New in OS X: Get MacRumors Push Notifications on your Mac

Resubscribe Now Close

Tim Cook and Samsung CEO to Discuss Patent Dispute One Last Time Today Ahead of Jury Deliberations

With Apple and Samsung having concluded their presentations for the jury in the high-profile U.S. court case over patent and design issues, Bloomberg reports that Apple CEO Tim Cook and Samsung CEO Kwon Oh Hyun will talk one last time in an effort to settle or at least narrow their differences before jury deliberations begin as soon as tomorrow.
The companies’ lawyers will report to U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh in federal court in San Jose, California, on the outcome of today’s telephone discussion between Apple’s Tim Cook and Samsung’s Kwon Oh Hyun, according to the person, who asked not to be identified because the talks are private. [...]

As testimony in the trial drew to a close, Koh asked that the CEOs talk, and said she was “pathologically optimistic” they could settle claims over patents for smartphones and tablet computers.

Senior executives of the two companies met several times leading up to the trial and were unable to reach an agreement, but Samsung is now operating under new CEO Kwon, who was elevated to the position in early June as part of an executive reshuffling.

Apple estimates that it should be owed roughly $2.5 billion in damages based on sales of Samsung devices it claims infringed upon Apple's patents and trade dress, while Samsung claims that Apple owes approximately $400 million in licensing fees for 3G-related patents based on a royalty rate of 2.4% per unit sold. Apple has claimed that the licensing fees for the standards-essential patents should be significantly lower.

Top Rated Comments

(View all)

29 months ago


There are only so many ways to design a four sided object with a touch screen interface.


You are right. There aren't many ways to design a touch screen.


or an icon






or a charger





or a tablet case




or a cable




or a minicomputer


or dress code

Rating: 20 Votes
29 months ago
Though I support Apple, I don't mind the imitations and copy-cats that put competitive pressure for Apple to step up its game each year.
Rating: 20 Votes
29 months ago
Samsung CEO not good enough to get his name in the title :p
Rating: 12 Votes
29 months ago

Though I support Apple, I don't mind the imitations and copy-cats that put competitive pressure for Apple to step up its game each year.


but if the competition came up with their own stuff, it would push Apple to do even better.

Apple makes X, Samsung makes X, Apple makes X+1, Samsung makes X+1
vs
Apple makes X, Samsung makes X+1, Apple makes X+2, Samsung makes X+3

the rate of innovation is much slower when all the competition does is copy.
Rating: 11 Votes
29 months ago
Bold prediction: Nothing will come of this meeting. :rolleyes:
Rating: 10 Votes
29 months ago
I still say I hope Apple puts the screws to Samsung and if Apple stole any technological ideas from other companies, that they be screwed too by having to pay royalties.

You have to protect your innovation period.

It doesn't matter the size of the company or not. If you invent something that someone else copies, then protect it. Failure to do so fails your investors, shareholders and yourself. It doesn't matter if Apple is selling 10:1 (pure example) or 10:9 iPhones to Galaxies or tablets or whatever. Protect it.

A similar example is a local company here in Ottawa. They make adult toys which are popular. Almost reaching $100 million in sales. Now other companies are copying it so they're going after those folks. Why? Well duh, because any other copy has the potential to take away sales.

http://www.ottawacitizen.com/business/industry+Ottawa+latest+sector/7108256/story.html

I'll repeat so it doesn't look like I'm the fanboi - if Apple is guilty of stealing ideas/technology then companies should go after them too.

Yes, competition is a great thing, but invent your own and challenge....don't be a copycat by directly copying something. Shows your nothing but a cheap company imho.

Cheers,
Keebler
Rating: 9 Votes
29 months ago

:apple: is trying to destroy healthy competition


Samsung(or any other company) shouldn't be copying.
Rating: 8 Votes
29 months ago

Wish we could watch the meeting.


Samsung: Seems you were right all along, Mr Cook.

Apple: Ha. Didn't I tell y'all that the free publicity would be priceless?

Samsung: It's amazing! Both our smartphone sales have gone out of sight!

Apple: Here's a check for the two billion dollars, btw. Give it back when you lose.

Samsung: Thanks, buddy! So what's next on our agenda?

Apple: I think we're going to add Wacom pen support to the iPad. This time you complain, and we'll play innocent.

Samsung: Brilliant!

Apple: Hey, that's why I'm CEO!
Rating: 8 Votes
29 months ago

I look at Android and see buggy garbage. Android will not be able to hold a candle to the most anticipated phone of the year (iPhone5) or iPad.

*Eagerly waiting for iPhone 5 release*

:apple:


Yeah. I see both OSes and see bugs, quirks, great features and great UI fails.

Oh - "one last thing" - Android is an OS. the iPhone and iPad are devices. So saying that Android can't hold a candle to one or the other is ignorant.
Rating: 8 Votes
29 months ago

After the judge said that Apple's lawyers must have been smoking crack if they thought she would allow one of their latest stalling tactics.

This isn't as clean cut as either side is making out.

There are only so many ways to design a four sided object with a touch screen interface. Why aren't they going after all the other manufacturers that have 'stolen' the idea?


Perhaps it's not as simple as you make it out to be? Anyone who thinks this trial is about rounded rectangles is obviously drinking the Samsung kool-aid.
Rating: 7 Votes

[ Read All Comments ]