Apple Seeks Sanctions Against Samsung for Unlawful Use of Apple-Nokia Patent License Terms - MacRumors
Skip to Content

Apple Seeks Sanctions Against Samsung for Unlawful Use of Apple-Nokia Patent License Terms

apple_samsung_logosApple has filed a new motion for sanctions against Samsung in a California court, accusing the Korean electronics manufacturer of unlawfully obtaining sensitive information about the terms and conditions of its 2011 patent license agreement with Nokia, reports FOSS Patents.

The motion states that Dr. Seungho Ahn, a Samsung executive, informed Nokia that the terms of the Apple-Nokia patent settlement were “known to him”, and used that information to negotiate other potential patent settlements in Samsung’s favor. According to the complaint, the Apple-Nokia license terms were turned over to Samsung's outside lawyers during the Apple v. Samsung case and were marked "Highly Confidential -- Attorneys' Eyes Only", but were improperly shared with Ahn and dozens of other Samsung employees.

Licensing executives from Samsung and Nokia held a meeting on June 4, 2013 to discuss a patent license deal between these parties. In that meeting, a Samsung exec, Dr. Seungho Ahn, "informed Nokia that the terms of the Apple-Nokia license were known to him" and according to a declaration from Nokia's Chief Intellectual Property Officer, Paul Melin, "stated that Apple had produced the Apple-Nokia license in its litigation with Samsung, and that Samsung's outside counsel had provided his team with the terms of the Apple-Nokia license". The Melin declaration furthermore says that "to prove to Nokia that he knew the confidential terms of the Apple-Nokia license, Dr. Ahn recited the terms of the license, and even went so far as to tell Nokia that 'all information leaks.'"

The motion itself details how files containing the sensitive information were transferred between Samsung’s outside counsel and Samsung executives, with the unredacted documents having been posted on an FTP server accessible to Samsung employees and then transmitted via email.

“Samsung’s outside counsel posted the report on an FTP site that was accessible by Samsung personnel. An email providing instructions to access the FTP site was addressed the regular client distribution list used by counsel to provide Samsung personnel updates regarding the case.

The information was then sent, over several different occasions, to over fifty Samsung employees, including high-ranking licensing executives. Specifically, on at least four occasions between March 24, 2012 and December 21, 2012, Samsung's outside counsel emailed a copy of some version of the report to Samsung employees, as well as various counsel representing Samsung in courts and jurisdictions outside the United States.

Since 2011, Samsung and Apple have been in a long, ongoing legal battle over patent and design issues, with the first U.S. trial awarding $1 billion to Apple in 2012. However, a judge voided nearly half of that amount in March, and a new trial between the two companies is set for November of this year.

Popular Stories

iPhone Duo Outer Display Hand

Apple Aiming to Upgrade the iPhone Duo in Four Ways

Sunday November 15, 2026 8:42 am PST by
Bloomberg's Mark Gurman today said Apple has four goals for future iPhone Duo models: Face ID, an Action button, a telephoto camera, and a thinner-and-lighter design. Gurman said Apple has already developed iPhone Duo 2 prototypes with Face ID on the outer display, but it is "running out of time" to finalize the feature for that model, so it might not arrive until the iPhone Duo...
Apple Health AI Study App Feature

Apple Just Released a New App

Monday November 16, 2026 9:43 am PST by
Apple today launched a new research study in the U.S. to explore the use of AI for health, and it has released a dedicated iPhone app for participants. In a press release, Apple said the study and app are "designed to advance the understanding of how people interact with conversational health AI tools." The Apple Health AI Study App contains a generative AI chatbot that participants can...
iphone duo yellow hand

Apple Adds Facial Unlock Option on iPhone Duo in iOS 27.3

Monday November 16, 2026 10:17 am PST by
Apple today added a new option for unlocking the iPhone Duo using the front-facing camera, giving device users multiple ways to access their content. The feature is available in the second iOS 27.3 beta. The option to unlock with facial recognition is only available on the Lock Screen, and authentication via Touch ID is still needed for Apple Pay purchases, adding passwords and logins, and...

Top Rated Comments

WildCowboy Avatar
171 months ago
I read this site every day, but please no more patent news. I beg of you.

We work pretty hard to keep our coverage of patent lawsuits to only the important ones.

This one's a doozy.
Score: 28 Votes (Like | Disagree)
sseaton1971 Avatar
171 months ago
At the top of the page there are tabs for Front Page, Mac Blog, iOS Blog, etc. It would be great if they added a tab for Litigation Blog so those of us that don't want to read all the stupid legal machinations could just skip it.
Or you could just skip over the articles you don't like. You are not required to read everything. ;)
Score: 24 Votes (Like | Disagree)
bawbac Avatar
171 months ago
At the top of the page there are tabs for Front Page, Mac Blog, iOS Blog, etc. It would be great if they added a tab for Litigation Blog so those of us that don't want to read all the stupid legal machinations could just skip it.
They already give you that option.
Don't click on the thread.:)
Score: 24 Votes (Like | Disagree)
171 months ago
Aren't there enough sanctions already?

Not until a punishment is imparted upon Samsung that actually hurts them. The reason why Samsung repeatedly lies, cheats, steals, manipulates and bribes, is because they still make money under such practices. If you fine them in such a way that actually shakes their ivory tower, maybe then there will be enough sanctions. Until that point, sanction the hell out of Samsung!

