For Debate: Is Apple Using Steganography In iTunes Plus Songs? [Updated: No?] - MacRumors
Skip to Content

For Debate: Is Apple Using Steganography In iTunes Plus Songs? [Updated: No?]

Following the discovery that Apple was embedding iTunes account information in iTunes Plus songs, Erica Sadun at O'Reilly speculates that Apple may be using Steganography within the AAC portion of iTunes Plus tracks.

The conclusion came after purchasing the same iTunes Plus song from the iTunes Store using two accounts. After having stripped the files of their meta data (where iTunes would store account information, and any extraneous information), she compared the files and found 774 bytes (out of 6.7 MB) were different in the AAC data itself. Her conclusion: "Clearly some sort of fingerprinting/steganography is going on in the data itself."

The EFF has apparently also begun investigating the issue, although they do not indicate how far they will pursue the issue.

Most forum users appear to not be dissuaded by the revelations, and appear to accepting the move as a compromise allowing music companies to have some recourse against those who illegally share music, but opening the DRM restrictions for legitimate users.

Of note, Apple does not indicate that it uses such technology in its iTunes Terms of Service.

Steganography (from Wikipedia): "the art and science of writing hidden messages in such a way that no one apart from the intended recipient knows of the existence of the message." Different from cryptography in that the existence of the message itself is not disguised, but the content is obscured.

Update: After an independent MacRumors investigation, it does not appear that watermarking is taking place in the AAC data itself, and it may be presumptuous to claim that steganography is taking place. A recount of our investigation is posted here.

A forum post suggests the differences seen in the files are simply a result of differences in modification dates embedded in the files, rather than any sort of embedded identifying information.

Related Forum: Mac Apps

Popular Stories

M5 Vision Pro Thumb 2

Apple Has Given Up on the Vision Pro After M5 Refresh Flop

Wednesday April 29, 2026 11:31 am PDT by
Apple has all but given up on the Vision Pro after the M5 model failed to revitalize interest in the device, MacRumors has learned. Apple updated the Vision Pro with a faster M5 chip and a more comfortable band in October 2025, but there were no other hardware changes, and consumers still weren't interested. The Vision Pro has been criticized for its high price tag and its uncomfortable...
Four iPhone 18 Pro Colors Mock Feature

iPhone 18 Pro to Launch in September With These 10 New Features

Tuesday April 28, 2026 9:35 am PDT by
While the iPhone 18 Pro and iPhone 18 Pro Max are not launching until September, there are already plenty of rumors about the devices. It was initially reported that the iPhone 18 Pro models would have fully under-screen Face ID, with only a front camera visible in the top-left corner of the screen. However, the latest rumors indicate that only one Face ID component will be moved under the...
app store monthly sub commitment

Apple Introduces App Store Monthly Subscriptions With 12-Month Commitment

Monday April 27, 2026 12:52 pm PDT by
Apple today announced the launch of a new subscription option for App Store developers: monthly subscriptions with a 12-month commitment. The new option allows developers to offer subscribers discounted pricing typically associated with an annual subscription but paid on a monthly basis to keep payments more affordable. This new payment option allows you to offer subscribers more affordable...