Apple Loses Appeal to Delay E-Books Antitrust Monitorship But Gains Boundaries - MacRumors
Skip to Content

Apple Loses Appeal to Delay E-Books Antitrust Monitorship But Gains Boundaries

by

iBooksThe U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New York today ruled that Michael Bromwich, the lawyer assigned to monitor Apple's antitrust compliance policies, may continue with his duties while Apple continues to pursue another appeal to remove its monitorship all together.

Back in early January, Apple requested that U.S. District Judge Denise Cote disqualify Bromwich from his monitorship because he had demonstrated personal bias against the company. Apple asked for both a stay on the original order requiring an external monitor and the removal of Bromwich, both requests that Cote denied.

Apple did manage to win a brief emergency stay as the Appeals court examined its request for a longer stay, but with today's decision, Bromwich will be able to continue on as monitor.

The ruling did, however, limit some of Bromwich's power, suggesting that he is not able to demand access to any document or interview Apple executives with respect to any subject.

Thus, according to appellees, the monitor was empowered to demand only documents relevant to his authorized responsibility as so defined, and to interview Apple directors, officers, and employees only on subjects relevant to that responsibility.

We agree with that interpretation of the district court’s order. In addition, we take counsel’s statement as a formal representation that appellees also accept that interpretation, and that the monitor will conduct his activities within the bounds of that order, absent further action by the district court or by the panel that will in due course hear the merits of the appeal

Apple's antitrust monitor was originally put in place after the company was found guilty in July 2013 of conspiring with five publishers to raise the prices of e-books. Since then, Apple and Bromwich have engaged in several back and forth disputes stemming from Bromwich's fees and his insistence on interviewing key Apple executives.

Bromwich, for his part, has said he has seen a "surprising and disappointing lack of cooperation from Apple and its executives."

Apple's second appeal, which requests the removal of Bromwich entirely and questions Cote's decision to appoint a monitor, is ongoing.

Top Rated Comments

167 months ago
I'd say that's a good compromise. That he stops annoying people like Ive or Gore, who have nothing to see with the iBook saga...
Exactly. Neither of them had anything to do with this- going after them was nothing more than a power trip.
Score: 3 Votes (Like | Disagree)
167 months ago
I'd say that's a good compromise. That he stops annoying people like Ive or Gore, who have nothing to see with the iBook saga...
Score: 2 Votes (Like | Disagree)
167 months ago
I'd say that's a good compromise. That he stops annoying people like Ive or Gore, who have nothing to see with the iBook saga...

I can see it now,

Bromwich: 'So Mr Ive what do you know about the contractual issues surrounding iBooks?'

Ive: 'Nothing'

Bromwich: 'This is intolerable. These Apple directors are being difficult, we must tell the judge immediately so that my power to investigate can be widened.'

So in summary, this is a total wast of everyone's time because they already have all the documents and emails and cross examination from the original court proceedings.:rolleyes:
Score: 1 Votes (Like | Disagree)
rdlink Avatar
167 months ago
The winner is this idiot Bromwich, he's charging Apple $900/hr. to fight Apple.
Damn, for that kind of money, I'll fight day & night too.

If he's able to charge them $900 an hour to annoy them I'd say he's not too much of an idiot...:D
Score: 1 Votes (Like | Disagree)

Popular Stories

iPhone Duo Outer Display Hand

Apple Aiming to Upgrade the iPhone Duo in Four Ways

Sunday November 15, 2026 8:42 am PST by
Bloomberg's Mark Gurman today said Apple has four goals for future iPhone Duo models: Face ID, an Action button, a telephoto camera, and a thinner-and-lighter design. Gurman said Apple has already developed iPhone Duo 2 prototypes with Face ID on the outer display, but it is "running out of time" to finalize the feature for that model, so it might not arrive until the iPhone Duo...
iphone duo yellow hand

Apple Adds Facial Unlock Option on iPhone Duo in iOS 27.3

Monday November 16, 2026 10:17 am PST by
Apple today added a new option for unlocking the iPhone Duo using the front-facing camera, giving device users multiple ways to access their content. The feature is available in the second iOS 27.3 beta. The option to unlock with facial recognition is only available on the Lock Screen, and authentication via Touch ID is still needed for Apple Pay purchases, adding passwords and logins, and...
apple pro tell logo

