Got a tip for us? Share it...

New in OS X: Get MacRumors Push Notifications on your Mac

Resubscribe Now Close

Nearly All Mobile Device Makers Cheat on Benchmarks, Except Apple and Motorola

Following Tuesday's report that Samsung artificially inflates its benchmarking scores, well-respected hardware review site AnandTech has published evidence suggesting nearly all mobile manufacturers, with the exception of Apple and Motorola, use CPU/GPU optimizations to game benchmark tests.

Samsung and other OEMs use a variety of methods to enhance device performance when a benchmark is detected. For example, with its Galaxy S 4 Samsung raised its thermal limits (and max GPU frequency) to get an edge on certain benchmarks and also raised its CPU voltage/frequency to its highest state when a benchmark was sensed, a tactic engaged by multiple manufacturers like LG, HTC, and ASUS as well.

In the table below, Anandtech highlights devices that detect benchmarks and immediately respond with max CPU frequency.

anandtechbenchmarks
With the exception of Apple and Motorola, literally every single OEM we’ve worked with ships (or has shipped) at least one device that runs this silly CPU optimization. It’s possible that older Motorola devices might’ve done the same thing, but none of the newer devices we have on hand exhibited the behavior. It’s a systemic problem that seems to have surfaced over the last two years, and one that extends far beyond Samsung.
AnandTech notes that it’s a continual "cat and mouse" game discovering which devices have optimized for which benchmarks, because targeted benchmarks must be avoided.
The only realistic solution is to continue to evolve the suite ahead of those optimizing for it. The more attention you draw to certain benchmarks, the more likely they are to be gamed. We constantly play this game of cat and mouse on the PC side, it's just more frustrating in mobile since there aren’t many good benchmarks to begin with. […]

There's no single solution here, but rather a multi-faceted approach to make sure we’re ahead of the curve. We need to continue to rev our test suite to stay ahead of any aggressive OEM optimizations, we need to petition the OEMs to stop this madness, we need to work with the benchmark vendors to detect and disable optimizations as they happen and avoid benchmarks that are easily gamed.
Despite all of the effort that OEMs put into benchmark optimizations, the gains are negligible. The impact on CPU tests revealed a 0 to 5 percent performance increase, and a less than 10 percent increase on GPU benchmarks.

Top Rated Comments

(View all)

13 months ago
Guy 1: My phone is faster than your phone!

Guy 2: I have a girlfriend.
Rating: 132 Votes
13 months ago
Mad respect to Anandtech for making this chart. I love the title of the table :D

Props to Apple and Motorola for not being so cheap.
Rating: 53 Votes
13 months ago
"I can't believe I have to make this table"

Hah!
Rating: 47 Votes
13 months ago
Im Sorry but Samsung got Ys across the board. They are also the only one on that table cheating Geekbench which is one of the most popular benchmarking apps used.
Rating: 25 Votes
13 months ago
And this is why Android phones have been able to claim great performance via benchmarks and specs while iPhones have performed just as well or better in practice. I remember folks telling me that the Galaxy S2 performed better than my iPhone 3GS according to benchmarks, but in practice (side-by-side) my iPhone 3GS seemed to be twice as fast with no stutter on tasks that seemed to stutter and lag on the GS2.
Rating: 25 Votes
13 months ago
This week's lesson: don't buy Samsung
Rating: 21 Votes
13 months ago
So only apple and google are playing it fair...
Rating: 16 Votes
13 months ago
I'm glad this has been published. A little reassurance on which company is the bigger scumbag.
Rating: 14 Votes
13 months ago
This speaks volumes about Samsung's business sense and ethics...

Oh, wait, they are perfect and poop gold nuggets... :rolleyes:
Rating: 13 Votes
13 months ago
All they do in Korea is copy everything. I love Koreans but they don't innovate in any business. When you go there all you see is fake Nikes, Adidas, cheap suits, faux leather, faux wood, faux gold, faux everything. It should be expected that they cheat in benchmark tests.
Rating: 12 Votes

[ Read All Comments ]