iPhone XS and XS Max in silver, space gray, and gold.
Netflix Tests Disabling In-App Subscriptions on iOS in Some Countries
Netflix is already one of the highest grossing apps on the App Store, as many iPhone and iPad users pay for their subscriptions via iTunes/Apple ID billing, but the streaming video platform wants an even bigger piece of the pie.
TechCrunch today reported that, until September 30, new or lapsed subscribers in some 33 countries will be unable to pay using iTunes.
The countries: Argentina, Australia, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Canada, Colombia, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Ecuador, Finland, France, Germany, Hungary, India, Italy, Indonesia, Japan, Korea, Malaysia, Mexico, Norway, Peru, Philippines, Poland, Slovakia, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, Taiwan, Thailand, and the UK.
A customer service representative for Netflix confirmed the test with TechCrunch:
Apple collects a 30 percent commission—15 percent after the first year—from users who subscribe via its in-app purchase mechanism, so it's pretty clear that Netflix is trying to avoid padding the pockets of one of its biggest competitors, which just so happens to be working on a Netflix-like service itself.
Of note, Apple's App Store Review Guidelines state that developers are not permitted to "directly or indirectly target iOS users to use a purchasing method other than in-app purchase," but it appears that Netflix has worked around this rule by simply not offering new users the option to sign up in-app whatsoever.
We've reached out to Apple for comment.
TechCrunch today reported that, until September 30, new or lapsed subscribers in some 33 countries will be unable to pay using iTunes.
The countries: Argentina, Australia, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Canada, Colombia, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Ecuador, Finland, France, Germany, Hungary, India, Italy, Indonesia, Japan, Korea, Malaysia, Mexico, Norway, Peru, Philippines, Poland, Slovakia, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, Taiwan, Thailand, and the UK.
A customer service representative for Netflix confirmed the test with TechCrunch:
During this time, customers in these countries may experience any of the following when launching the Netflix app on an iOS (mobile or tablet) device:This means that some iPhone and iPad users who open the Netflix app will only be able to sign into an existing, active account, with no option to create a new account. By the sound of it, Netflix is hoping that these users will close the app, and sign up through its mobile website or elsewhere with a credit card.
1. Ability to sign up in app with only iTunes Mode Of Payment.
2. Ability to log into Netflix but not sign up (sign up only via mobile browser).
We are constantly innovating and testing new signup approaches on different platforms to better understand what our members like. Based on what we learn, we work to improve the Netflix experience for members everywhere.
Apple collects a 30 percent commission—15 percent after the first year—from users who subscribe via its in-app purchase mechanism, so it's pretty clear that Netflix is trying to avoid padding the pockets of one of its biggest competitors, which just so happens to be working on a Netflix-like service itself.
Of note, Apple's App Store Review Guidelines state that developers are not permitted to "directly or indirectly target iOS users to use a purchasing method other than in-app purchase," but it appears that Netflix has worked around this rule by simply not offering new users the option to sign up in-app whatsoever.
We've reached out to Apple for comment.
Tag: Netflix
[ 232 comments ]
Top Rated Comments
(View all)
4 weeks ago
It’s their loss. Most people like me subscribe from iTunes. They will lose lots of people.
Lmao, right. I promise you most people don’t subscribe to Netflix through iTunes. Nobody who wants to subscribe to Netflix will avoid doing it because you can’t do it through iTunes, if you think that’s the case you’re living in your own little universe. The only one who will lose out is Apple, losing out on fees they aren’t entitled to anyway and should have never received.
4 weeks ago
I can sortof understand Apple charging ~30% for purchasing an app on their store. They host the App afterall.
But taking 15% from subscriptions? 30% from in-app purchases that have absolutely NOTHING to do with Apple except using them as a payment processor is ridiculously high for a payment processor. MasterCard/Visa charges 1-2% of each purchase. Even your run of the mill non standard ones only charge 2-3%. Taking 15% of monthly subscription based services is very high and puts unecessary burdens on those companies.
Apple needs to adjust here to remain competitive. services like Netflix are already small margin and are fairly inexpensive. 15% of your fee can suddenly make the service unprofitable to deliver, and if that's the case, we al lose as the services that aren't profitable go away, even if they're great like Netflix.
Do we WANT Netflix to stop being used on iOS devices? do we want them to just say "it's not worth it" and walk away? of course not. That hurts everyone. Apple needs to realize this isn't 2010 anymore. they no longer have a captive position as the dominant platform.
But taking 15% from subscriptions? 30% from in-app purchases that have absolutely NOTHING to do with Apple except using them as a payment processor is ridiculously high for a payment processor. MasterCard/Visa charges 1-2% of each purchase. Even your run of the mill non standard ones only charge 2-3%. Taking 15% of monthly subscription based services is very high and puts unecessary burdens on those companies.
Apple needs to adjust here to remain competitive. services like Netflix are already small margin and are fairly inexpensive. 15% of your fee can suddenly make the service unprofitable to deliver, and if that's the case, we al lose as the services that aren't profitable go away, even if they're great like Netflix.
