Got a tip for us? Share it...

Lack of 3G a Deal Breaker... No, Not Talking about iPhone

After talking to others about the MacBook Air yesterday, one common theme seems to be appearing... the lack of mobile broadband (3G) is a deal breaker for many.

As I told many people yesterday... if the MacBook Air had included any sort of 3G internet connection, I would have bought one instantly. No questions asked. I probably would have loaded up on SSD Flash as well, knowing it would be my primary mobile device. But with the lack of 3G, I see no compelling reason to move off from my MacBook, which also has a 3G USB dongle hanging off its side.

Perhaps this is a skewed view of the world at the Macworld Expo, where there's a high concentration of power-users and bloggers, but it's a practical consideration for a product that is supposed to be an "ultra" mobile device.

In the days leading up to the event, it was clear that Apple was coming out with a super thin MacBook... but the lack of reliable 3G/WiMax rumors concerned me. In the days before I had hoped the "Air" name would refer to more than just the lightness of the device.

Some have suggested that Apple will be heading down this path later this year, though that would certainly annoy some of the early adopters of the MacBook Air. There are plans in place by Intel to start launching WiMax chipsets around mid year. The iPhone itself is rumored to be getting 3G towards the middle of the year.

As it is, I'm not alone in my disappointment.

Top Rated Comments

(View all)

53 months ago
What kind of track record does Apple have with any WiMax providers?
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
53 months ago
I think there's a USB to Expresscard adapter. Then you can plug in your 3G card, right? I mean, sure, that's kind of annoying. But it's still possible. Don't fret! :)
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
53 months ago
I was pretty disappointed. No ethernet/no 3G with at&t... just seemed odd. Jobs must have a minion to haul the laptop with the 3G dongle, and the cord around.
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
53 months ago
I'm not sure. There was no reliable information leading up to the release that indicated the Air would include anything like 3G or WiMax...just the reactions of forum posters to the "There's something in the air" posters and their guesses about what it could mean. I think something that big would have been leaked quicker than stuff like the external drive was being such a big feature, so I don't really see a reasonable expectation for it. Certainly it would be nice for some potential buyers, but that could be said about a lot of features.

I wouldn't be someone to see the use in it anyways since my whole campus is wired for 802.1x-authed wireless and ethernet ports abound, not to mention that 3G is non-existant here.
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
53 months ago
It may be a piece of crap otherwise, but I think the Kindle has set a new expectation for what wireless connectivity really means.
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
53 months ago

I think there's a USB to Expresscard adapter. Then you can plug in your 3G card, right? I mean, sure, that's kind of annoying. But it's still possible. Don't fret! :)


I think the point is that he is already using a dongle workaround with a MBP; Since the MBA doesn't solve this problem, there is no point in getting an MBA.
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
53 months ago
Two comments:

1. MacBook Air should be thought of as an equivalent to the original iMac. This is a simple, sleek machine that's not really meant for power users.

2. I learned from Apple long ago not to buy their first generation products. The features and capabilities that get added on the first upgrade are worth the wait.
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
53 months ago

It may be a piece of crap otherwise, but I think the Kindle has set a new expectation for what wireless connectivity really means.


Absolutely, I dont own one, but the Kindle's feature of always connected is amazing. Every laptop should have this feature.
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
53 months ago
...conference room full of bloggers finds something to complain about. Details at 11.
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives
53 months ago
Of course that would all be solved if Apple would let the iPhone work as a modem in tandem with their laptops, which they oddly allow other phones to do (the main reason I have not jumped on the iPhone bandwagon.) These days at Apple, bottom line decisions are taking over consumer benefit decisions way too often for my taste.
Rating: 0 Positives / 0 Negatives

[ Read All Comments ]