macOS 27 Golden Gate Reverses a Divisive Tahoe Design Choice - MacRumors
Skip to Content

macOS 27 Golden Gate Reverses a Divisive Tahoe Design Choice

In macOS 27 Golden Gate, Apple has removed many of the menu item icons that are so prevalent throughout macOS 26 Tahoe, as spotted by Nikita "Tonsky" Prokopov (via Daring Fireball). The developer shared before-and-after screenshots on Mastodon to evidence the reversal.

macos 27 vs macos 26 menu item icons%402x scaled

Menu item icons in macOS 26 (left) vs. macOS 27 (image: Nikita Prokopov)

Tahoe was the first version of macOS to place a small icon next to nearly every entry in the menu bar across Apple's apps, but the change drew swift criticism from designers and developers. Many of the icons are inconsistent and often difficult to understand on their own, with different Apple apps showing different icons for the same menu items.

The third-party developer pushback was strong enough that some even adopted open-source code provided by NetNewsWire's Brent Simmons to switch the icons off by default.

In Golden Gate though, they're gone – or only used where genuinely useful. Apple has also revised its Human Interface Guidelines to tell developers to use menu item icons "sparingly and with purpose," reserving them for common actions, file system locations, connected devices, and similar cases.

macOS 27 is currently in developer beta, with a public beta to arrive next month, followed by a general release in the fall.

Related Roundups: macOS Tahoe, macOS Golden Gate
Related Forum: macOS Tahoe

Popular Stories

macOS 27 next to MacBook Pro Running macOS 27

Apple Releases macOS Golden Gate Beta 8

Monday August 31, 2026 10:14 am PDT by
Apple today provided developers with the eighth beta of macOS Golden Gate, with the update coming a week after Apple seeded the seventh beta. Developers can download macOS Golden Gate by going to System Settings > General > Software Update. Beta Updates will need to be enabled, and a free developer account is required. macOS Golden Gate includes multiple design improvements. Liquid Glass...
macOS Golden Gate HDR

macOS Golden Gate Seems to Hint at MacBook Pro With OLED Display

Tuesday September 1, 2026 12:34 pm PDT by
As noted by Broadcasts developer Steven Troughton-Smith, many Liquid Glass interface elements on the macOS Golden Gate beta have an even glassier appearance on certain high-end OLED displays with HDR support than they do on ordinary displays. Apple reportedly plans to release new MacBook Pro or "MacBook Ultra" models with an OLED display by early 2027, so it is likely that macOS Golden Gate...
iOS 26 6 1 iPhone

Apple Releases iOS 26.6.1, macOS 26.6.2, and More

Monday August 17, 2026 10:52 am PDT by
Apple today released iOS 26.6.1, iPadOS 26.6.1, visionOS 26.6.1, and macOS 26.6.2, with all of the updates containing security fixes. Apple also released iOS 18.7.10 and iPadOS 18.7.10 with security fixes. All of the iOS and iPadOS updates released today deliver security fixes that were first made available in the iOS 27 and iPadOS 27 betas, according to an Apple support document, which...

Top Rated Comments

Divxz Avatar
12 weeks ago
I didn't know this was controversial. I liked them.
Score: 55 Votes (Like | Disagree)
12 weeks ago
Shame on whoever started this in the first place. Hope they got scolded at Apple
Score: 32 Votes (Like | Disagree)
12 weeks ago
Relevant article that further explains the poor and confusing icon design decisions in macOS:

https://tonsky.me/blog/tahoe-icons/
Score: 30 Votes (Like | Disagree)
dmr727 Avatar
12 weeks ago
I really love that they reversed this - the whole point of the icon was to make it easier to quickly identify commonly used menu items. This went back to the earliest days of the Mac. As the saying goes, if everything is special, nothing is special. :)
Score: 25 Votes (Like | Disagree)
capamac Avatar
12 weeks ago
When I look at the line of icons on the left, I couldn't tell you what most of them mean. These icons are meaningless symbols to me. But I can tell you what the word to the right of the icon means. Removing the icons was the right decision.
Score: 23 Votes (Like | Disagree)
12 weeks ago
Tahoe really will go down as the worst designed Mac OS ever. its truly shocking the amount of inconsistencies and ways it fundamentally breaks Apples own design criteria. I'm really suprised how these elements of the design were signed off

So glad I skipped it.
Score: 22 Votes (Like | Disagree)