Skip to Content

Apple Loses Appeal to Delay E-Books Antitrust Monitorship But Gains Boundaries

by

iBooksThe U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New York today ruled that Michael Bromwich, the lawyer assigned to monitor Apple's antitrust compliance policies, may continue with his duties while Apple continues to pursue another appeal to remove its monitorship all together.

Back in early January, Apple requested that U.S. District Judge Denise Cote disqualify Bromwich from his monitorship because he had demonstrated personal bias against the company. Apple asked for both a stay on the original order requiring an external monitor and the removal of Bromwich, both requests that Cote denied.

Apple did manage to win a brief emergency stay as the Appeals court examined its request for a longer stay, but with today's decision, Bromwich will be able to continue on as monitor.

The ruling did, however, limit some of Bromwich's power, suggesting that he is not able to demand access to any document or interview Apple executives with respect to any subject.

Thus, according to appellees, the monitor was empowered to demand only documents relevant to his authorized responsibility as so defined, and to interview Apple directors, officers, and employees only on subjects relevant to that responsibility.

We agree with that interpretation of the district court’s order. In addition, we take counsel’s statement as a formal representation that appellees also accept that interpretation, and that the monitor will conduct his activities within the bounds of that order, absent further action by the district court or by the panel that will in due course hear the merits of the appeal

Apple's antitrust monitor was originally put in place after the company was found guilty in July 2013 of conspiring with five publishers to raise the prices of e-books. Since then, Apple and Bromwich have engaged in several back and forth disputes stemming from Bromwich's fees and his insistence on interviewing key Apple executives.

Bromwich, for his part, has said he has seen a "surprising and disappointing lack of cooperation from Apple and its executives."

Apple's second appeal, which requests the removal of Bromwich entirely and questions Cote's decision to appoint a monitor, is ongoing.

Top Rated Comments

167 months ago
I'd say that's a good compromise. That he stops annoying people like Ive or Gore, who have nothing to see with the iBook saga...
Exactly. Neither of them had anything to do with this- going after them was nothing more than a power trip.
Score: 3 Votes (Like | Disagree)
167 months ago
I'd say that's a good compromise. That he stops annoying people like Ive or Gore, who have nothing to see with the iBook saga...
Score: 2 Votes (Like | Disagree)
167 months ago
I'd say that's a good compromise. That he stops annoying people like Ive or Gore, who have nothing to see with the iBook saga...

I can see it now,

Bromwich: 'So Mr Ive what do you know about the contractual issues surrounding iBooks?'

Ive: 'Nothing'

Bromwich: 'This is intolerable. These Apple directors are being difficult, we must tell the judge immediately so that my power to investigate can be widened.'

So in summary, this is a total wast of everyone's time because they already have all the documents and emails and cross examination from the original court proceedings.:rolleyes:
Score: 1 Votes (Like | Disagree)
rdlink Avatar
167 months ago
The winner is this idiot Bromwich, he's charging Apple $900/hr. to fight Apple.
Damn, for that kind of money, I'll fight day & night too.

If he's able to charge them $900 an hour to annoy them I'd say he's not too much of an idiot...:D
Score: 1 Votes (Like | Disagree)

Popular Stories

Apple 2026 Black Friday Event Hero

Apple Announces 2026 Black Friday Event, Here's What You Can Get

Thursday November 19, 2026 9:11 am PST by
Apple's annual four-day Black Friday through Cyber Monday shopping event is returning on Friday, November 27 through Monday, November 30 in many countries, including the United States, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, the United Kingdom, Belgium, the Netherlands, Sweden, Thailand, and others. In the U.S., Apple's terms and conditions say the promotion begins on...
apple design award 2025

Apple Announces 2025 Design Award Winners Ahead of WWDC 2025

Tuesday June 3, 2025 10:14 am PDT by
As we wait for WWDC to kick off next Monday, Apple today announced the winners of its annual Apple Design Awards, recognizing apps and games for their innovation, ingenuity, and technical achievement. The 2025 Apple Design Award winners are listed below, with one app and one game selected per category: Delight and Fun - CapWords (App) and Balatro (Game) Innovation - Play (App) and PBJ -...
Apple Support Community

