Twitter Kills Quote Tweet Prompt, Returns Retweet Action to Original Behavior

Back in August, Twitter began calling retweets with comments Quote Tweets, and a couple of months later the social media platform changed the way retweets worked so that users were prompted to Quote Tweet a retweet first before deciding to share it.

twitterquotetweets
Users didn't have to type anything in the quote tweet prompt, and could still retweet with no added context. Still, the idea behind the small change was to encourage more thoughtful amplification of tweets, so that users didn't just mindlessly retweet something without due consideration.

However, it turns out that the tweak didn't have the intended effect, as Twitter explained on Wednesday in a blog post.

We hoped this change would encourage thoughtful amplification and also increase the likelihood that people would add their own thoughts, reactions and perspectives to the conversation. However, we observed that prompting Quote Tweets didn't appear to increase context: 45% of additional Quote Tweets included just a single word and 70% contained less than 25 characters.

Twitter said it also saw a 20% decrease in retweets and quote tweets while the automatic quote tweet prompt was active. As a result, Twitter is reverting the retweet action to its original behavior, and users will no longer see the Quote Tweet prompt when they tap the Retweet button.

Tag: Twitter

Top Rated Comments

Rogifan Avatar
11 months ago
The problem with Twitter isn’t Twitter it’s human beings. They keep trying different tweaks to change human behavior and keep finding out that it doesn’t work.
Score: 8 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Reason077 Avatar
11 months ago

Twitter said it also saw a 20% decrease in retweets and quote tweets while the automatic quote tweet prompt was active.
That sounds like a positive result to me. Requiring users to put slightly more thought into a retweet resulted in less mindless re-tweeting?
Score: 8 Votes (Like | Disagree)
CarlJ Avatar
11 months ago

How exactly is encouraging people to add their own thoughts to a quote they are sharing “stifling” their speech or “forcing them to speak in a way that they disagree with”?
Indeed, and the bigger picture is they’re talking about a private company that has no power to force anyone to do anything. There’s no Twitter Goon Squad who came to their house and forced them to (sign up for a Twitter account and) tweet specific things that they disagree with. Too many seem to think that Twitter is some sort of government-run public utility. It’s not.

If Twitter wanted to establish a new rule that, say, no one could post any new tweets that contained vowels, that’s entirely within Twitter’s rights - it might be a very unpopular decision, but it wouldn’t be an illegal one, and it wouldn’t be “Twitter forcing people to post only consonants”, it would be “people choosing to continue using Twitter and posting consonant-only tweets after Twitter enacts new rule”.

It feels sometimes like those who crow the loudest about capitalism and free enterprise and others being snowflakes, don’t really believe in what they've been spouting, the moment it affects them.
Score: 3 Votes (Like | Disagree)
sdf Avatar
11 months ago

Twitter said it also saw a 20% decrease in retweets and quote tweets while the automatic quote tweet prompt was active.
This is a case of Twitter getting exactly the effect they wanted, then realizing they don't want it.

Or maybe I'm not being cynical enough. Maybe they just wanted it during the US election.
Score: 3 Votes (Like | Disagree)
scottishwildcat Avatar
11 months ago

How exactly is encouraging people to add their own thoughts to a quote they are sharing “stifling” their speech or “forcing them to speak in a way that they disagree with”?
Almost word for word what I was about to say.
Score: 3 Votes (Like | Disagree)
calstanford Avatar
11 months ago
A product still looking for it's purpose and raison d'etre
Score: 1 Votes (Like | Disagree)

Related Stories

twitter verified featured

Twitter Resumes Verified Account Program, Previews New 'About' Tab on Profiles

Thursday May 20, 2021 8:59 am PDT by
Twitter today announced it will begin rolling out a new application process for account verification, allowing for qualifying individuals like government officials, journalists, athletes, and recognizable brands to apply for verified status. Verified accounts have a blue checkmark icon next to their Twitter name, helping people distinguish the authenticity of accounts that are of public...
twitter blue

