Shanghai Court Denies Injunction Against iPad Sales in Proview Trademark Dispute - MacRumors
Skip to Content

Shanghai Court Denies Injunction Against iPad Sales in Proview Trademark Dispute

proview logoReuters reports that a Shanghai court has declined to issue an injunction that would have barred sales of Apple's iPad in the city, a ruling that is part of the dispute between Apple and Proview Technology over the trademark on the iPad name.

Early reports had painted the decision as a significant victory for Apple, but while the company is no doubt pleased that the judge in the case did not find sufficient cause to halt iPad sales at this time, it appears to mainly be a procedural ruling to put off further proceedings until a decision is reached in a related case in Guangdong province. Apple lost an initial case there and is currently appealing that decision.

The Shanghai Pudong New Area People's Court denied a request by Proview Technology (Shenzhen) for the injunction and agreed to Apple's request that the trademark infringement case be suspended pending a ruling in a separate case in a higher court.

The decision, announced on Thursday on the court's website, gives Apple some leeway in a larger battle over the iPad trademark in China, which is important to Apple not only as a consumer market, but also because the country is a major production base for the iPad and other of its products.

Proview has won several small victories against Apple in cities around China, but a ruling against Apple in Shanghai would have been by far the most significant given the city's size and Apple's presence there with three of its own retail stores.

Related Roundup: iPad
Buyer's Guide: iPad (Don't Buy)
Related Forum: iPad

Popular Stories

iPhone Ultra Fold Feature

Foldable 'iPhone Ultra' May Launch Later in China, Says Leaker

Tuesday September 8, 2026 4:46 am PDT by
Apple's foldable "iPhone Ultra" may launch in mainland China later than in some other markets, according to an oft-reliable Chinese leaker. Posting on the Weibo social media platform, Instant Digital said that Apple has a limited initial inventory for its first foldable device, and the rollout could be shaped by regional allocation. The claim follows a recent report out of Japan...
iOS 18 Siri Personal Context

Siri AI Settlement Website Now Live: Apple to Pay Some iPhone Owners

Sunday September 20, 2026 7:24 pm PDT by
In May, Apple agreed to pay $250 million to settle a U.S. class action lawsuit over Siri AI's delayed launch, and the settlement website is now live. Apple will pay an estimated $25 per eligible iPhone to eligible customers, who can submit a claim via the settlement website between September 21 and December 21 of this year. The exact payment may be higher or lower than $25 depending on the...
Mostly Screen iPhone Purple Feature 2027

iPhone 20 Pro Display Sizes Leak Ahead of 2027 Launch

Monday September 21, 2026 4:29 am PDT by
Apple's 20th-anniversary iPhone lineup could feature slightly larger displays than the iPhone 18 Pro models, if a new leak shared on Weibo is accurate. Prolific Chinese leaker Digital Chat Station claims that early iPhone 20 Pro display specifications include a 6.41-inch screen with a resolution of approximately 2,686 × 1,236 pixels, while the iPhone 20 Pro Max is said to have a 6.96-inch...

Top Rated Comments

CylonGlitch Avatar
190 months ago
But this one doesn't appear to be legit. Proview appears to have seller's remorse on the original deal when they sold the trademark and having severe financial problems, simply sees a big payday. Personally, I'd bet that if Apple offered them $1 million to settle, they'd take it...maybe even less, but that would set a bad precedent for Apple and make them a target for other lawsuits.

Just to be clear; here is a quick summary of what transpired.

1. Dec 2009 : B&M (Apple's Shell) buys iPad trademark from Proview.Taiwan from Chairman Mr. Yang (who is also Chairman of Proview.China, and YOKE). The trademark is for Taiwan, HongKong and China. (VERY clearly defined).

2. Jan 2010 : Apple announces iPad

3. Feb 2010 : Proview.China claims they never sold the Trademark (Proview.Taiwan had no rights to sell it -- Although Mr. Yang their Chairman signed off the papers). Now demand $10,000,000 from Apple.

4. March 2010 : Apples says, no, we purchased it clearly.

5. April 2010 : Proview.China files bankruptcy.

6. Apple has been fighting since then to get the trademark they paid for.
Score: 13 Votes (Like | Disagree)
CylonGlitch Avatar
190 months ago
Something is telling me that the world of hurt is just starting for Proview.
Score: 7 Votes (Like | Disagree)
190 months ago
These guys are ridiculous. Trying to get paid for something they had nothing to do with because of a trademark. Maybe they should go and actually produce a worthwhile product to make money...like a normal business.

There's nothing wrong with a trademark lawsuit when they're legit. And Apple has seemed a bit arrogant in this space. Just because Apple is large and everyone wants an iPad doesn't necessarily make them right.

But this one doesn't appear to be legit. Proview appears to have seller's remorse on the original deal when they sold the trademark and having severe financial problems, simply sees a big payday. Personally, I'd bet that if Apple offered them $1 million to settle, they'd take it...maybe even less, but that would set a bad precedent for Apple and make them a target for other lawsuits.
Score: 6 Votes (Like | Disagree)
*LTD* Avatar
190 months ago
Boom.

Sweep these ridiculous small fry out of Apple's way already. People want iPads, tyvm. There was even an admission by the gov't or another body earlier that a sales ban on iPads would not play well with the public.
Score: 6 Votes (Like | Disagree)
BobbyRond Avatar
190 months ago
Now to sue for the iMac rip-off. :cool:
Score: 5 Votes (Like | Disagree)
190 months ago
Pointless

Far too many tech companies are waging patent and trademark wars rather than actually creating good products.

And here we have Proview. If they actually had a product that had world-wide recognition, or even decent market penetration in their home territory, then they would have a point. But no. Instead they are trying to get rich by playing legal games instead. I saw a poster on here of a supposed Proview product, but it looked like it had been released in the 80's and not something any sane person would ever buy. Did it ever actually exist?