Apple Launches Two Products Today

Friday November 13, 2026 2:37 am PST by
Apple is releasing two new products today, Friday, November 13: the all-new Apple HomeView and the fourth-generation Apple TV 4K, both of which have been available to pre-order since mid-October. Apple HomeView: Apple's new smart home display, powered by Apple Intelligence with Siri AI, for entertainment and managing the home. Available in tabletop and wall-mounted models, it can recognize up...
Latest Stories
Everything New in iOS 27.3 Beta 2
Everything New in iOS 27.3 Beta 2
57 minutes ago
Apple Plans to Release These 18 New Products Next Year
Apple Plans to Release These 18 New Products Next Year
3 hours ago
New Apple TV 4K Discount Returns at Amazon
New Apple TV 4K Discount Returns at Amazon
3 hours ago
iPhone Duo Orders Will Now Arrive Before the Holidays
iPhone Duo Orders Will Now Arrive Before the Holidays
3 hours ago
Hands-On With the iPhone Duo's New Face Unlock
Hands-On With the iPhone Duo's New Face Unlock
4 hours ago
macOS 27.3 Warns Against Giving AI Apps Full Mac Control
macOS 27.3 Warns Against Giving AI Apps Full Mac Control
4 hours ago
iPad and Mac Get Apple Intelligence in China in 27.3 Betas
iPad and Mac Get Apple Intelligence in China in 27.3 Betas
5 hours ago
Apple News+ Puzzles Come to UK, Australia, and French Canada
Apple News+ Puzzles Come to UK, Australia, and French Canada
6 hours ago
macOS Golden Gate 27.3 Beta 2 Now Available for Developers
macOS Golden Gate 27.3 Beta 2 Now Available for Developers
6 hours ago
Apple Celebrates Pokémon With iPhone Wallpapers and Special Gift Card
Apple Celebrates Pokémon With iPhone Wallpapers and Special Gift Card
6 hours ago
Apple TV App Gets Video Podcasts in iOS 27.3
Apple TV App Gets Video Podcasts in iOS 27.3
6 hours ago
Best Early AirPods Black Friday Deals Include AirPods Pro 3 for $179
Best Early AirPods Black Friday Deals Include AirPods Pro 3 for $179
7 hours ago
iOS 27.3 Adds 'Ask About Page' Siri AI Feature to Safari
iOS 27.3 Adds 'Ask About Page' Siri AI Feature to Safari
7 hours ago
Apple Says More Than 200,000 Apps Now Optimized for iPhone Duo
Apple Says More Than 200,000 Apps Now Optimized for iPhone Duo
7 hours ago
Apple Adds Facial Unlock Option on iPhone Duo in iOS 27.3
Apple Adds Facial Unlock Option on iPhone Duo in iOS 27.3
7 hours ago
iOS 27.3 Beta Adds Daily Siri AI Limits and iCloud+ Upgrades
iOS 27.3 Beta Adds Daily Siri AI Limits and iCloud+ Upgrades
7 hours ago
iOS 27.3 Beta 2 Now Available for Developers
iOS 27.3 Beta 2 Now Available for Developers
7 hours ago
Apple Launches Spanish Version of Its U.S. Website
Apple Launches Spanish Version of Its U.S. Website
7 hours ago
Apple Releases Second watchOS 27.3, tvOS 27.3 and visionOS 27.3 Betas
Apple Releases Second watchOS 27.3, tvOS 27.3 and visionOS 27.3 Betas
7 hours ago
Some OLED MacBook Pro Owners Report Eye Strain and Dizziness
Some OLED MacBook Pro Owners Report Eye Strain and Dizziness
7 hours ago
Didn't Order Apple's HomeView Yet? Wait Times Are Significant Now
Didn't Order Apple's HomeView Yet? Wait Times Are Significant Now
9 hours ago
Apple Pushes Back Against Canada's Plan to Access User Data
Apple Pushes Back Against Canada's Plan to Access User Data
9 hours ago
Black Friday TV Deals Include Year's Best Prices on Samsung, Sony, LG, and Many More
Black Friday TV Deals Include Year's Best Prices on Samsung, Sony, LG, and Many More
10 hours ago
Adobe's Black Friday Sale Takes 57% Off Creative Cloud Pro for Your First Year
Adobe's Black Friday Sale Takes 57% Off Creative Cloud Pro for Your First Year
10 hours ago
Apple's New HomeView Smart Home Hub Has Issues, Say Owners
Apple's New HomeView Smart Home Hub Has Issues, Say Owners
11 hours ago
'Slow Horses' to Hit 10-Season Milestone With Apple TV Renewal
'Slow Horses' to Hit 10-Season Milestone With Apple TV Renewal
11 hours ago
Apple Watch SE 3 Black Friday Deals Arrive With $50 Off Every Model
Apple Watch SE 3 Black Friday Deals Arrive With $50 Off Every Model
11 hours ago
Apple Confirms iOS 27.3 Beta 2 Coming Today
Apple Confirms iOS 27.3 Beta 2 Coming Today
11 hours ago
'iPhone 20 Pro' Rumored to Be Based on iPhone Air
'iPhone 20 Pro' Rumored to Be Based on iPhone Air
12 hours ago
iPhone 20 Pro Rumored to Feature New 17nm Camera Sensor
iPhone 20 Pro Rumored to Feature New 17nm Camera Sensor
13 hours ago