Apple Explores Detecting User Behavior Patterns to Enhance Device Security

Thursday July 17, 2014 7:49 AM PDT by Kelly Hodgkins
touch_id_iconThe United States Patent and Trademark Office today published an Apple patent application (via AppleInsider) describing methods for detecting the behavior of the person who is currently using the device and comparing them to past patterns. While the January 2013 patent application, "Generating Notifications Based on User Behavior", speaks relatively generically about such notifications, the invention's utility in providing device security seems clear.

This security method goes beyond the standard PIN-based security by examining cues such as grammar and vocabulary usage, motion sensor data, and gesture input to identify a user. Any changes from the recorded pattern of usage will send an alert that a new person is in control of the phone.

The phone then can either request that the person enter a password or Touch ID scan to confirm their identity or send a notification to a third-party service that alerts the original owner that their phone may be compromised.
A method for determining behavior associated with a user device, comprising: receiving behavior data identifying multiple types of user interaction with the user device; comparing the behavior data with patterns of behavior data associated with the user device, wherein the behavior-data patterns are generated from previously-received behavior data of an original user; determining a current user is potentially different from the original user based on the comparison of the behavior data with the patterns; and transmitting a command to the user device to lock the user device until the current user is verified as the original user.
Apple may be exploring this technology in response to increasing civil pressure to provide advanced security measures for its iOS devices. In the United States, a growing number of politicians, district attorneys and law enforcement officials on both the local and federal levels are asking mobile phone manufacturers to build a kill-switch feature that dissuades theft into their devices. While federal legislation makes it way through Congress, Minnesota earlier this year became the first state to require a kill switch in a mobile phone.

Top Rated Comments

(View all)

Posted: 14 weeks ago
Dad: I need to google something real quick and make a call. I left my phone in the car

Me: *hands phone to dad*

Siri: You type like an old man. Scan your thumb to verify your identity.

Me: *scans thumb and hands back phone*

Siri: You made an unusual search for "golf clubs". Scan your thumb to verify your identity.

Me: *scans thumb again*

Siri: You pinch to zoom like a noob and your posture has changed. Scan your thumb to verify your identity.

Me: Dad, just go get your iPhone.

…later that day, alone at home with my iPhone…

Siri: Your typing is much improved. Scan your thumb to verify your identity.

----------------------

Being chased by a murderer…

Me: *dialing 911*

Siri: You're trembling and typing erratically. Scan your thumb to verify your identity.

Me: *scans thumb*

Siri: Your thumb placement was unusual and your thumb very moist. Please scan your thumb again to verify your identity.

/dead lol
Rating: 11 Votes
Posted: 14 weeks ago

Hah, knew this comment would be here.

Gotta love the double standard


Not really a double standard, as the two companies have very different business models. Google makes its money off your personal profile. Apple makes its money off, well, your money.

Why is this so hard to understand? I trust Apple more with my personal details simply because they have no core business reason to abuse them. Google (and Facebook, etc.) do, and so I am more wary of what I give them. Perfectly rational.
Rating: 4 Votes
Posted: 14 weeks ago
How about Apple increases security by requiring more than just my passcode to view my saved password database? It's the same on OS X. I want to use a very long secure passphrase for it, but there's no way to do that with iCloud's keychain.

Could be a pain for families who share devices - unless we're going to see user profiles? Though I doubt it as I think Apple would much prefer everyone to buy their own device


Then your pattern would be what the family does. If someone outside your family started using it and it was widely different to the pattern your family does, it'll flag up.
Rating: 2 Votes
Posted: 14 weeks ago
Sure, it sounds kinda creepy, but I'd rather Apple have this patent than Google.
Rating: 2 Votes
Posted: 14 weeks ago
Is there a "down vote" button hidden somewhere? I see a lot of posts here are in the negatives...
Rating: 2 Votes
Posted: 14 weeks ago

How about Apple increases security by requiring more than just my passcode to view my saved password database? It's the same on OS X. I want to use a very long secure passphrase for it, but there's no way to do that with iCloud's keychain.



Then your pattern would be what the family does. If someone outside your family started using it and it was widely different to the pattern your family does, it'll flag up.


I believe the solution is obvious: use a proper password to begin with :). A good passphrase will be sufficient while also being easier to remember. This ought to help:

http://world.std.com/~reinhold/diceware.html
Rating: 1 Votes
Posted: 14 weeks ago

Then your pattern would be what the family does. If someone outside your family started using it and it was widely different to the pattern your family does, it'll flag up.


I take your point but to be honest I think any behaviour is going to sit within the spectrum of 45 year old father undergoing midlife crisis and 9 year old loomband-obsessed daughter.
Rating: 1 Votes
Posted: 14 weeks ago

Is there a "down vote" button hidden somewhere? I see a lot of posts here are in the negatives...


yeah i would love to see it come back ... i don't know how some people have it
Rating: 1 Votes
Posted: 14 weeks ago

Am I the first to think of the criminal side of things to this...I.e. Criminal mastermind is arrested, his/her cronies can remotely force a wipe/kill the device therefore completely destroying any evidence a law enforcement agency could glean from the device? Given that all iPhones supposedly encrypt everything? Probably wrong but it seems that side of things have been possibly completely overlooked?


The iPhone protects criminal masterminds from the police in exactly the same way it protect you from criminal masterminds. And there is no need for cronies to do a remote wipe. Use a strong passcode (not four digits, but ten digits or 8 random letters), set the iPhone to lock automatically after a very short time, and nobody can crack it.

For a search warrant, the police would actually need concrete evidence that evidence is stored on the phone. Saying "he's a criminal mastermind, there is surely same evidence on the phone" won't do, and the criminal mastermind's lawyer will (rightfully) tear anyone apart in court who tries something like that.

----------

Personally I don't care if a "mastermind" has his phone wiped. My data belongs to me. Besides a real wipe takes hours and hours, the iphone probably just marks the data for deletion and never overwrites it so its all still there.


Wrong. All data on any iPhone is encrypted. The encryption key is stored on the device (it is itself encrypted, obviously, and can only be encrypted by you entering the passcode). For safety in case it is accidentally destroyed, it's stored in two places. Erasing these two places is all it takes, and after that the data on the phone is not readable by anyone.
Rating: 1 Votes
Posted: 14 weeks ago

Apple makes money off of both and so does google.

I buy products from and provide data to both companies. Both companies sell ads

Both deserve suspicion IMO


Simply not true. Take Google's primary revenue generator, selling your profile away from them and they shut down in short order. Take that business segment away from Apple, and they continue to make boatloads of cash.

Also, compare what information a typical MDM software can see on an iOS device and an Android device. You will be amazed at the difference.
Rating: 1 Votes

[ Read All Comments ]