WhatsApp Backs Apple in Legal Fight Against UK Encryption Demands - MacRumors
Skip to Content

WhatsApp Backs Apple in Legal Fight Against UK Encryption Demands

WhatsApp plans to support Apple in its ongoing legal battle with the UK Home Office over user data privacy, the messaging platform's boss Will Cathcart has told the BBC.

iCloud Versus UK Key Feature
The Meta-owned service warned that the case "could set a dangerous precedent" by encouraging other governments to demand access to encrypted communications.

Apple launched legal action after receiving a secret government notice earlier this year demanding backdoor access to encrypted iCloud data worldwide. The UK used its Investigatory Powers Act to require Apple to compromise its Advanced Data Protection feature, which encrypts user photos, notes, messages, and device backups.

Rather than comply, Apple pulled the encryption feature from UK users entirely in February.

"WhatsApp would challenge any law or government request that seeks to weaken the encryption of our services," Cathcart said. The company vowed to continue defending users' "right to a private conversation online."

The encryption controversy has drawn criticism from American politicians, with some calling it a "dangerous attack on US cybersecurity." Tulsi Gabbard, director of US National Intelligence, described the UK's demands as an "egregious violation" of US citizens' privacy.

A UK court rejected the government's attempt to keep details of Apple's legal challenge secret. Judges ruled that conducting hearings entirely in private would be "truly extraordinary."

The Home Office has defended its position, saying the government's "first priority" is keeping people safe while protecting privacy. Officials argue the powers help investigate serious crimes including terrorism and child abuse.

Apple maintains that creating backdoors would inevitably compromise security for all users, making them vulnerable to malicious actors.

Note: Due to the political or social nature of the discussion regarding this topic, the discussion thread is located in our Political News forum. All forum members and site visitors are welcome to read and follow the thread, but posting is limited to forum members with at least 100 posts.

Popular Stories

Apple Store Wallpaper Basic Apple Guy

Apple Store in UK Reopening on iPhone Duo Launch Day

Friday October 2, 2026 7:17 am PDT by
Following more than three months of renovations, the Apple SouthGate store in Bath, England will be reopening on Friday, October 23, just in time for iPhone Duo launch day. Last year, Apple permanently closed its store in the heart of nearby Bristol, but Apple Cribbs Causeway remains open inside a shopping center on the outskirts of the city. In other UK store news, Apple Lakeside in Essex was ...
apple tim cook kings trust

Apple Launches Creative Labs Program With The King's Trust

Wednesday October 7, 2026 2:29 pm PDT by
Apple is partnering with UK charity The King's Trust to launch a new education program that will help young people build careers in creative industries, Apple said today. The Apple x King's Trust Creative Labs will give people aged 18 to 30 the opportunity to work with Apple experts as they look into different career paths. An initial cohort of up to 20 people is participating in...
homeview calendar

Apple's HomeView Touts These 5 Privacy Features

Tuesday October 13, 2026 7:31 am PDT by
Apple uses a number of methods to keep HomeView users' personal information private, even when a whole household shares the device. The device recognizes up to six people, giving each their own Home Screen with personalized apps and widgets. Apple says personal content stays private to each user, while shared photo albums and music can remain available to everyone in the household, including ...

Top Rated Comments

Joseph C Avatar
18 months ago

If you're not guilty of committing a crime (and don't plan on doing so), why get so worked up about this? Are we so paranoid as to believe that a worker at the Home Office is going to randomly access a person's messages for a laugh? We have the least amount of privacy ever; a person can literally walk down the road and record videos of you without you even knowing, then share it online where it will be forever available - but I'm not going to Hogwarts to rob the invisible cloak.
"Ultimately, arguing that you don't care about the right to privacy because you have nothing to hide is no different than saying you don't care about free speech because you have nothing to say."
Score: 35 Votes (Like | Disagree)
18 months ago

If you're not guilty of committing a crime (and don't plan on doing so), why get so worked up about this?
Literally the sentence every single totalitarian regime in the world has used throughout history to justify mass and intrusive surveillance of its population.

