashians.