iPhone 4 Deemed Most Reliable, Least Rugged Among Popular Smartphones - MacRumors
Skip to Content

iPhone 4 Deemed Most Reliable, Least Rugged Among Popular Smartphones

Last month, warranty company SquareTrade shared the results of a study of warranty claims showing a higher accidental damage rate for the iPhone 4 than the iPhone 3GS, with the iPhone 4 having a particular propensity for cracked glass due to the fact that glass is used on both the front and back of the device.

SquareTrade today followed up with a broader study of over 50,000 smartphones covered by its warranty program, revealing that the iPhone 4 checks in as the most reliable smartphone when it comes to non-accident malfunctions, but that it also experiences the highest accident rates among the studied devices.

133305 squaretrade overall failure rate

When it comes to non-accident malfunctions, SquareTrade's extrapolation of iPhone 4 data yields a failure rate of 2.1% after 12 months, better than the 2.3% rate for the iPhone 3GS and all other studied smartphone brands.

Apple emerged as the most reliable manufacturer, with Motorola not far behind. We project fewer than 2.5% of iPhone and Motorola owners will report a malfunction in the first 12 months of use, with iPhone 4s leading the pack. HTC came next with a one-year malfunction rate of 3.7%, and BlackBerry's 6.3% was the highest of the four manufacturers examined. All other smart phones taken together fared the worst, with 6.7% reporting a malfunction.

But in looking at accident rates, the iPhone 4 projections suggest that 13.8% of iPhone 4s will suffer an accidental breakage within the first 12 months, topping the list of studied smartphones that includes the iPhone 3GS and its 9.4% accident rate.

As reported in our previous study on the iPhone 4 glass, the early iPhone 4 data shows a much higher accident rate compared to its predecessor. However, when we compare it to the Android manufacturers, it is higher, but not by much. We expect 13.8% of iPhone 4 owners to report an accident within a year, compared to 12.2% for both Motorola and HTC.

The study comes just as Cult of Mac offers its own report corroborating earlier claims that Apple is investigating issues with slide-on cases for the iPhone 4 leading to cracked and broken glass backs on the device as dirt and sand trapped between the phone and case lead to scratches that weaken the glass.

The report claims that Apple's retail stores are not stocking slide-on cases for the iPhone 4 as the company works to thoroughly evaluate each case design at a secret testing facility. The delay in availability is affecting a number of case manufacturers, many of whom rely on Apple's retail stores as their largest distribution channels.

One high-profile manufacturer affected by the issue is Mophie, which reportedly ordered a production run of over 100,000 for its Juice Pack Air, which offers a combination case and rechargeable external battery. According to Mophie, the case is sold through the company's own site and through AT&T stores, but remains unavailable directly through Apple.

Other manufacturers are disputing that there is even a problem, calling it a perception issue that Apple is carefully trying to guard against, particularly after all the attention the company received over antenna performance issues on the iPhone 4. So until Apple can certify for itself that these third-party slide-on cases are not leading to cracked iPhone 4s, the company is expected to refrain from offering them for sale.

Related Forum: iPhone

Popular Stories

iPhone Duo Outer Display Hand

Apple Aiming to Upgrade the iPhone Duo in Four Ways

Sunday November 15, 2026 8:42 am PST by
Bloomberg's Mark Gurman today said Apple has four goals for future iPhone Duo models: Face ID, an Action button, a telephoto camera, and a thinner-and-lighter design. Gurman said Apple has already developed iPhone Duo 2 prototypes with Face ID on the outer display, but it is "running out of time" to finalize the feature for that model, so it might not arrive until the iPhone Duo...
Apple Health AI Study App Feature

Apple Just Released a New App

Monday November 16, 2026 9:43 am PST by
Apple today launched a new research study in the U.S. to explore the use of AI for health, and it has released a dedicated iPhone app for participants. In a press release, Apple said the study and app are "designed to advance the understanding of how people interact with conversational health AI tools." The Apple Health AI Study App contains a generative AI chatbot that participants can...
iphone duo yellow hand