I am not British myself, but I find it truly sad that some people can resort to the same justification of mass surveillance without realising what the eventual implications are, in the country of George Orwell who saw and brilliantly exposed those issues decades ago.
Score: 31 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Moonjumper Avatar
18 months ago

If you're not guilty of committing a crime (and don't plan on doing so), why get so worked up about this? Are we so paranoid as to believe that a worker at the Home Office is going to randomly access a person's messages for a laugh? We have the least amount of privacy ever; a person can literally walk down the road and record videos of you without you even knowing, then share it online where it will be forever available - but I'm not going to Hogwarts to rob the invisible cloak.
Because it requires a backdoor. Once there is a backdoor, others will find a way in, such as criminals.
Score: 26 Votes (Like | Disagree)
cjsuk Avatar
18 months ago

If you're not guilty of committing a crime (and don't plan on doing so), why get so worked up about this? Are we so paranoid as to believe that a worker at the Home Office is going to randomly access a person's messages for a laugh? We have the least amount of privacy ever; a person can literally walk down the road and record videos of you without you even knowing, then share it online where it will be forever available - but I'm not going to Hogwarts to rob the invisible cloak.
Well say you're gay. Then they record all your conversations, because they can. Then they make being gay illegal. Then you're ****ed. That's why.
Score: 18 Votes (Like | Disagree)
SpaceMagic Avatar
18 months ago
To people who think "I have nothing to hide, so why is this a problem", just remember that the following things were once illegal, and still are in several countries worldwide:


* interracial marriage
* same sex relationships
* protest
* cohabitation without marriage
* alcohol
* tattoos
* dancing
* accessing foreign media
* forming unions
* women working certain professions
* cannabis
* caffeine
* birth control
* travel without a man
* teaching about evolution
* reading certain books
* speaking certain languages
* and many many more

So you may think you have nothing to hide today, but who knows what you'll have to hide tomorrow.

We all want certain crimes to be pursued and prosecuted (terrorism / abuse of minors / etc), but there are a multitude of other ways these acts can be uncovered or, better, prevented (let's start with educational and health inequality, a rethinking of the way we design housing and communities, financial inequalities...). Do we want the rights of all to be eroded due to the acts (albeit sometimes heinous) of very, very few.
Score: 17 Votes (Like | Disagree)
18 months ago

If you're not guilty of committing a crime (and don't plan on doing so), why get so worked up about this? Are we so paranoid as to believe that a worker at the Home Office is going to randomly access a person's messages for a laugh? We have the least amount of privacy ever; a person can literally walk down the road and record videos of you without you even knowing, then share it online where it will be forever available - but I'm not going to Hogwarts to rob the invisible cloak.
So thought the German Jews in the 1920s when their religious views were registered. A decade later, being Jewish was punishable by death.

Especially with what we’re seeing in the states currently, this topic should not be up for debate 😬

