AirPods 5 vs. AirPods Pro 3 Buyer's Guide: Which Should You Buy? - MacRumors
Skip to Content

AirPods 5 vs. AirPods Pro 3 Buyer's Guide: Which Should You Buy?

Apple's AirPods 5 bring Active Noise Cancellation to its $129 earbuds for the first time. The $149 AirPods 5 with Wireless Charging Case add longer battery life, volume controls on the stems, and a case speaker for Find My. The AirPods Pro 3 cost $249.

airpods 5 vs airpods pro 3

The ‌AirPods 5‌ arrived in September 2026, a year after the AirPods Pro 3. They continue to narrow the feature gap between the devices, but the Pro model still offers a sealed in-ear fit, substantially better noise cancellation, and hearing and workout features. Our guide helps to answer the question of how to decide which of these sets of AirPods is best for you.

‌AirPods 5‌
(2026)
‌AirPods 5‌ with Wireless Charging Case
(2026)
‌AirPods Pro 3‌
(2025)
Open-ear fit without ear tips Open-ear fit without ear tips In-ear fit with foam-infused silicone ear tips in five sizes
Optical in-ear sensor Optical in-ear sensor Skin-detect sensor
Open-ear Active Noise Cancellation Open-ear Active Noise Cancellation In-ear Active Noise Cancellation; up to 3x more effective than ‌AirPods 5‌
Force sensor controls Force sensor controls with volume swipe Touch controls with volume swipe
Hearing Test, Hearing Aid, Hearing Protection, Automatic Conversation Boost, and Loud Sound Reduction
Heart rate sensing during workouts
Up to 4 hours of listening time on one charge with ANC Up to 5 hours of listening time on one charge with ANC Up to 8 hours of listening time on one charge with ANC
Up to 20 hours of listening time with ANC using the case Up to 22 hours of listening time with ANC using the case Up to 24 hours of listening time with ANC using the case
Case charges via USB-C Case charges via USB-C, Apple Watch charger, or Qi charger Case charges via USB-C, Apple Watch charger, Qi charger, or MagSafe charger
Speaker in case for ‌Find My‌ Speaker in case for ‌Find My‌
Second-generation Ultra Wideband chip in case for Precision Finding with a compatible iPhone
Charging case is 1.97 inches (50.1 mm) wide Charging case is 1.97 inches (50.1 mm) wide Charging case is 2.45 inches (62.2 mm) wide and has a lanyard loop
Starts at $129 Starts at $149 Starts at $249

The ‌AirPods 5‌ with Wireless Charging Case are the best choice for most buyers. For $20 more than the base model, you get an extra hour of listening time per charge with ANC, volume swipes on the stems, wireless charging, and a speaker that makes a misplaced case easier to find. Choose the $129 model if the lowest price matters most and you are content with its shorter battery life and USB-C-only charging case.

However, the ‌AirPods Pro 3‌ are worth the extra $100 over the higher-end ‌AirPods 5‌ if noise cancellation is your priority and you prefer a snug in-ear fit. Apple says they provide up to three times as much ANC as the ‌AirPods 5‌, since the ear tips create a physical seal. Their eight-hour listening time per charge is particularly useful on long journeys. In our hands-on testing, the ‌AirPods 5‌ sounded muddier than the Pro 3, particularly in the lower midrange.

The ‌AirPods Pro 3‌ are also the clear choice if you want their hearing health features or heart rate sensing during workouts without relying on an Apple Watch. Their charging case adds Precision Finding, too. If you dislike silicone ear tips, the ‌AirPods 5‌ let you keep the open-ear fit while getting nearly all of the everyday listening features shared by the Pro model.

AirPods frequently receive discounts from third-party retailers, which can narrow the ‌AirPods Pro 3‌'s $100 list-price premium over the $149 ‌AirPods 5‌. Check the latest prices using our Deals roundup before buying.

Related Roundups: AirPods 5, AirPods Pro 3
Related Forum: AirPods

Popular Stories

First iPhone 18 Pro Apple Watch Series 12 Apple Watch Ultra 4 and AirPods 5 Orders Arriving to Customers Feature

First iPhone 18 Pro, Apple Watch Series 12, Apple Watch Ultra 4 and AirPods 5 Orders Arriving to Customers

Thursday September 17, 2026 2:59 pm PDT by
It's Friday, September 18 in Australia and New Zealand, which means customers who pre-ordered are beginning to receive their new devices. The iPhone 18 Pro, iPhone 18 Pro Max, Apple Watch Series 12, Apple Watch Ultra 4, and AirPods 5 are launching today. Apple fans who ordered an iPhone, Apple Watch, or AirPods will soon be sharing first impressions on Instagram, Reddit, the MacRumors...
AirPods Pro Beta Firmware 2