Apple Adds Facial Unlock Option on iPhone Duo in iOS 27.3

Monday November 16, 2026 10:17 am PST by
Apple today added a new option for unlocking the iPhone Duo using the front-facing camera, giving device users multiple ways to access their content. The feature is available in the second iOS 27.3 beta. The option to unlock with facial recognition is only available on the Lock Screen, and authentication via Touch ID is still needed for Apple Pay purchases, adding passwords and logins, and...
Latest Stories
Aqara Debuts Six Matter Smart Lights That Work With Apple Home
Aqara Debuts Six Matter Smart Lights That Work With Apple Home
3 hours ago
Disney+ and Hulu Will Fully Merge Into One App in December
Disney+ and Hulu Will Fully Merge Into One App in December
3 hours ago
iFixit Says Apple's HomeView is Unnecessarily Hard to Repair
iFixit Says Apple's HomeView is Unnecessarily Hard to Repair
5 hours ago
Final Cut Pro Now Includes MotionVFX for Creator Studio Users
Final Cut Pro Now Includes MotionVFX for Creator Studio Users
6 hours ago
Apple Blames Internal Update for Outage, Says It Wasn't a Cyberattack
Apple Blames Internal Update for Outage, Says It Wasn't a Cyberattack
8 hours ago
Nomad Launches Black Friday Sale With Up to 30% Off Apple Accessories
Nomad Launches Black Friday Sale With Up to 30% Off Apple Accessories
8 hours ago
Google Wallet Available on iPhone, But Without Tap to Pay
Google Wallet Available on iPhone, But Without Tap to Pay
9 hours ago
Apple Accounts, App Store and Apple Music Experiencing Issues
Apple Accounts, App Store and Apple Music Experiencing Issues
9 hours ago
Apple Moves Ahead With Better Dual SIM Support for Apps
Apple Moves Ahead With Better Dual SIM Support for Apps
10 hours ago
Former Apple Chairman Plans to Sell $32 Million in Apple Stock
Former Apple Chairman Plans to Sell $32 Million in Apple Stock
11 hours ago
Apple Accused of Silencing iPhone Duo Supplier Over 'Crackgate' Issue
Apple Accused of Silencing iPhone Duo Supplier Over 'Crackgate' Issue
11 hours ago
Apple Store App Now Optimized for iPhone Duo
Apple Store App Now Optimized for iPhone Duo
11 hours ago
Apple Says iCloud+ Plans Will Not Include Increased Siri AI Usage in UK
Apple Says iCloud+ Plans Will Not Include Increased Siri AI Usage in UK
12 hours ago
Amazon Offering Early Black Friday Discounts on TVs, Headphones, and Charging Devices
Amazon Offering Early Black Friday Discounts on TVs, Headphones, and Charging Devices
12 hours ago
Apple Now Sells DIY Repair Parts for iPhone Duo
Apple Now Sells DIY Repair Parts for iPhone Duo
12 hours ago
iPhone 20 Pro Screen Protectors Show Rumored Curved Design
iPhone 20 Pro Screen Protectors Show Rumored Curved Design
13 hours ago
MacBook Neo Black Friday Deals Arrive With $49 Discounts on Nearly Every Model at Amazon
MacBook Neo Black Friday Deals Arrive With $49 Discounts on Nearly Every Model at Amazon
13 hours ago
iPhone Users Targeted in Major Website Security Breach
iPhone Users Targeted in Major Website Security Breach
14 hours ago
Apple Names 'Baby, This Is Keke Palmer' Podcast of the Year
Apple Names 'Baby, This Is Keke Palmer' Podcast of the Year
15 hours ago
Apple Tests Bringing Back a Softer Side of Liquid Glass
Apple Tests Bringing Back a Softer Side of Liquid Glass
16 hours ago
Apple Close to Rare Long-Term Memory Deal With Samsung
Apple Close to Rare Long-Term Memory Deal With Samsung
17 hours ago
Everything New in iOS 27.3 Beta 2
Everything New in iOS 27.3 Beta 2
1 day ago
Apple Plans to Release These 18 New Products Next Year
Apple Plans to Release These 18 New Products Next Year
1 day ago
New Apple TV 4K Discount Returns at Amazon
New Apple TV 4K Discount Returns at Amazon
1 day ago
iPhone Duo Orders Will Now Arrive Before the Holidays
iPhone Duo Orders Will Now Arrive Before the Holidays
1 day ago
Hands-On With the iPhone Duo's New Face Unlock
Hands-On With the iPhone Duo's New Face Unlock
1 day ago
macOS 27.3 Warns Against Giving AI Apps Full Mac Control
macOS 27.3 Warns Against Giving AI Apps Full Mac Control
1 day ago
iPad and Mac Get Apple Intelligence in China in 27.3 Betas
iPad and Mac Get Apple Intelligence in China in 27.3 Betas
1 day ago
Apple News+ Puzzles Come to UK, Australia, and French Canada
Apple News+ Puzzles Come to UK, Australia, and French Canada
1 day ago
macOS Golden Gate 27.3 Beta 2 Now Available for Developers
macOS Golden Gate 27.3 Beta 2 Now Available for Developers
1 day ago