Learn from history - or be bound to repeat it!
Score: 17 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Latest Stories
Anker and Jackery Offer Prime Day Encore Discounts on Power Stations
Anker and Jackery Offer Prime Day Encore Discounts on Power Stations
53 minutes ago
New Apple TV 4K and Siri Remote Have These 14 New Features
New Apple TV 4K and Siri Remote Have These 14 New Features
56 minutes ago
HomeView Runs Third-Party Apps From Your iPhone or iPad
HomeView Runs Third-Party Apps From Your iPhone or iPad
1 hour ago
RIP, homeOS
RIP, homeOS
2 hours ago
New Apple TV 4K Supports Surround Sound via Four HomePods
New Apple TV 4K Supports Surround Sound via Four HomePods
2 hours ago
Apple Says HomePod Mini 2 Won't Support Siri AI Right Away
Apple Says HomePod Mini 2 Won't Support Siri AI Right Away
2 hours ago
HomeView Can Dim to Apple's Lowest-Ever Display Brightness
HomeView Can Dim to Apple's Lowest-Ever Display Brightness
2 hours ago
New Apple TV 4K Adds Far-Field Microphones for Hands-Free Siri
New Apple TV 4K Adds Far-Field Microphones for Hands-Free Siri
2 hours ago
Apple Details HomeView's Audio Hardware
Apple Details HomeView's Audio Hardware
3 hours ago
Apple Shares Videos for HomeView, Apple TV 4K, and HomePod Mini 2
Apple Shares Videos for HomeView, Apple TV 4K, and HomePod Mini 2
3 hours ago
HomeView Comes in Four Colors, but Wall-Mounted Model Gets Just Two
HomeView Comes in Four Colors, but Wall-Mounted Model Gets Just Two
3 hours ago
Older Apple TV 4K Models to Gain Apple Intelligence and Siri AI Support
Older Apple TV 4K Models to Gain Apple Intelligence and Siri AI Support
3 hours ago
HomeView Brings Guided Recipes and Hands-Free Timers to the Kitchen
HomeView Brings Guided Recipes and Hands-Free Timers to the Kitchen
3 hours ago
New Siri Remote is $59 and Compatible With These Apple TV Models
New Siri Remote is $59 and Compatible With These Apple TV Models
4 hours ago
HomeView's Wall Model: Pay More, Get Less Speaker
HomeView's Wall Model: Pay More, Get Less Speaker
4 hours ago
Apple's HomeView Touts These 5 Privacy Features
Apple's HomeView Touts These 5 Privacy Features
4 hours ago
Apple Watch Ultra 3 Gets Major Discounts at Amazon and Best Buy
Apple Watch Ultra 3 Gets Major Discounts at Amazon and Best Buy
4 hours ago
Apple TV Finally Gaining Apple Intelligence and Siri AI
Apple TV Finally Gaining Apple Intelligence and Siri AI
4 hours ago
ADT to Offer In-Home Installation of Apple's New HomeView and More
ADT to Offer In-Home Installation of Apple's New HomeView and More
4 hours ago
HomeView Needs an iPhone or iPad for Some AI Features
HomeView Needs an iPhone or iPad for Some AI Features
4 hours ago
Apple Launches 'Apple Home Collection' With Cameras, Lock, Thermostats and More
Apple Launches 'Apple Home Collection' With Cameras, Lock, Thermostats and More
5 hours ago
Apple TV 4K is Now Even More Expensive, 128GB Model Priced at $299
Apple TV 4K is Now Even More Expensive, 128GB Model Priced at $299
5 hours ago
Apple Announces $149 HomePod Mini 2 With Siri AI, 'Sound Glow', and Four-Speaker Surround Sound
Apple Announces $149 HomePod Mini 2 With Siri AI, 'Sound Glow', and Four-Speaker Surround Sound
5 hours ago
Apple HomeView Won't Be Available in the European Union
Apple HomeView Won't Be Available in the European Union
5 hours ago
New Apple TV 4K Announced With A19 Chip, Updated Siri Remote, More
New Apple TV 4K Announced With A19 Chip, Updated Siri Remote, More
5 hours ago
Apple Announces 'HomeView' Smart Home Hub
Apple Announces 'HomeView' Smart Home Hub
5 hours ago
Beats and Pokémon Team Up for Special-Edition Beats Pill Speaker
Beats and Pokémon Team Up for Special-Edition Beats Pill Speaker
5 hours ago
Apple's Next Launch is Today: 'Welcome Home' in New York
Apple's Next Launch is Today: 'Welcome Home' in New York
6 hours ago
Apple Explains Why Chrome Users Should 'Switch to Safari'
Apple Explains Why Chrome Users Should 'Switch to Safari'
6 hours ago
Apple Unveils Immersive Horror Film Coming Exclusively to Vision Pro
Apple Unveils Immersive Horror Film Coming Exclusively to Vision Pro
6 hours ago