YouTube iOS App Removes Apple's Obtrusive Volume Indicator in New Update

YouTube has removed the large, default volume indicator from its iOS app, letting users effectively toggle sound controls up and down while in a full-screen video without having to worry about the translucent UI obscuring most of the content. The removal came in version 11.30 of the YouTube app, which began rolling out yesterday. Any time the app is in portrait mode, the regular indicator will still appear.

youtube new volume update 2
YouTube's new volume rocker can be located at the top of any full-screen video on iOS

The obtrusive volume indicator has been an annoyance for many iOS users over the years, since it usually blocks the most crucial aspects of a video when it pops up. The UI is system-wide, so it shows up most places a video is played on an iPhone or iPad -- Photos, for example -- and has been a mainstay in third-party apps as well. Still, many of Apple's first-party apps include a more inconspicuous volume toggle that appears in a widescreen menu along with play, pause, and video scrubbing controls, like in Trailers and Videos.

Thankfully, over the years, some of these third-party apps have managed to combat Apple's UI choice with volume toggles of their own. Snapchat began using its own alternative about a year ago, in the form of a line of thin rectangles at the top of the screen that grow bolder or lighter when users increase or decrease the volume. Instagram's version is more in line with YouTube's now, with a simple black line that indicates soft and loud volume from the left to the right.

Volume Rockers snapchat instagram
The volume indicator for Snapchat (top) and Instagram (bottom)

In an earlier beta release of iOS 10, some users noticed that the volume UI was gone from the new version of iOS when watching videos, believing its complete removal could possibly be Apple's response to user frustration. However, in subsequent updates the square-shaped HUD has returned, so it appears that the company won't be moving to change this particular part of its mobile operating system when iOS 10 launches in the fall.

Along with the usual bug fixes and performance enhancements, the new update also introduces thumbnails when users scrub through videos on iOS so they can easily find specific scenes. YouTube is available to download for free from the App Store. [Direct Link]

Tag: YouTube


Top Rated Comments

(View all)
Avatar
40 months ago
If we could disable the volume display in iOS that would be good too! Like put it in the settings for us to choose.
Rating: 6 Votes
Avatar
40 months ago
A solid black horizontal line is not a good UI for volume level, particularly in playback apps that already have a left-to-right scrubber.
Rating: 3 Votes
Avatar
40 months ago

They should really follow in Android's footsteps with this aspect of their OS. Android has been far ahead of them in this one aspect, considering that apple has never changed the bolume indicator


I completely agree. As much as I like iOS more than Android generally, the volume controls on Android have always been more advanced. Good to see operating systems take notes from each other as a result of their rivalry.
Rating: 2 Votes
Avatar
40 months ago
I've never found it to be intrusive. I don't change volume repeatedly while watching videos.
Rating: 2 Votes
Avatar
40 months ago
Even moving the huge volume box lower on the screen would be an improvement Apple.
Rating: 2 Votes
Avatar
40 months ago
So google was lazy and just used apple's volume control and now after many years they have gotten around to creating their own volume control. But let's blame apple for google's laziness. Personally I try never to watch a video on an iphone -- too old and bad eyes. But when I have, the apple volume control has not bothered me. But that is me. If an app developer doesn't like Apples implementation, they are free to develop their own. But if you don't develop your own, don't cry about using apple's API - it was your choice to begin with, right?
Rating: 2 Votes
Avatar
40 months ago
Yes, that was (and still is) very annoying! I hope Apple will change that UI now that some big apps are changing it.
Rating: 2 Votes
Avatar
40 months ago

I've never found it to be intrusive. I don't change volume repeatedly while watching videos.


The point is that it's intrusive either way.. It's a huge design flaw and should have been designed differently from the start.
Rating: 1 Votes
Avatar
40 months ago

Sometimes I find YouTube itself annoying and obtrusive versus the volume control.


Care to explain but more? How is YouTube app annoying and obstructive?
[doublepost=1470812761][/doublepost]

So google was lazy and just used apple's volume control and now after many years they have gotten around to creating their own volume control. But let's blame apple for google's laziness. Personally I try never to watch a video on an iphone -- too old and bad eyes. But when I have, the apple volume control has not bothered me. But that is me. If an app developer doesn't like Apples implementation, they are free to develop their own. But if you don't develop your own, don't cry about using apple's API - it was your choice to begin with, right?


So you blame Google using Apple's default UI?

I remember someone in this forum complaining Google uses Android UI for their iOS apps.

So now, it is Google's fault using Apple's default UI? We should all blame Google using default UI. And there is nothing wrong with Apple's part?
[doublepost=1470812981][/doublepost]

While we're on the subject, can anyone explain to me the difference between "volume" and "ringer". Sometimes when I adjust the volume one or the other displays. Doesn't the overall system volume affect the ringer?


Volume is volume, you adjust the loudness of your media play back.

However, you would adjust how loud system notifications sound when you aren't playing any media.

Hence,volume is the loudness of your media playback. Ringer is loudness of your notifications sound.
Rating: 1 Votes
Avatar
40 months ago
YES.

Glad to see someone had some sense.
Rating: 1 Votes
[ Read All Comments ]