Apple Releases New AirPods Beta Firmware

Tuesday September 29, 2026 11:38 am PDT by
Apple today released new beta firmware for the AirPods Pro 2, AirPods Pro 3, AirPods 4, AirPods 5, and AirPods Max 2. The firmware has a build number of 9B5042a and is rolling out for developers and public beta testers. There's no word on what's included in the firmware update because Apple doesn't offer notes for AirPods beta releases. When the AirPods are connected to an iPhone, iPad,...
AirPods Pro Beta Firmware 2

Apple Releases New AirPods Beta Firmware

Tuesday October 13, 2026 11:28 am PDT by
Apple today released new beta firmware for the AirPods Pro 2, AirPods Pro 3, AirPods 4, AirPods 5, and AirPods Max 2. The firmware has a build number of 9B5043a and is rolling out for developers and public beta testers. There's no word on what's included in the firmware update because Apple doesn't offer notes for AirPods beta releases. When the AirPods are connected to an iPhone, iPad,...

Top Rated Comments

3 weeks ago
The hearing test and subsequent 'recalibrating' of the Pro pods is a real 'ease of life' feature for some, like me. Just recently I realised that my Pro 2 pods could do this. The hearing test told me something I knew (eardrum patching after scuba diving had left me with poor hearing in 1 ear) and then went about 'solving' it, at least when I have my pods in.

I remember Tim Cook once getting angry with an 'investor' who wanted Apple to do only what's gives an ROI. IIRC Cook was adamant that he wanted to contribute to accessibility breakthroughs for users, even without the ROI payoff.

Good call Tim!
Score: 6 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Mrkevinfinnerty Avatar
3 weeks ago
I have a pair of Pro 3 and use my £17 wired earpods instead because i hate them :)
Score: 5 Votes (Like | Disagree)
3 weeks ago
For me, it is the AirPods 5. I like the open ear fit. Not going to upgrade from my AirPods 4 with ANC but I think the AirPods 5 will definitely be my choice.
Score: 4 Votes (Like | Disagree)
SactoGuy18 Avatar
3 weeks ago
I prefer the AirPods Pro 3 because the real seal with the IEM design improves sound quality and active noise cancellation.
Score: 3 Votes (Like | Disagree)
jclardy Avatar
3 weeks ago
I moved from Pro 3 to the 5's. The Pro's are great, but they lose the main thing the original AirPods had for me, a tiny case that you could forget you have on you. The Pro case has become this giant bulbous thing that I have to intentionally keep in my pocket, it is bigger than the ridiculous car key fobs that we have now. The 5 case is so tiny and unobtrusive, you can just keep it on you all the time, which to me, was always the point of AirPods.
Score: 3 Votes (Like | Disagree)
3 weeks ago

I briefly had the Pro 3 and it felt like I was getting an deep ear cleaning or something.
Very unpleasant to me. I really never even use my APP2 as it is.

No interest in things lodged in there that much.

Good reports about AP5 on this front (great ANC w/o anything in my ear canal), but I'll be riding my AP4s into the ground.
My Pro 2s suffer from this to a degree. I live in them (city life), so probably an edge case, but it got so bad that my left ear was sending crippling, shooting pain right into the ear canal. It felt like a knife in my ear drum. It would come and go in waves, lasting for days then weeks, but over months and years, progressively got worse and worse. Funnily enough it kind of started when I passed out with them on day (never noticed any significant pain before that day). I guess having them press into my ear was the final straw. But since that day, it started becoming a real problem. Taking breaks from them made the pain largely go away (it would still flare up for a few min here and there) but as soon as I put them back in, pow, right in the kisser!

After doing some research and wading thru the dreck online, I traced it to the silicon tips and the pressure they put on the concha and tragus. I moved down to the small tips (from medium) and it went away overnight! I use them a lot less these days, but it’s amazing how pain moves around and how a small thing can make such a big difference.

The 3s are worse because Apple offloaded a lot more onto to the tips than before (I’m glad I returned them!). This has led to some people scraping their conchas and traguses to where they started bleeding! Moreover, if you move down to smaller tips, the earbuds won’t stay in as well as the 3s rely a lot more on the tips to stay in. It also means you shouldn’t use them for prolonged periods of time, which also sucks.