And by the way, this isn't just regarding phones. Samsung has employed these same practices in producing their TVs -- TVs I love -- but they're still wrong. Additionally, I'd just like to say that since I've learned of their practices, I do not buy their name brand offerings, though I know much of the electronic components I use contain their products.
Score: 22 Votes (Like | Disagree)
diddl14 Avatar
171 months ago
Yep, sounds like Samsung.
Score: 20 Votes (Like | Disagree)
171 months ago
I read this site every day, but please no more patent news. I beg of you.
Score: 19 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Latest Stories
WhatsApp's iCloud Backup Alternative Rolls Out to Beta Users on iPhone
WhatsApp's iCloud Backup Alternative Rolls Out to Beta Users on iPhone
34 minutes ago
MacPaw's Moonlock Cybersecurity App Launches for iPhone
MacPaw's Moonlock Cybersecurity App Launches for iPhone
48 minutes ago
Apple Reportedly Developing Two Designs for 20th Anniversary iPhone
Apple Reportedly Developing Two Designs for 20th Anniversary iPhone
51 minutes ago
Apple Rolls Out All-New Maps Experience Across India
Apple Rolls Out All-New Maps Experience Across India
1 hour ago
iPhone Air 2 Reportedly Sticks With Same Display
iPhone Air 2 Reportedly Sticks With Same Display
2 hours ago
iPhone 18 and iPhone Air 2 Display Production to Begin Soon Ahead of Expected March Launch
iPhone 18 and iPhone Air 2 Display Production to Begin Soon Ahead of Expected March Launch
2 hours ago
Aqara Debuts Six Matter Smart Lights That Work With Apple Home
Aqara Debuts Six Matter Smart Lights That Work With Apple Home
13 hours ago
Disney+ and Hulu Will Fully Merge Into One App in December
Disney+ and Hulu Will Fully Merge Into One App in December
14 hours ago
iFixit Says Apple's HomeView is Unnecessarily Hard to Repair
iFixit Says Apple's HomeView is Unnecessarily Hard to Repair
16 hours ago
Final Cut Pro Now Includes MotionVFX for Creator Studio Users
Final Cut Pro Now Includes MotionVFX for Creator Studio Users
17 hours ago
Apple Blames Internal Update for Outage, Says It Wasn't a Cyberattack
Apple Blames Internal Update for Outage, Says It Wasn't a Cyberattack
18 hours ago
Nomad Launches Black Friday Sale With Up to 30% Off Apple Accessories
Nomad Launches Black Friday Sale With Up to 30% Off Apple Accessories
19 hours ago
Google Wallet Available on iPhone, But Without Tap to Pay
Google Wallet Available on iPhone, But Without Tap to Pay
19 hours ago
Apple Accounts, App Store and Apple Music Experiencing Issues
Apple Accounts, App Store and Apple Music Experiencing Issues
20 hours ago
Apple Moves Ahead With Better Dual SIM Support for Apps
Apple Moves Ahead With Better Dual SIM Support for Apps
21 hours ago
Former Apple Chairman Plans to Sell $32 Million in Apple Stock
Former Apple Chairman Plans to Sell $32 Million in Apple Stock
21 hours ago
Apple Accused of Silencing iPhone Duo Supplier Over 'Crackgate' Issue
Apple Accused of Silencing iPhone Duo Supplier Over 'Crackgate' Issue
22 hours ago
Apple Store App Now Optimized for iPhone Duo
Apple Store App Now Optimized for iPhone Duo
22 hours ago
Apple Says iCloud+ Plans Will Not Include Increased Siri AI Usage in UK
Apple Says iCloud+ Plans Will Not Include Increased Siri AI Usage in UK
23 hours ago
Amazon Offering Early Black Friday Discounts on TVs, Headphones, and Charging Devices
Amazon Offering Early Black Friday Discounts on TVs, Headphones, and Charging Devices
23 hours ago
Apple Now Sells DIY Repair Parts for iPhone Duo
Apple Now Sells DIY Repair Parts for iPhone Duo
23 hours ago
iPhone 20 Pro Screen Protectors Show Rumored Curved Design
iPhone 20 Pro Screen Protectors Show Rumored Curved Design
1 day ago
MacBook Neo Black Friday Deals Arrive With $49 Discounts on Nearly Every Model at Amazon
MacBook Neo Black Friday Deals Arrive With $49 Discounts on Nearly Every Model at Amazon
1 day ago
iPhone Users Targeted in Major Website Security Breach
iPhone Users Targeted in Major Website Security Breach
1 day ago
Apple Names 'Baby, This Is Keke Palmer' Podcast of the Year
Apple Names 'Baby, This Is Keke Palmer' Podcast of the Year
1 day ago
Apple Tests Bringing Back a Softer Side of Liquid Glass
Apple Tests Bringing Back a Softer Side of Liquid Glass
1 day ago
Apple Close to Rare Long-Term Memory Deal With Samsung
Apple Close to Rare Long-Term Memory Deal With Samsung
1 day ago
Everything New in iOS 27.3 Beta 2
Everything New in iOS 27.3 Beta 2
2 days ago
Apple Plans to Release These 18 New Products Next Year
Apple Plans to Release These 18 New Products Next Year
2 days ago
New Apple TV 4K Discount Returns at Amazon
New Apple TV 4K Discount Returns at Amazon
2 days ago