New York Bill Would Force Apple and Other Manufacturers to Decrypt Smartphones

A bill that is working its way through the New York state assembly would require Apple and other smartphone manufacturers and mobile operating system providers to decrypt and unlock devices to aid law enforcement. The bill was first spotted by On The Wire (via The Next Web).

ios9security
Any smartphone sold or leased in New York after January 1, 2016 would have to be capable of being decrypted or unlocked by its manufacturer or OS provider. If manufacturers or OS providers do not comply, they would be subject to a fine of $2,500 per device.

Assemblyman Matthew Titone introduced the bill last summer and referred it to committee on January 6. In his notes accompanying the bill, Titone justified the decryption of smartphone security by citing the safety of citizens.
“The safety of the citizenry calls for a legislative solution, and a solution is easily at hand. Enacting this bill would penalize those who would sell smart- phones that are beyond the reach of law enforcement,” the notes on the bill say.

“The fact is that, although the new software may enhance privacy for some users, it severely hampers law enforcement’s ability to aid victims. All of the evidence contained in smartphones and similar devices will be lost to law enforcement, so long as the criminals take the precaution of protecting their devices with passcodes. Of course they will do so. Simply stated, passcode-protected devices render lawful court orders meaningless and encourage criminals to act with impunity.”
The next steps for the bill would be for it to move to the floor and then be voted on in both the assembly and senate.

Tim Cook and Apple have consistently spoken out against putting backdoors in encryption technology, arguing that allowing a backdoor for "good guys" also allows "bad guys" to use it for more nefarious means. Last month, Apple criticized the proposed Investigatory Powers bill in the UK, which tracks users' website history and adds backdoors into encryption. Last week, Cook lambasted White House officials on their encryption policy, asking them to adopt a "no backdoors" approach.

Note: Due to the political nature of the discussion regarding this topic, the discussion thread is located in our Politics, Religion, Social Issues forum. All forum members and site visitors are welcome to read and follow the thread, but posting is limited to forum members with at least 100 posts.



Top Rated Comments

(View all)
Avatar
23 weeks ago
these politicians are out of their minds
Rating: 78 Votes
Avatar
23 weeks ago
I happily forfeit whatever lack of safety comes from not living in some horrible surveillance state. Yeah freedom comes with a risk - that's fine.
Rating: 45 Votes
Avatar
23 weeks ago
I hope they pay the fine and tell NY to go eff themselves. Better yet, close every Apple Store in Ny and tell the employees why they lost their jobs and who to blame.
Rating: 30 Votes
Avatar
23 weeks ago
Anyone who advocates for further government overreach can go **** themselves.
Rating: 26 Votes
Avatar
23 weeks ago

Don't they know they are only pushing me and others like me TO encryption? If Apple really has no backdoor, then NY's only recourse is to ban Apple products in the state. Can't make Apple do something that technically is not possible. I use FileVault 2, but DO NOT let Apple store my key. I DO NOT keep a copy of my key. My password is in my head.

Also, if/when I get a an iPhone in the future (still have the 5), I will NEVER use the fingerprint reader, as you can be legally compelled to offer your prints, whereas you cannot be compelled to offer a password. I don't use my stuff for anything illegal, but that's nobody's business. I go out of my way now to setup encryption.

Thanks government!

Here's a tip - if law enforcement forces you to use Touch ID, restart the phone. A passcode will be required after a restart and fingerprints won't be accepted.
Rating: 22 Votes
Avatar
23 weeks ago

will Tim stand up to his pledge for user privacy and stop selling iPhones in NY? #notbloodylikely

Profits trump pledges


Sadly, I have to agree with you. Would be amazing to see though... if they flat stopped selling them in NY. And i would bet that sales would not be impacted that much.... because the people that buy them would just cross a border and buy one elsewhere.
Rating: 22 Votes
Avatar
23 weeks ago
Assemblyman Matthew Titone needs to go **** himself. I hate arrogant, corrupt ***** politicians like him. They are destroying our country. You want to get into a criminal's encrypted phone? Waterboard the ****er, I don't care. But don't punish the rest of us for what criminals do. That makes you a moron.
Rating: 22 Votes
Avatar
23 weeks ago
**** this goddamn country with its barbaric surveillance laws. This is the United States, not Saudi Arabia god dammit. :mad:
Rating: 21 Votes
Avatar
23 weeks ago
If this passes, its bad news for our right to privacy nationwide. As soon as the first domino falls it won't be long for the other 50 (49 states and Federal) to follow.
Rating: 21 Votes
Avatar
23 weeks ago
To be clear, Democrat Rep Titone...
Rating: 20 Votes
[ Read All Comments ]