The 3s are a huge step back for the health and wellbeing of your precious ears.
Score: 2 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Latest Stories
Massive Discounts Hit 2026 MacBook Pro With Up to $800 Off
Massive Discounts Hit 2026 MacBook Pro With Up to $800 Off
3 minutes ago
iPhone Duo is Sold Out for Christmas as Shipping Estimates Slip to 2027
iPhone Duo is Sold Out for Christmas as Shipping Estimates Slip to 2027
21 minutes ago
Didn't Pre-Order an iPhone Duo Yet? Wait Times Are Significant Now
Didn't Pre-Order an iPhone Duo Yet? Wait Times Are Significant Now
1 hour ago
First Apple TV 4K Pre-Order Discount Arrives at Amazon
First Apple TV 4K Pre-Order Discount Arrives at Amazon
1 hour ago
iPhone Duo Pre-Order Deals: The Best Carrier Offers From AT&T and T-Mobile
iPhone Duo Pre-Order Deals: The Best Carrier Offers From AT&T and T-Mobile
1 hour ago
iPhone Duo Now Available to Pre-Order From Apple
iPhone Duo Now Available to Pre-Order From Apple
2 hours ago
iPhone 18 Pro vs. iPhone Duo Buyer's Guide: Which Should You Choose?
iPhone 18 Pro vs. iPhone Duo Buyer's Guide: Which Should You Choose?
4 hours ago
Apple Store Down Ahead of iPhone Duo Pre-Orders
Apple Store Down Ahead of iPhone Duo Pre-Orders
4 hours ago
Oops, Apple's Website Just Hinted at iPad Mini 8
Oops, Apple's Website Just Hinted at iPad Mini 8
13 hours ago
OLED MacBook Pro Won't Get M7 Chips Until Late 2027
OLED MacBook Pro Won't Get M7 Chips Until Late 2027
15 hours ago
Apple Pledged $25 Million to Trump's White House Ballroom
Apple Pledged $25 Million to Trump's White House Ballroom
17 hours ago
Touchscreen MacBook Pro Could Launch on November 6
Touchscreen MacBook Pro Could Launch on November 6
18 hours ago
New Withings Users Must Pay $99/Year for Apple Health Syncing
New Withings Users Must Pay $99/Year for Apple Health Syncing
18 hours ago
Meta and Apple Bring Muse Spark Open AI Model to Mac Studio
Meta and Apple Bring Muse Spark Open AI Model to Mac Studio
20 hours ago
iPad Mini 8: Apple Has Tested Both 60Hz and 120Hz ProMotion Displays
iPad Mini 8: Apple Has Tested Both 60Hz and 120Hz ProMotion Displays
20 hours ago
Apple TV 4K 2022 vs. 2026 Buyer's Guide: All Differences Compared
Apple TV 4K 2022 vs. 2026 Buyer's Guide: All Differences Compared
21 hours ago
Apple CEO John Ternus on Early Foldables: 'Kind of Cheap and Crappy'
Apple CEO John Ternus on Early Foldables: 'Kind of Cheap and Crappy'
22 hours ago
Greg Joswiak Says Apple Isn't Focused on Making AI for 'Lunatic Fringe'
Greg Joswiak Says Apple Isn't Focused on Making AI for 'Lunatic Fringe'
23 hours ago
Amazon Offers $120 Discount on AirPods Max 2, $50 Off AirPods Pro 3
Amazon Offers $120 Discount on AirPods Max 2, $50 Off AirPods Pro 3
23 hours ago
Apple CEO John Ternus Featured on Cover of TIME Magazine: 'New Era'
Apple CEO John Ternus Featured on Cover of TIME Magazine: 'New Era'
1 day ago
Apple Announces Deadline to 'Get Ready' to Pre-Order the iPhone Duo
Apple Announces Deadline to 'Get Ready' to Pre-Order the iPhone Duo
1 day ago
MKBHD is 'Not Convinced' About Apple's New HomeView, Here's Why
MKBHD is 'Not Convinced' About Apple's New HomeView, Here's Why
1 day ago
Apple's Wall-Mounted HomeView Ships Without a Power Adapter
Apple's Wall-Mounted HomeView Ships Without a Power Adapter
1 day ago
Rare Apple-1 With Steve Jobs Letter Sells for $1.15 Million
Rare Apple-1 With Steve Jobs Letter Sells for $1.15 Million
1 day ago
Apple Now Inviting Media to October 28 'Launch Experience'
Apple Now Inviting Media to October 28 'Launch Experience'
1 day ago
iPhone Duo's A20 Pro Chip Benchmarked Ahead of Launch
iPhone Duo's A20 Pro Chip Benchmarked Ahead of Launch
2 days ago
10 HomeView Features You Might Have Missed
10 HomeView Features You Might Have Missed
2 days ago
Apple Becomes Second Company to Close Above $5 Trillion
Apple Becomes Second Company to Close Above $5 Trillion
2 days ago
Which Apple Home Devices Get Siri AI, and When
Which Apple Home Devices Get Siri AI, and When
2 days ago
Apple's Long-Delayed HomeView Was Already Being Tested in 2024
Apple's Long-Delayed HomeView Was Already Being Tested in 2024
2 days ago