Twitter Confirms Plans for 'Twitter Blue' $2.99 Monthly Subscription Service

Thursday May 27, 2021 3:29 pm PDT by
Twitter appears to have mistakenly confirmed its plans to launch a new subscription tier called "Twitter Blue," with the new purchase option now listed in the iOS App Store. Under In-App Purchases, there's now a "Twitter Blue" option that's priced at $2.99, though the feature does not appear to be live in the iOS app at this time. The Twitter Blue in-app purchase option was discovered by...
app tracking transparency twitter

Twitter Begins Asking Users to Enable Ad Tracking

Friday May 14, 2021 2:12 pm PDT by
Following an app update, Twitter today began asking users to enable ad tracking under Apple's App Tracking Transparency rules. After updating to version 8.65, which adds Spaces support, Twitter users will begin seeing a popup that asks them to "keep ads relevant" by allowing Twitter to track data from other companies like apps used and websites visited. Tapping "Continue" on the popup...
Twitter Feature

Twitter Opens Spaces to All Users With More Than 600 Followers

Monday May 3, 2021 10:31 am PDT by
Beginning on Monday, Twitter will enable anyone with at least 600 followers on its platform to host Spaces, its version of the audio room network Clubhouse. Announced via a blog post, Twitter says that its decision to open up the functionality to users with at least 600 followers came following feedback from Twitter users and the community. Spaces originally launched last year, but so far...
wwdc 2021 details

Reliable Leaker Suggests No MacBook Pro or Other Hardware Announcements at WWDC Today

Monday June 7, 2021 5:13 am PDT by
In response to a tweet asking if there will be hardware announcements at WWDC 2021, cryptic but reliable leaker "l0vetodream" suggested there won't be any. In a follow-up tweet, he seems to have ruled out new 14-inch and 16-inch MacBook Pro models being unveiled at this time, suggesting that it is still too early for an announcement. Leading up to WWDC, which kicks off today with Apple's...
Twitter Feature

'Twitter Blue' Subscription Announced, Launches in Canada and Australia First

Thursday June 3, 2021 7:16 am PDT by
Twitter has today announced "Twitter Blue," a new subscription service that features the ability to undo and bookmark Tweets, a reader mode, color theme options, and more. Twitter describes the new subscription as giving "access to exclusive features and perks that will take their experience on Twitter to the next level." Twitter Blue currently features: Bookmark Folders: A way to...
WWDC 2021 Twitter Hashflag

WWDC 2021 Twitter Hashflag Goes Live

Tuesday June 1, 2021 9:43 pm PDT by
Ahead of the beginning of this year's WWDC, Apple has set out another marketing campaign on Twitter by enabling a special Twitter hashflag with the "#WWDC21" hashtag across the social network. This year's hashflag includes an icon resembling the thumbs-up Tapback effect from iMessage. According to Jane Manchun Wong's Hashflag Browser, the new hashflag will last until June 6, one day short...
twitter fleet example

Twitter Launches Ephemeral Tweets Called 'Fleets' for All Users

Tuesday November 17, 2020 1:27 pm PST by
Twitter today announced the worldwide launch of a new ephemeral tweet option called a "Fleet," which will last for 24 hours on the social network before disappearing. Much like stories on Instagram or Facebook, fleets are located at the top of the Twitter timeline. Fleets have no retweets, likes, or public comments, do not show up in search or moments, and cannot be embedded on external...
twitterquotetweets

Twitter Makes Retweets With Comments Easier to Find

Monday August 31, 2020 4:37 pm PDT by
Twitter today announced the official rollout of its new Quote Tweets feature, which is designed to make tweets about a tweet easier to located. Twitter is now calling retweets with comments Quote Tweets, and Quote Tweets are now visible when tapping into a tweet and selecting the "Quote Tweets" option to see all quoted replies in one spot. Viewing Quote Tweets shows the original tweet...
twitter combined feature

Twitter App for iOS Now Supports Larger Image Previews in Timeline

Wednesday May 5, 2021 1:51 pm PDT by
Twitter today announced that the Twitter for iOS app supports larger image previews in the timeline, which means tall images will no longer be cropped to a significant degree in the Twitter app. Twitter has been testing larger-sized image previews on iOS and Android since March, but now the expanded image previews are rolling out for everyone. no bird too tall, no crop too shortintroducing ...