Tomorrow Marks the End of a 28-Year Era at Apple

Thursday November 19, 2026 7:08 am PST by
Apple previously announced that the Apple Support Community discussion forums for user-to-user tech support will be permanently closing this Friday, November 20. The forums have existed in some form for 28 years. It is the end of an era. It is our understanding that the forums will eventually be removed entirely, meaning that existing posts will no longer be visible. However, it is not clear ...
Latest Stories
Apple Black Friday Deals Available Now: AirPods, Apple Watches, MacBooks, and More
Apple Black Friday Deals Available Now: AirPods, Apple Watches, MacBooks, and More
22 hours ago
Apple Store in UK Permanently Closing Today
Apple Store in UK Permanently Closing Today
22 hours ago
Siri AI Settlement: Here's How Much Apple Will Pay You
Siri AI Settlement: Here's How Much Apple Will Pay You
22 hours ago
RIP, Apple Support Community
RIP, Apple Support Community
22 hours ago
Top Stories: iPhone Duo Face Unlock, HomeView Tidbits, and More
Top Stories: iPhone Duo Face Unlock, HomeView Tidbits, and More
1 day ago
Amazon Takes $120 Off 46mm GPS Apple Watch Series 12 With New Record Low Price [Update: Gone]
Amazon Takes $120 Off 46mm GPS Apple Watch Series 12 With New Record Low Price [Update: Gone]
1 day ago
Siri Recap Hands-On: Private, But Not Very Useful
Siri Recap Hands-On: Private, But Not Very Useful
2 days ago
Save on Headphones This Black Friday With Major Deals on Beats, Sony, Soundcore, and More
Save on Headphones This Black Friday With Major Deals on Beats, Sony, Soundcore, and More
2 days ago
MacRumors Giveaway: Win a 512GB OLED iPad Mini and a Year of Astropad Workbench
MacRumors Giveaway: Win a 512GB OLED iPad Mini and a Year of Astropad Workbench
2 days ago
The MacRumors Show: What's Next for iPhone Duo?
The MacRumors Show: What's Next for iPhone Duo?
2 days ago
Anker's Black Friday Steals: The Lowest Prices Yet on MagSafe Favorites
Anker's Black Friday Steals: The Lowest Prices Yet on MagSafe Favorites
2 days ago
Microsoft to Retire 'To Do' Apps Next Year
Microsoft to Retire 'To Do' Apps Next Year
2 days ago
First Look at iPhone Air 2 and iPhone 18 Revealed By Dummy Models
First Look at iPhone Air 2 and iPhone 18 Revealed By Dummy Models
2 days ago
WhatsApp Raises Group Chat Limit to 1,500 Members
WhatsApp Raises Group Chat Limit to 1,500 Members
2 days ago
MacBook Pro Black Friday Deals Are Here: Get Up to $250 Off M6 and PROLED XDR
MacBook Pro Black Friday Deals Are Here: Get Up to $250 Off M6 and PROLED XDR
3 days ago
Apple is Building an AI Agent That Can Use Apps and Code
Apple is Building an AI Agent That Can Use Apps and Code
3 days ago
Black Friday Deal: Apple TV Streaming Service for $6.99/Month
Black Friday Deal: Apple TV Streaming Service for $6.99/Month
3 days ago
AirPods Black Friday Deals Hit Pro 3 at $179 and Max 2 at $429
AirPods Black Friday Deals Hit Pro 3 at $179 and Max 2 at $429
3 days ago
Second iOS 27.3 and macOS Golden Gate 27.3 Public Betas Now Available
Second iOS 27.3 and macOS Golden Gate 27.3 Public Betas Now Available
3 days ago
Google's Gemini Can Now Control Apps on Your Mac
Google's Gemini Can Now Control Apps on Your Mac
3 days ago
iPhone Duo vs. Samsung Galaxy Z Fold8: Which is Better?
iPhone Duo vs. Samsung Galaxy Z Fold8: Which is Better?
3 days ago
Apple Executive in Charge of iPhone's Camera App Reportedly Retires
Apple Executive in Charge of iPhone's Camera App Reportedly Retires
3 days ago
Apple Announces 2026 Black Friday Event, Here's What You Can Get
Apple Announces 2026 Black Friday Event, Here's What You Can Get
3 days ago
Sonos Black Friday Sale Takes Up to 25% Off Speakers, Soundbars, and More
Sonos Black Friday Sale Takes Up to 25% Off Speakers, Soundbars, and More
3 days ago
Apple TV to Stream Female 'F1 Academy' Races in U.S. Starting in 2027
Apple TV to Stream Female 'F1 Academy' Races in U.S. Starting in 2027
3 days ago
Tomorrow Marks the End of a 28-Year Era at Apple
Tomorrow Marks the End of a 28-Year Era at Apple
3 days ago
Amazon Takes $200 Off Every Apple Studio Display for Black Friday
Amazon Takes $200 Off Every Apple Studio Display for Black Friday
3 days ago
UK Loses Secrecy Fight Over Apple 'Backdoor' Order
UK Loses Secrecy Fight Over Apple 'Backdoor' Order
3 days ago
Beats 360 Black Friday Deal Arrives With Massive $100 Discount on Amazon
Beats 360 Black Friday Deal Arrives With Massive $100 Discount on Amazon
3 days ago
Apple Music Radio Now Reaches Over 50 Million Monthly Listeners
Apple Music Radio Now Reaches Over 50 Million Monthly Listeners
3 days ago