Organisations like Proview who appear to be just looking for a free ride need to have their asses kicked by the courts as they add nothing to society. By the same token we need to stop organisations hoarding patents just because they can, and then suing anyone who has an idea that is remotely similar even though they had no intention/inclination to bring the stuff to market. Patents have a place in the development process, but they should also have a fairly short shelf life.
Score: 4 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Latest Stories
Apple Releases First Public Betas of iOS 27.2 and macOS Golden Gate 27.2
Apple Releases First Public Betas of iOS 27.2 and macOS Golden Gate 27.2
3 hours ago
OpenAI's New GPT-6 Sol and Luna Models Bring Astra Improvements to Cheaper Tiers
OpenAI's New GPT-6 Sol and Luna Models Bring Astra Improvements to Cheaper Tiers
6 hours ago
Apple Park Visitor Center Just Lost an Attraction Offered Since 2017
Apple Park Visitor Center Just Lost an Attraction Offered Since 2017
7 hours ago
Shazam App for iPhone Updated With New Icon and iMessage Stickers
Shazam App for iPhone Updated With New Icon and iMessage Stickers
7 hours ago
Anthropic Launches Claude Opus 5.5 With Fable-Level Performance at a Lower Price
Anthropic Launches Claude Opus 5.5 With Fable-Level Performance at a Lower Price
7 hours ago
Apple Releases Firmware Update for Beats 360
Apple Releases Firmware Update for Beats 360
9 hours ago
Beats 360 Pre-Orders Open at Amazon With Cushion Kits on Sale, Plus More Beats Deals
Beats 360 Pre-Orders Open at Amazon With Cushion Kits on Sale, Plus More Beats Deals
9 hours ago
Apple Puts AirTag-Sized AI Pin on Hold
Apple Puts AirTag-Sized AI Pin on Hold
9 hours ago
Beats 360 Ear Cushion Kits Just $9.99 Each Until the End of October
Beats 360 Ear Cushion Kits Just $9.99 Each Until the End of October
10 hours ago
Apple Testing Prototypes of Whoop-Like Screenless Fitness Band
Apple Testing Prototypes of Whoop-Like Screenless Fitness Band
10 hours ago
Apple Will Soon Announce an All-New Operating System
Apple Will Soon Announce an All-New Operating System
10 hours ago
Apple Watch Series 10 vs. Series 12 Buyer's Guide: Should You Upgrade?
Apple Watch Series 10 vs. Series 12 Buyer's Guide: Should You Upgrade?
11 hours ago
Apple's Smart Glasses to Enter a Rapidly Growing Market
Apple's Smart Glasses to Enter a Rapidly Growing Market
11 hours ago
Apple Event This October? These 7 New Products Expected Next Month
Apple Event This October? These 7 New Products Expected Next Month
11 hours ago
Beats 360 Deliver Customizability and a Revamped Over-Ear Headphone Design
Beats 360 Deliver Customizability and a Revamped Over-Ear Headphone Design
13 hours ago
Massive Discounts Hit 2026 MacBook Pro, Save Up to $600 on Amazon
Massive Discounts Hit 2026 MacBook Pro, Save Up to $600 on Amazon
13 hours ago
Apple Planning to Bring iPhone Duo Display Tech to Pro in 2029
Apple Planning to Bring iPhone Duo Display Tech to Pro in 2029
13 hours ago
Apple Announces 'Tap to Pay on iPhone' Availability in 8 More Countries
Apple Announces 'Tap to Pay on iPhone' Availability in 8 More Countries
13 hours ago
New Mac Mini and Mac Studio Now Available for Same-Day Pickup at Apple Stores
New Mac Mini and Mac Studio Now Available for Same-Day Pickup at Apple Stores
15 hours ago
Apple Still Working on Anti-Snatching Feature That Locks Stolen iPhones
Apple Still Working on Anti-Snatching Feature That Locks Stolen iPhones
15 hours ago
Apple Quietly Excludes Older iPhones From New Camera Feature
Apple Quietly Excludes Older iPhones From New Camera Feature
16 hours ago
App Switcher Returns in watchOS 27.2 Beta With New Launch Gesture
App Switcher Returns in watchOS 27.2 Beta With New Launch Gesture
18 hours ago
Apple Music Hall Spatial Audio Venue Opens in Battersea Power Station
Apple Music Hall Spatial Audio Venue Opens in Battersea Power Station
19 hours ago
Apple CEO John Ternus Talks iPhone Duo Design, Siri AI, and Becoming CEO
Apple CEO John Ternus Talks iPhone Duo Design, Siri AI, and Becoming CEO
1 day ago
You Can No Longer Downgrade From iOS 27 to iOS 26
You Can No Longer Downgrade From iOS 27 to iOS 26
1 day ago
macOS 27.2 Beta Brings New Volume and Brightness Sliders
macOS 27.2 Beta Brings New Volume and Brightness Sliders
1 day ago
GM Wants You to Know It Still Plans to Ditch Apple CarPlay in Future EVs
GM Wants You to Know It Still Plans to Ditch Apple CarPlay in Future EVs
1 day ago
iPhone 14 Pro vs. iPhone 18 Pro Buyer's Guide: Should You Upgrade?
iPhone 14 Pro vs. iPhone 18 Pro Buyer's Guide: Should You Upgrade?
1 day ago
Apple Seeds Second macOS Golden Gate 27.2 Beta to Developers
Apple Seeds Second macOS Golden Gate 27.2 Beta to Developers
1 day ago
Apple Releases Second iOS 27.2 Beta
Apple Releases Second iOS 27.2 Beta
1 day ago