New in OS X: Get MacRumors Push Notifications on your Mac

Resubscribe Now Close

Apple Faces Patent Lawsuit Over iPhone's Battery Technologies

Somaltus, LLC has filed a complaint against Apple today in an Eastern Texas district court, accusing the iPhone maker of infringing upon its 2010 patent related to complex battery technologies. The small Frisco, Texas-based firm also filed lawsuits against Asus, Lenovo, Samsung, Sony, and Toshiba over the same patent.

iPhone-6s-li-on
The lawsuit claims that the iPhone 6s and any similar devices sold by Apple infringe upon U.S. Patent No. 7,657,386, titled "Integrated Battery Service System," and seeks unspecified monetary damages or, alternatively, a running royalty on sales of infringing devices from the time of judgment going forward.
Defendant sells, offers to sell, and/or uses telephones including, without limitation, the iPhone 6s (the "Product"), for example, and any similar devices, which infringe at least Claim 1 of the ‘386 Patent.

On information and belief, the Product includes a battery service system including a processor (e.g., the A9 chip), which is configured to receive signals from connectors coupled to a battery (e.g., the Product's rechargeable lithium-ion battery).
Specifically, it appears that the infringement claim at least partially relates to the iPhone's process of charging in fast-charge mode until the battery reaches 80% capacity, and then adjusting to trickle-charge mode above 80% capacity.
On information and belief, the processor executes the control codes to continually adjust a charge level to the battery. The Product has a charging system according to which the system operates in fast-charge mode until the battery reaches 80% capacity and then adjusts to trickle-charge mode when the capacity exceeds 80%. When the capacity drops below 80%, the system gain adjusts to fast-charge operation. The purpose of the system is to reduce the charging level applied to the battery at high capacity in order to extend the battery lifespan. Thus, the system adjusts the charging level applied to the battery and does so continuously as the battery charge capacity repeatedly exceeds and drops below 80%.
Somaltus, LLC generally fits the description of a "patent troll," as it does not appear to provide any obvious products or services and lacks an easily identifiable online presence. Nevertheless, it has successfully reached out-of-court settlements with automakers like Ford and Nissan in the past in relation to the same particular patent.

The legal complaint's case number is 2:16-cv-00758 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas.



Top Rated Comments

(View all)

34 months ago
i honestly dont understand how one can still innovate something these days without falling into the trap of some patent troll.
Rating: 27 Votes
34 months ago

Can we sue Apple etc for their battery technology being utterly useless?

No, but you can buy phones from other companies that meet your needs.
Rating: 24 Votes
34 months ago
Apple faces new patent infringement charges every two days. This is getting ridiculous...
Rating: 17 Votes
34 months ago
That's it; now Jony's just gonna have to get rid of the battery altogether.

Now's your chance, bud.
Rating: 17 Votes
34 months ago
How to be a patent troll:

1. Find a technology everyone uses.
2. Create and patent the obvious next iteration of said technology.
3. Wait for everyone to upgrade their technology to the next obvious iteration.
4. Sue everyone.
Rating: 14 Votes
34 months ago
For crying out loud, this isn't even patent worthy. People had been doing this with manual battery chargers long before Lithium batteries were even imagined.
Rating: 11 Votes
34 months ago

Can we sue Apple etc for their battery technology being utterly useless?


You must still use the first 8GB iPhone.

My 6S Plus 128GB easily lasts all day, every day.
[doublepost=1468351607][/doublepost]

Good, make them stop using it. It sucks. Love having to charge my phone twice a day plus overnight, and I have a 6s so not like it's old.


You are charging it wrong!
Rating: 7 Votes
34 months ago
Can we sue Apple etc for their battery technology being utterly useless?
Rating: 4 Votes
34 months ago
The patent system either has to be hugely revamped, or thrown out altogether. And I'm not saying this as just a defense of Apple, they play the game as well as anybody.

It's like, without any idea how to actually make one, I could have patented "A rectangle with a screen on one side to be used as a phone' 15 years ago and now sued ALL the current smartphone makers. Just complete BS.
Rating: 4 Votes
34 months ago

i honestly dont understand how one can still innovate something these days without falling into the trap of some patent troll.


You can still innovate. It's typically only once you're successful that the troll will come knocking.
Rating: 3 Votes

[ Read All Comments ]