Review: Casetify's $70 Apple Watch Bands Can Be Customized With Any Design

Casetify, a company that makes customizable iPhone, iPad, and MacBook cases, has also begun selling Apple Watch bands, which can be printed with any design. Available for both the 38 and 42mm Apple Watches and in two finishes, bands can be customized with photographs or artwork or ordered from Casetify's pre-designed artist collection.

casetifybandopen

Fit


Casetify's Apple Watch bands are made from polycarbonate and are closest in nature to the Apple Watch Sport bands. I've been wearing a 38mm Casetify Apple Watch band for just over a week and while it is comfortable, the material of the band is not as soft, flexible, or as thin as the fluoroelastomer the Apple Watch Sport bands are constructed from.

casetifybandcomparedtoapplewatchsportband
Bands come in two sizes, one for each watch. The 38mm band fits wrists sized 140 to 200mm, while the 42mm band fits wrists sized 150 to 210mm. The underside of each band is ridged, with the Casetify logo printed on each side.

casetifybandsunderside
At about an eighth of an inch thick, Casetify's bands seem to be approximately a third thicker than the Apple Watch Sport (there's maybe about a millimeter of difference between the two). That's not a huge thickness disparity, but it is noticeable when wearing the Casetify band after wearing a Sport band, especially on a small wrist.

casetifybandthickness
My wrist is under 5.5 inches in circumference so the Casetify looks and feels a bit bulky on my arm, but this may be less of an issue for people with bigger wrists. Part of the reason for the bulk is that I need to wear the band on its second to last loop, so there's a lot of extra band at the underside of my wrist.

casetifybandonwristback
It's definitely thicker and less flexible than the Apple Watch sport band, but the Casetify band has still been comfortable to wear all day long, even during exercise and when it gets wet. The band has a lot of holes to adjust the fit, so it's going to fit well on a lot of different wrist sizes.

casetifybandonwrist
Most Apple Watch bands are relatively easy to put on one-handed, this band from Casetify is not. It's a standard buckle watch, so it takes some maneuvering to get it on your wrist with one hand.

Hardware


The Casetify bands attach to the Apple Watch using stainless steel adapters, in either a matte silver or a matte black finish, and each watch has a matching stainless steel buckle.

casetifyadapter
Bands attach much like any other Apple Watch band, sliding into the groove on the side of the Apple Watch until it snaps in place. The Casetify bands don't slide in and out of the Apple Watch as smoothly or as easily as Apple's own bands, but they do lock into place in the same way.

casetifybandswithbuckle
One of the bands that I received from Casetify was assembled backwards, causing it to not slide in properly or lock, so that's something to watch out for if you order one of these. Fixing it would require unscrewing the adapter and turning the band around.

I have a stainless steel Apple Watch and the matte silver of the adapter does not match the shiny finish of the Apple Watch, but when wearing the watch, the difference in finish isn't overly noticeable from a distance. If someone's close to your wrist, though, the difference is easy to see.

casetifyadaptercolordifference
The matte silver also does not quite match the aluminum of the Apple Watch Sport, and the mismatching finishes is definitely going to be a deal breaker for some people when it comes to the Casetify bands. The incongruity between the band adapter and the Apple Watch is what bothered me most about the Casetify band, but no one seemed to notice but me.

casetifybandattachedtoapplewatch
Casetify provided me with a band that has matte black adapters, but I didn't have access to a Space Black or Space Gray Apple Watch to make a fair comparison on color. I did notice a tiny bit of chipping on the matte black Casetify adapter after I put it on my Apple Watch, so I am concerned that people who buy the matte black version might have similar problems with it. Casetify says that the chipping I saw is uncommon.

spaceblackchipping

Printed Designs


Customizability is the key feature in Casetify's Apple Watch bands, and designing a band that precisely fits your style and specifications is the main reason to purchase one of these bands. Casetify sells pre-designed Apple Watch bands in a range of colors and patterns, but you're also able to create your own using any image.

casetifyprinting2
You can upload an image or connect to Facebook or Instagram to use a photo from one of those services. Bands designs can use one, two, or five photos, and built-in tools on the site and in the app let you resize and move photos as necessary to create a desired design.

casetifybandcreator
Design wise, the possibilities are nearly endless. You can create a band with photos of kids, pets, or favorite cartoon characters, or use a more abstract design or photo. Things like flowers and sunsets turn out particularly well. A high resolution image is necessary for the best print quality, especially when using only a single image.

It's also worth taking a look through Casetify's artist's gallery for designs that have been created by others. There are a lot of whimsical, colorful designs that are fun to browse through.