Do we WANT Netflix to stop being used on iOS devices? do we want them to just say "it's not worth it" and walk away? of course not. That hurts everyone. Apple needs to realize this isn't 2010 anymore. they no longer have a captive position as the dominant platform.
4 weeks ago
can't say I blame them. Audible has never allowed you to buy from the app for anything. Why would any company want to lose out on 15% of revenue?
4 weeks ago
Your move, Apple. Take Netflix down from their App Store maybe? :D
Why? People aren’t subscribing to Netflix because of Apple.[doublepost=1534862090][/doublepost]
It’s their loss. Most people like me subscribe from iTunes. They will lose lots of people.
Meh, it’s really easy to subscribe from the browser. That’s what I did when I had a Spotify subscription.[doublepost=1534862216][/doublepost]
can't say I blame them. Audible has never allowed you to buy from the app for anything. Why would any company want to lose out on 15% of revenue?
Barnes and Noble doesn’t either. Doesn’t stop me from buying books on bn.com. Why should Apple get a cut of B&N book sales? Just because they offer their own book service? I assumed the yearly developer fee is to cover the cost of Apple hosting a free app on the App Store.
4 weeks ago
The little angel on my left shoulder says "Netflix deserves to get the full price". The little devil on the right shoulder says "but you can save 15-20% by using discounted iTunes gift cards". And there is faint laughter in the distance that sounds like Tim Cook.
4 weeks ago
It’s their loss. Most people like me subscribe from iTunes. They will lose lots of people.
how so? Giving Apple 30% is massive chunk and I never used in app purchases for subscription and this will certainly not deter people from using netflix. After all, you only need to subscribe once and please don't tell me people are so damn lazy these days to go on a website and do it from there.I can safely say that those lazy slackers will still amount for less revenue lost than the 30% Apple is taking right now.
So good on Netflix, I would have done this ages ago.
[doublepost=1534864636][/doublepost]
So Netflix sacrifices user experience for their greed.
really? How often do you use this "feature"? I would rather that Netflix uses the extra 30% to improve the film collection and services then lose a massive chunk of money because people are so damn lazy these days
4 weeks ago
I subscribe through Apple because I don’t want Netflix to grab all my details that they then sell for more profit.
Forcing me to give you my details Netflix will drive me away.
4 weeks ago
It’s their loss. Most people like me subscribe from iTunes. They will lose lots of people.
So if you use and enjoy Netflix, you'll stop enjoying and using it because you'd have to go to their website to subscribe?Also, your current subscription is not affected. Only new ,and lapsed (expired) subscriptions are going to have to go through the netflix website.
4 weeks ago
Good for them. The bulk of Netflix's costs are going to be content licensing and bandwidth, neither of which Apple provides any benefit. Why should Apple take 30% off the top of an already low gross profit margin business for doing nothing more than acting as a payment mediator?
Maybe this will trigger a discussion where developers who want to offer payment through an in-app purchase can get closer to what Apple or the vendor actually gets charged for running the transaction through the customer's credit card itself. I can guarantee it is less than 3%.
Maybe this will trigger a discussion where developers who want to offer payment through an in-app purchase can get closer to what Apple or the vendor actually gets charged for running the transaction through the customer's credit card itself. I can guarantee it is less than 3%.
4 weeks ago
Kind of surprising considering in their last update the appstore guidelines specifically forbid this:
3.1.3(b) Multiplatform Services: Apps that operate across multiple platforms may allow users to access content, subscriptions, or features they have acquired elsewhere, including consumable items in multi-platform games, provided those items are also available as in-app purchases within the app. You must not directly or indirectly target iOS users to use a purchasing method other than in-app purchase, and your general communications about other purchasing methods must not discourage use of in-app purchase.
Forbit what exactly? They just removed the subscribe button. They did not replace it with a „subscribe now on your mobile browser“ button.
[ Read All Comments ]
Rain Design, a maker of accessories for Apple products, released three laptop stands made of anodized aluminum to match Apple's MacBook and MacBook Pro models earlier this year: the mBar, mBar...
As part of its digital health initiative in iOS 12, Apple has introduced some improvements to the way app notifications can be managed, enabling users to more easily reduce the number of daily...
Apple today seeded the first beta of an upcoming tvOS 12.1 update to its public beta testing group, two days after providing the beta to developers and three days after releasing the tvOS 12 update.
...
Hulu today is rolling out a new update for Hulu.com, bringing it in line with the design and user interface that users should be familiar with if they use Hulu on smartphones and TVs, like iOS and...
There's nothing worse than waking up in the middle of the night, glancing over at your iPhone to check the time, and seeing a bunch of notifications that demand your attention and distract you...
Apple Maps now supports transit in New Zealand, enabling users to navigate with public transportation in most populated areas of the country.
In the largest city of Auckland, directions are...
The Apple Watch Series 4 has multiple new watch faces for users to choose from, including Fire, Water, Liquid Metal, and Vapor faces that were custom-designed for Series 4 to interact with the edges...
In iOS 12, Apple's digital health push includes a couple of special new features for iPhone and iPad users who want to cut down on their app usage: App Limits and Downtime. In this article,...
