New in OS X: Get MacRumors Push Notifications on your Mac

Resubscribe Now Close

Apple and FBI to Testify at Congressional Hearing on Encryption Next Week

Apple's legal chief Bruce Sewell and FBI Director James Comey will both testify at a U.S. congressional hearing on encryption issues planned for March 1, the House Judiciary Committee announced today.

sewellcomey
Comey will participate in the first panel, while Sewell will testify in the second panel alongside Worcester Polytechnic Institute professor Susan Landau and New York District Attorney Cyrus Vance. Vance last week said his office was in possession of 175 iPhones that can't be accessed due to encryption. "This has become the Wild West in technology," he said. "Apple and Google are their own sheriffs and there are no rules."

The congressional hearing, titled "The Encryption Tightrope: Balancing Americans' Security and Privacy" will examine encryption technology and its impact on American citizens and lawmakers with the goal of finding a solution that lets law enforcement do their jobs without affecting the privacy protections of U.S. citizens.
"The widespread use of strong encryption has implications both for Americans' privacy and security. As technology companies have made great strides to enhance the security of Americans' personal and private information, law enforcement agencies face new challenges when attempting to access encrypted information. Americans have a right to strong privacy protections and Congress should fully examine the issue to be sure those are in place while finding ways to help law enforcement fight crime and keep us safe.
Head Apple lawyer Bruce Sewell is leading Apple's legal team in its fight against the FBI. Apple plans to oppose an order that would require it to help the FBI brute force the passcode on San Bernardino shooter Farook Syed's iPhone. The FBI is demanding Apple create a software that would both disable passcode security features and allow passcodes to be entered electronically.

In an interview yesterday, Tim Cook said that the FBI was asking Apple to build the "software equivalent of cancer," something the company won't do. While Apple has announced its intentions to fight the order, its official appeal is due tomorrow.

Update: In related news, Microsoft today announced its full support of Apple's decision to stand against the FBI. Next week, Microsoft plans to file an amicus brief to back the company. Verizon has also come out in support of Apple. "We support the availability of strong encryption with no backdoors," Verizon CEO and chairman Lowell McAdam said in a statement.

Note: Due to the political nature of the discussion regarding this topic, the discussion thread is located in our Politics, Religion, Social Issues forum. All forum members and site visitors are welcome to read and follow the thread, but posting is limited to forum members with at least 100 posts.

Tag: Apple-FBI


Top Rated Comments

(View all)

18 weeks ago
This will be about who can scare the people more.

FBI: Terrrrrorrrrrists are coming to keeeeel you and we need backdoors to find them.
Apple: Terrrrrorrrrrists are coming to keeeeel you once they find FBI backdoors to track you.
FBI: shut up
Apple: No you shut up.
FBI: I said it first
Apple: We said it to infinity

:eek:
Rating: 16 Votes
18 weeks ago

175 iPhones?! So Apple were right, this wouldn't be a one off rogue version of iOS that was used on one phone.

First it was 1 ... then 12 ... now 175. The FBI are looking like a bunch of ass hats right now ... not that they weren't before ... but this is ridiculous.
Rating: 14 Votes
18 weeks ago
FBI: just oooone phone pleease
FBI: Just 12 phones, come one, that's not a lot
FBI: Really? Is 175 phones that big of a concern to you?
FBI: Wow, this country is a bunch of terrorists, not letting us unluck 1,920 phones.
FBI: Dude, 20,000 phones? That's like nothing.
FBI: 240,000 phones we have to unlock, and Apple won't even let us unlock one? Those terrorists.
FBI: 2.8 million phones from innocent pe- I mean terrorists we have to fix. This country truly is corrupted. DONALD TRUMP FOR PRESIDENT 2016!!! MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN AND BOYCOTT APPLE!!!
Rating: 12 Votes
18 weeks ago
Remember that Microsoft software from like 10 years ago that let's the FBI hack into any computer? Then a hacker stole it and it got passed around on torrent sites? Yeah, it's like that.

Google Microsoft Windows back door and look at all of the hits that come up. And people wonder why Windows needs anti-virus software.
Rating: 11 Votes
18 weeks ago
This remains the single best point of logic I've read on MacRumor in many a year.

If I was a defense attorney representing a person accused of wrongdoing, and this type of "back door" iPhone data was being used by the prosecutor, I would ask in discovery for a detailed, exacting description of how The information was obtained by Apple. I would probably want to do a discovery deposition of each of the technicians that were involved in crafting the software that unlocked the phone. I would probably also want them to produce the code to have my own forensic experts examine it. The cat is out of the bag then
Rating: 7 Votes
18 weeks ago

First it was 1 ... then 12 ... now 175. The FBI are looking like a bunch of ass hats right now ... not that they weren't before ... but this is ridiculous.


That's 175 just in the possession of the NY DA's office. What about the rest of the country? Between DA's, Police, Sheriff, FBI, etc, there are probably thousands.
Rating: 7 Votes
18 weeks ago
I hope this ends up being productive, but I kind of doubt it will be. We have some pretty dense lawmakers.
Rating: 6 Votes
18 weeks ago
Sometimes I don't wake up until the coffee kicks in. I have the solution. Offer two versions of every iPhone!!! One for terrorists with the backdoor and one for the rest of us. Think Different!!!

P.S. You will have to present your Terrorist affiliation card at checkout. Sheesh, maybe I should run for congress.
Rating: 6 Votes
18 weeks ago

You did see the part where it said "congressional", you know the same group that decided to shut down the government when things didn't go their way.


You say shut down the government like it is a bad thing.
Rating: 5 Votes
18 weeks ago

We need an NRA equivalent for the 4th amendment!


God, yes we do.

Anyone who says Apple should "obey" is clearly misinformed, oblivious, fear-mongering, irrational people who do not understand the repercussions of this.

You could say, first one iPhone, then millions, then the thoughts in our brains. Well 20 years ago, no one would have thought it wold be digital, which it is, and now the Feds are wanting us to obey in the name of "National Security". Simply a joke to ANYONE who cares about their Constitutional Rights.
Rating: 4 Votes

[ Read All Comments ]