Got a tip for us? Share it...

Six Months Later: 'iTunes LP' Format Performance Remains Lackluster


GigaOM provides an interesting reexamination of Apple's "iTunes LP" format for enhanced album content six months after the format's debut. While iTunes LPs were touted at its launch as a means to reignite sales of albums as opposed to individual tracks, Apple has done very little promotion of the format in recent months and currently offers only 31 iTunes LP albums (plus three comic book/single packages using the format) in its U.S. iTunes Store.

Reports leading up to launch of iTunes LP, previously codenamed "Cocktail", had suggested that the idea had been put forward by the record labels but was rejected by Apple until the labels banded together to begin developing their own similar format. GigaOM's report yesterday offers a similar perspective on those developments, which offers an explanation for Apple's lack of promotion of the format.

But I'm told by an industry source who preferred to remain anonymous that iTunes LP wasn't Apple's idea in the first place. Rather, it's the result of the same renegotiations between Apple and the major record labels that yielded DRM-free songs and flexible pricing early last year, a concession by Cupertino to make a gesture in favor of album sales as consumers increasingly show a preference for digital singles.

According to the report, Apple even subsidized the initial iTunes LP productions at a cost of up to $60,000 each, presumably as a gesture to placate the record labels. Record labels are understandably reluctant to foot the bill for new releases at that price, despite the fact that Apple's initial promotion of the format did allow the releases to become profitable.

Apple claimed last October that it would be opening up the format to additional labels and did publish tools to assist developers in creating iTunes LP projects relatively soon after. But while developers are likely to be able to put together such releases at a cost significantly below that invested by Apple in the initial launches, few have yet to express interest in the format.

As the report notes, many artists have chosen to take advantage of Apple's App Store to offer enhanced content, but Apple's iPad may provide another opportunity for the iTunes LP format to gain some traction. For its part though, Apple has yet to tout the potential of the iPad for iTunes LP content, and artists and labels have yet to become excited by the possibilities available in that combination.

Top Rated Comments

(View all)

25 months ago
Not entirely surprised. If Apple didn't want to do it in the first place, then they will just sit on it. Too bad though. That is the one advantage to buying a cd is the album booklet you get. The fact that you don't really see it integrated with the Apple TV to me shows what Apple thinks
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
25 months ago
They should've added a "get up and turn to side 2" mode. :-D
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
25 months ago
Just the mp3 people, just the mp3. Keep it simple.
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
25 months ago
If they gave users the ability to roll their own using an easy WYSIWYG interface, this might take off. I could see this really taking off in the education market, where whole classes could be made into an LP.

Some pundits have suggested adapting iDVD to make them. Sounds good to me.
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
25 months ago

Not entirely surprised. If Apple didn't want to do it in the first place, then they will just sit on it. Too bad though. That is the one advantage to buying a cd is the album booklet you get. The fact that you don't really see it integrated with the Apple TV to me shows what Apple thinks


the other advantage is that some of like our higher quality music and like to rip it in lossless formats. Can't get great audio quality out of itunes
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
25 months ago
Of course it's not popular. Everyone lost the cd cases with the booklet anyway. These LPs are attempting to take the convenient out of digital music.
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
25 months ago
It was destined to be a fairly low-key product from the start. One reason people loved iTunes from the start was the ability to buy single tracks and not have to purchase an entire CD. Some hard-core music lovers need to have the album extras, photographs, lyrics, etc. However, the vast majority of people I think just want to be able to "have that cool song they heard on the radio."
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
25 months ago
I've never seen anyone with iTunes LP, including myself. If they want to make it more useful, put it on the iPad with more features. Seems like a better experience. Right now it's kinda lame.
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
25 months ago
I looked at an iTunes LP and even bought one. However what it offers is boring it is nothing better than a DVD Menu with some animation and connects to only the content that you see when you download it Music, Videos. And it is way overpriced. What about some real specials etc? If you look at a CD you can at least see what is on that special second disk in the case .... not on iTunes and again it is overpriced. In general I think that the pricing structure for US$1.29 for a single song is way too high (and don't tell me that there was a plan to have US$0.69 Songs out there I can't seem to find them ...)

Maybe the Labels are going to offer some real content and start to play with this format a little bit more...
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
25 months ago

I looked at an iTunes LP and even bought one. However what it offers is boring it is nothing better than a DVD Menu with some animation and connects to only the content that you see when you download it Music, Videos. And it is way overpriced. What about some real specials etc? If you look at a CD you can at least see what is on that special second disk in the case .... not on iTunes and again it is overpriced. In general I think that the pricing structure for US$1.29 for a single song is way too high (and don't tell me that there was a plan to have US$0.69 Songs out there I can't seem to find them ...)

Maybe the Labels are going to offer some real content and start to play with this format a little bit more...


I hate the $1.29 songs. So I just headed over to Amazon, got the same exact DRM-Free $1.29 songs for $0.99.

iTunes appeals to people who actually are so into a band that they would pay 30-40% more for an album. All those bonus videos can be found on YouTube and over 'cool' things aren't exciting. Plus, God forbid I would buy an iTunes LP and watch one of the videos on my flatscreen...the only way for that is using another Apple product to watch it.
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives

[ Read All Comments ]