Print quality on the Casetify bands is good, but it's not something that I'd describe as crisp. Up close, designs look a bit fuzzy due to the pixelated printing process, as you can see in the photo below.

casetifyprinting
At a reasonable distance, Casetify's band designs look quite nice, but I wouldn't choose a photo that has a lot of very fine detail for the printing process. Printing only covers the front of the band. The sides of the band are a light gray color, as is the back of the band.

casetifybandprintingdistance
So far, the design on my band has held up well over a week of heavy use and through attempts to damage the printing through scrubbing, twisting, bending, and rubbing. I have not been able to test the band over a long period of time, but the printing seems reasonably durable, as does the band -- it can stand up to a lot of abuse since it's made of polycarbonate.

Bottom Line


Casetify's bands are more expensive than the Apple Watch Sport band and have some caveats like their thickness and adapters that don't quite match the Apple Watch, but they're also the only Apple Watch band that's customizable, and that makes up for a lot of minor flaws.

If you want a band that's more colorful and has more personality than what you can get from Apple, or if you want to wear a band that's outfitted with pictures of your cat, Casetify's Apple Watch bands are the way to go. $70 is a lot to shell out for a band that's not quite as high-quality as the Apple Watch Sport band, but the tradeoff for customizability is worth it for Apple Watch owners who want something that stands out.

casetifybandspacegray2
One thing to keep in mind - there aren't many third-party Apple Watch bands on the market yet, and that's because Apple hasn't solidified its "Made for Apple Watch" program. Apple has published guidelines on band and adapters (lugs) for third-party accessory designers, but it's not yet approving accessories. Casetify's bands, like all current third-party bands are not "Made for Apple Watch" approved.

In the coming months, we may see a lot more band options hitting the market. For the time being, third-party bands are few and far between, so it's nice to have options like Casetify that let the Apple Watch be better customized to fit different styles and tastes.

Pros:
  • Comfortable to wear
  • Customizable -- endless designs
  • Waterproof/sweatproof
  • Fits a wide range of wrist sizes
Cons:
  • Thicker, less flexible than Apple Watch Sport band
  • Adapter's matte silver doesn't quite match Apple Watch finish
  • Matte black version coating chips easily
  • Printed designs aren't crisp

How to Buy


Casetify's Apple Watch bands can be ordered from the Casetify website or the Casetify iOS app for $70.

Related Roundups: Apple Watch, watchOS 5, watchOS 6
Buyer's Guide: Apple Watch (Buy Now)


Top Rated Comments

(View all)
Avatar
55 months ago
Those bands scream "cheap and nasty".
Rating: 3 Votes
Avatar
55 months ago
Thank you for the review. You told me everything I had wanted to know about the Casetify bands.
Rating: 3 Votes
Avatar
55 months ago

I find these straps rather fun.

However, I don't have an Apple Watch, so they're lost on me.


well for just an additional $395, you could rectify this problem. :D
Rating: 2 Votes
Avatar
55 months ago
Overpriced for what it is. You can get a third party leather band for $25. And the buckle is ugly.
Rating: 2 Votes
Avatar
55 months ago
The biggest problem I see with their printing is they only do the top surface. When the band is laying flat on a table, it doesn't look too bad, but when you wrap it around your wrist, you've got the two white unprinted ends of the band (the part that wraps around the adapters) staring up at you from right next to either side of the watch. The unprinted sides can be excused, but the unprinted ends scream "we couldn't be bothered to think this all the way through."
Rating: 1 Votes
Avatar
55 months ago

Designing your own is a really neat idea, and of course costs more than an off-the-shelf stocked model.

But I don't like that clear plastic ring/loop. A black option might look better.

Which everyone was complaining about that it cost $3 to make, and selling for $50.

I do like the idea, but to get my attention, if they can sell them for $39, I'd definitely be interested. I think this is the paperclip question...

"Would you rather sell 1 paper clip for $1,000,000, or 100,000,000 paperclips for $0.01?"

Sure, your revenue would be the same, but the odds of finding a person willing to pay $1M for a paper clip is much harder.

(OK, comedy time... It's easy if you put an Apple Logo on it! ba-dum-dum!)
Rating: 1 Votes
Avatar
55 months ago

Overpriced for what it is. You can get a third party leather band for $25. And the buckle is ugly.

Agreed. This product is so ******, just by looking at it you can almost hear the company thinking aloud, "Hey, let's take the most basic band design and cheapest materials possible and price it at extortion levels because it has something to do with Apple."
Rating: 1 Votes
Avatar
55 months ago
To switch out bands on your own, you will need a Wiha P2 screwdriver to undo the pentalobe screws holding the adapter together.
Rating: 1 Votes
Avatar
55 months ago
Designing your own is a really neat idea, and of course costs more than an off-the-shelf stocked model.

But I don't like that clear plastic ring/loop. A black option might look better.
Rating: 1 Votes
Avatar
55 months ago

Designing your own is a really neat idea, and of course costs more than an off-the-shelf stocked model.

But I don't like that clear plastic ring/loop. A black option might look better.


Yeah. I actually disliked that too, but I couldn't think of something that would be better for all of the possible designs. Maybe one that's thinner would look better. A wrap under design like the sport band would work too.
Rating: 1 Votes
[ Read All Comments ]